The PaGaLGuY.com Business School Rankings

[Spiderman]

Hi PG , Apurv,
One has to register at pagalguy.com before one takes the survey.For me its OK cos I am already a memeber, and have also given mail id's of friends and colleagues, but i don't think they would want to register!

One of the points I read earlier that we want all to participate including MBA alumnus and recruiters. Many may not answer when they see that they have to register n stuff.

[pagalguy]

Originally Posted by Spiderman

Hi PG , Apurv,
One has to register at pagalguy.com before one takes the survey.For me its OK cos I am already a memeber, and have also given mail id's of friends and colleagues, but i don't think they would want to register!

One of the points I read earlier that we want all to participate including MBA alumnus and recruiters. Many may not answer when they see that they have to register n stuff.

We did give it thought - but then it is also easy for people to spam the survey if there is no entry barrier. We are tracking all kinds of data including your names/emails/telephone numbers because we want an accurate ranking - which I am sure you would agree is the goal and not just putting this out in the open.

[Cool_vijay]

Just for information sake from moderators , we are the students of newly opened extension of UBS chandigarh named as UBS Ludhiana ,and we are the first batch of this institute, I want to know has ours B-school considered in this ranking. If not will it be considered next times and what are the criterion of selecting B-schools

[Apurv]

Originally Posted by Cool_vijay

Just for information sake from moderators , we are the students of newly opened extension of UBS chandigarh named as UBS Ludhiana ,and we are the first batch of this institute, I want to know has ours B-school considered in this ranking. If not will it be considered next times and what are the criterion of selecting B-schools

The b-schools were selected by the people only on this thread - http://www.pagalguy.com/forum/our-an...ngs-stage.html (PaGaLGuY B-school Rankings Stage 1 [Pre-rankings] - Please give your inputs!)

Yes, we would add your b-school to it next year but we'll follow the same process... ask the people which schools they want to rank.

Cheers,

[TECHNORENGIT]

so wen can we expect the results ??

by mid december ?!

[beenubindas]

HI PG it was nice to see that PG started atleast something like this. But I just want to know when would the rankings be out.
I have one issue with this ranking. a student would rate his institute better than other institute. Like If a person is from SCHMRD he would rate that institute above SIBM or any other. So how do u accomodate this.

[akil_turbo]

Originally Posted by beenubindas

HI PG it was nice to see that PG started atleast something like this. But I just want to know when would the rankings be out.
I have one issue with this ranking. a student would rate his institute better than other institute. Like If a person is from SCHMRD he would rate that institute above SIBM or any other. So how do u accomodate this.

i think u arent among the B-school junta yet...actually PG has already thought of this ....and so when we B-schoolers actually login to vote....none of the comparisons offered to us have our own B-school in them...so no problem.

[The Raven]

Originally Posted by akil_turbo

i think u arent among the B-school junta yet...actually PG has already thought of this ....and so when we B-schoolers actually login to vote....none of the comparisons offered to us have our own B-school in them...so no problem.

That was probably a coincidence. My B-School did come up in the comparison.

[pagalguy]

Originally Posted by The Raven

That was probably a coincidence. My B-School did come up in the comparison.

and that answers the question the probability of you getting a ton of questions based around your school are so minimal that you may not even see your school in the comparison. Its tough to manipulate your school rankings if you don't see it

[beenubindas]

Dude I am already in that junta. I am in IIM Indore, Infact my B school came thrice in my survey. I voted it above three B schools of very good repute. in fact mine was better than those so I didnt find any problem in that. u said it wouldnt come in the list. hw do u identify people those who are in different b schools. I don see any logic behind this. I am still looking for a good explanation.