Sibm-bangalore ge/pi related discussions

@Celtics All the incorrect SNAP ids were corrected after day end ... So no worries.....

All the best for the results now 😃

@kssrisha1989 said:
The Times of India B School Ranking 2013!!!!
Amity is better than TISS, NMIMS, SIBM-P, SCMHRD etc. Seriously?
@kssrisha1989 said:
The Times of India B School Ranking 2013!!!!
Sir kaahe farzi rankings post kar rahe ho? Any child can say that these ranking are not believable...aap hi batao...Amity or IIFT-Kolkata....JBIMS, SP Jain, SIBM-Pune, MDI se aage ho gaye?

And XIMB (lol), MICA, IRMA, IMT-G....SIIB or ICFAI se bhi neeche ho gaye?

Times of India to kachra news paper hai hi....aur usne ye abhi prove bhi kar diya...aap bhi kuch bhi post kar diye...
@VijayRawat now what does Mr Ponytail has to say about this.

@VijayRawat bhai lagta hai seniors ne sibm b na naam uper dekh kar post kar di..

i was shocked ki **** ko no 1 institue nhi bataya in logo ne...:P:P..

@Sufi0469 said:

@VijayRawat bhai lagta hai seniors ne sibm b na naam uper dekh kar post kar di..

i was shocked ki **** ko no 1 institue nhi bataya in logo ne.....

i was talking abt II(P)M

To all Aspirants,

we did not make up this rankings, its TOI's.
and we posted not because SIBM,B is so high but because we were asked by a few students and parents during admissions to share survey reports.
To believe it or not is upto you guys.
Yes, it does seem a bit weird at certain places but considering it was published by India's No.1 daily, we decided to give it benefit of doubt.
Besides, we posting it seems immaterial when more than 3 crore people would have read it anyways.
I hope this answers all your Queries!

Sir,

I apologize for some harsh comments earlier...

& we all know about TOI being no1 & 3 crore readership...

but please as seniors of the college for which we r aspiring, atleast just read before posting anything...

everybody knows the fallicies in the list....& we as aspiriants expects some genuine posts from seniors...

@kssrisha1989
@Sufi0469 we do read before we post.
we posted the survey because we participated in it.
I do not know how the rest of the rankings are done, but regarding SIBM,B, there was a multi level questionaire that was sent to us regarding the college and some verifications also done about it.
As we participated, we put it up.
Besides, forget those rankings, we have been around the top 30 for the last 3 years, even by Pagalguy Rankings-and our average package shot up this year-so where do you think we would be?

Guys, please take these rankings with a pinch of salt... I know some names are always questionable..But what is more important that you (aspirants) know what you are getting for what you pay... That, can only known by talking to seniors,alumni, visiting the campus, checking the institute's overall performance etc.

Rankings are only estimates of a college's true potential as seen by the surveyors- they can never be accurate and always debatable..



So as of now, let the discussion move away from rankings and to more fruitful discussions like always 😃

@nikhilbrad that right sir....

so, can u please some light on the placements this year....

Sari baat yeh hai ki SIBM Banglore is the fastest growing B-school in INDIA...... I have noticed this in past 3 years..i m closely following that... Aur agar mera ho gaya to main to definately aunga wahan....No wonder ki uska cut off bhi high tha..Next year u can expect an even higher cutoff....3-4 saal mein itni tarakki.... wah...

Seniors..how many merit lists were released last year??

@nikhilbrad said:
Guys, please take these rankings with a pinch of salt... I know some names are always questionable..But what is more important that you (aspirants) know what you are getting for what you pay... That, can
only
known by talking to seniors,alumni, visiting the campus, checking the institute's overall performance etc.

Rankings are only estimates of a college's true potential as seen by the surveyors- they can never be accurate and always debatable..


So as of now, let the discussion move away from rankings and to more fruitful discussions like always
There are discussions egarding "Safe scores" to get the final merit call from the institutes (considering the cutoffs and break-up structure)
what do you reckon is the "safe %ile" for sibm-b merit call?

seniors and puys in ur opinion whc s better SCMHRD(MBA-IM) or SIBM-B???.i m just askng an informal personal view...

@mbaspirant0211 said:
There are discussions egarding "Safe scores" to get the final merit call from the institutes (considering the cutoffs and break-up structure) what do you reckon is the "safe %ile" for sibm-b merit call?
I don't think there is one. If someone has a 99.9 percentile but didn't perform well in the GD/PI and/or doesn't have a stellar academic record, it would substantially lower his/her chances.

40% of the weight-age depends on one's SNAP score but the rest of the 60% is up for grabs. The final result depends on one's GD/PI experience and overall profile- which is almost impossible to chart.

A 'safe score' would definitely provide momentary relief to the top percentilers but it doesn't change the fact that the entire premise of that argument is deeply flawed.
@AintSaint said:
I don't think there is one. If someone has a 99.9 percentile but didn't perform well in the GD/PI and/or doesn't have a stellar academic record, it would substantially lower his/her chances.

40% of the weight-age depends on one's SNAP score but the rest of the 60% is up for grabs. The final result depends on one's GD/PI experience and overall profile- which is almost impossible to chart.

A 'safe score' would definitely provide momentary relief to the top percentilers but it doesn't change the fact that the entire premise of that argument is deeply flawed.
well I hope you are right there then 😃
@mitchell said:
seniors and puys in ur opinion whc s better SCMHRD(MBA-IM) or SIBM-B???.i m just askng an informal personal view...
(For the nth time)- Cant compare colleges on Pagalguy ... Find out about both these colleges/courses yourself and make an informed choice 😃
@ibad786 said:
http://time4education.com/List_of_B-Schools.aspHere are the correct rankings on which everyone can believe.
Why are these correct.. Afair, these are almost the same rankings when I was a T.I.M.E student 2 years before and an year before that as well..So, you mean nothing has changed in the last 3 years?

I would say a lot has changed, for e.g.- We have arrived! And I am proud of it !


@ibad786 said:
This time new IIMs are also ranked. And I am not saying they are correct, I just want to say that these rankings doesn't look paid, these are believable. However, my aim is not to indulge in any controversies nor comparing any institutes. Its just like the topic on rankings was going on so I thought of contributing something. I apologize if my post hurts someone. Do let me know if it is to be removed.
Arre bhai why apologize ? No need to remove anything 😃

Let the discussions continue 😃