PaGaLGuY B-school Rankings Stage 1 [Pre-rankings] - Please give your inputs!

[akil_turbo]

My deletion list would be....
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune
Gitam Institute of Foreign Trade, Vishakhapatnam
I I P M, Delhi - how could u even think of this!!!
Jagan Institute of Management Studies, Delhi
Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
SDM Institute, Mysore
Bangalore Management Academy, Bangalore

Recommended list of additions:
TISS
IIM Shillong
BIM Bangalore
IIFT Kolkata
PSG coimbatore

hope this helps.......hope this works out more accurate and ranks **** and icfai in their right places [].
I know u might have considered this but....colleges like icfai have a HUGE student population (around 1000 hyd alone i think) at their disposal....so make sure that a mass attack on the system doesnt work....

[deep_agrawal]

My minus list:

Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Chennai Business School, Chennai
Jagan Institute of Management Studies, Delhi
Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
MET Institute of Management, Mumbai
MIT-School of Business, Pune
PES School of Management, Bangalore
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune

I I P M, Delhi - Wasn't his pseudo banned on PG? :Confused:


My Plus list:

TISS
IIM, Shillong
IIFT, Kolkata
Kirloskar Institute of Advanced Management Studies, Harihar

I hope we have some real rankings after the farce of the rankings by some magazines

[artikay]

My negative list :
Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
Asia-Pacific Institute of Management, Delhi
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Bangalore Management Academy, Bangalore
Chennai Business School, Chennai
Great Lakes Institute of Management, Chennai
I I P M, Delhi
IBA, Bangalore
IMDR, Pune
PES School of Management, Bangalore
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune

My to add list:
Aravali Instt of management, Jodhpur
SCMS, Cochin
Rajgiri, Cochin
TKM, Kollam

[ankit_ag123]

institutes which i think should be excluded

Amity, Delhi
Apeejay Institute of Management, Delhi
Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
Asia-Pacific Institute of Management, Delhi
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Bangalore Management Academy, Bangalore
Chennai Business School, Chennai
Chetana, Mumbai
I I P M, Delhi
IBA, Bangalore
Jagan Institute of Management Studies, Delhi
Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
MIT-School of Business, Pune
NIILM, Delhi
SDM Institute, Mysore
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune

institutes which i think should be included in the ranking
iift kolkata
iim shillong though ranking it wd b difficult coz we dnt knw anythg abt the faculty and the kinda infrastructure it's going to provide.
isbm pune
iimm pune
tiss mumbai.

i think isb and great lakes should nt b a part of these rankings bcz bth thses bskools cater to a different segment..

[anksingla]

I think we should

Delete:

1. Amrita School of Business, Coimbatore
2. Apeejay Institute of Management, Delhi
3. Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
4. Asia-Pacific Institute of Management, Delhi
5. Badruka College, Hyderabad
6. Bangalore Management Academy, Bangalore
7. Chennai Business School, Chennai
8. IBA, Bangalore
9. ISME, Bangalore
10.Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
11.MET Institute of Management, Mumbai
12.MIT-School of Business, Pune
13.NIILM, Delhi
14.PES School of Management, Bangalore

ADD:
1. IIM Shillong
2. IIFT Kolkatta
3. ICFAI, Gurgaon
4. SCMLD, Pune
5. Kirloskar Institute of Advanced Management Studies, Pune
6. TISS Mumbai
7. XIME
Also I think We should have a criterion where we rank SPECIALIZED colleges (e.g. MICA) differently. 'cause it makes no sense ranking an ENFIELD 350cc along with Pulsar & CBZ. Because both of them are in totally different category.

Regards
Ankush Singla

[Jackal]

first of all i am really sorry to spoil the flow of this thread..

but guys get a life.. you want IIM Shillong in for the ratings.. and ISB and GL out..?? why they not indian?? IIM shillong has not even set shop n u want it 2 be rated..

@apurv: this is why ratings was a v bad idea in the first place

n yeah I I P M.. why not..?? it deserves to be rated if this rating thing has to be done..

[u_vimal4u]

that's a nice one. we were all getting bored with the rankings and all that stupid stuff in magazines... at last we can give them a run fo their money!!!

[ameya_ahr]

I sincerely think that almost 80-90% of PGs get in top 25-30 b schools since they are interested enough abt their MBA.. so i would sincerely recommend going for top 30 or max top 40 Bschools .. still if majority feels like voting for top 75 then its their wish. Its just that figuring out top 30 would take much less time and effort.
Anyway, here's my take..

DELETE :-

Amity, Delhi
Amrita School of Business, Coimbatore
Apeejay Institute of Management, Delhi
Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
Asia-Pacific Institute of Management, Delhi
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Bangalore Management Academy, Bangalore
BIM, Trichy
BIMTECH, Noida
Chennai Business School, Chennai
Chetana, Mumbai
Christ College, Bangalore
Gitam Institute of Foreign Trade, Vishakhapatnam
Great Lakes Institute of Management, Chennai
I I P M, Delhi
IBA, Bangalore
ICFAI, Mumbai
IFMR, Chennai
IIFM, Bhopal
IISWBM, Kolkata
IMDR, Pune
Institute of Petroleum Management, Gandhinagar
ISME, Bangalore
ITM, Navi Mumbai
Jagan Institute of Management Studies, Delhi
Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
Loyola Institute (LIBA), Chennai
MET Institute of Management, Mumbai
MFC- Delhi University, Delhi
MHROD - Delhi School of Economics, Delhi
MIT-School of Business, Pune
NIILM, Delhi
NL Dalmia, Mumbai
PES School of Management, Bangalore
SDM Institute, Mysore
SIES, Navi Mumbai
SIOM, Nasik
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune
UBS, Chandigarh

ummmmmmmmm cant say ........TYPES ::::

SITM, Pune Sydenham, Mumbai
IMT, Nagpur



ADD:-

TISS
IIM, Shillong

[sgx100]

List for deletion :

They look pretty much the same

List for addition:

NIBM, Pune (Seems this was left out of the fray in totality)
IIM, Shillong


Will Keep adding to this

[buck_was]

The institutes that better be out of the final 75:
Amity, Delhi
Apeejay Institute of Management, Delhi
Army Institute of Management, Kolkata
Asia-Pacific Institute of Management, Delhi
Badruka College, Hyderabad
Chennai Business School, Chennai
Gitam Institute of Foreign Trade, Vishakhapatnam
I I P M, Delhi
ISME, Bangalore
Jagan Institute of Management Studies, Delhi
Jaipuria Institute of Management, Lucknow
MIT-School of Business, Pune
PES School of Management, Bangalore
Suryadatta Institute of Management, Pune

Some institutes which better be in the final 75:
IIM Shillong - despite question marks everywhere, merely for academic interest - to capture the 'perception' of tag value..
TISS, Mumbai
IIFT, Kolkata
NIBM, Pune
FMS (MS), Delhi Univ.
DFS, Delhi Univ.
Entrepreneurship Development Institute, Gandhinagar
Faculty/School of Mgmt. Studies, BHU
SRCC (MBA-GBO), Delhi
IMT, Dubai - again, for academic interest
ICFAI, Gurgaon
BK School of Management, Ahmedabad
NIT, Trichy
Kirloskar Institute of Advanced Management Studies, Pune
Instt of Mktg. Mgmt., Delhi
IILM, Noida
SCIT, Pune

Some institutes which others recommended for inclusion, but I beg to differ :
ICFAI, Ahmedabad
SCMLD, Pune
PSGIM, Coimbatore
ICFAI, Kolkata
M.S. Ramaiah Instt. of Mgmt., Bangalore
Aravali Instt of Mgmt., Jodhpur
SCMS, Cochin
Rajgiri, Cochin
TKM, Kollam
ISB&M, Pune
IIMM, Pune

On ISB/Great Lakes, I don't see any reason why they should not be included! Rather, SP Jain Dubai/Singapore is better candidate for exclusion, as it offers highly specialized courses, viz. Retail Mgmt., Wealth Mgmt. etc.