[shivit]

Originally Posted by pec2006

I have a small query I can't decide which one to chose between MDI and IIT B

The thing that goes in favour of IIT B is its placements and very less fees
The only thing that stops me doing this is that many ratings rate MDI better than IIT B

But somehow my gut felling is that these ratings underate IIT B

Can u help me make a informed decision

Wud i be missing the brand MDI if i do so.

Hi pec2006
Comparing two B schools is not encouraged at PG. MDI and IIT-B both are great B schools and both have their advantages.
I think for getting a better idea you can use PM facility.
Few factors which can help you decide:-
1. Stream of specialization in MBA - for eg. if you want to do finance, then find out about professors in both B schools,companies for summer placements (for finance) and of course final placements.
2. Events & Extra-curricular Activities, Guest Lectures - say for eg. XLRI has marketing fair called MAXI-FAIR. Does IIT-B or MDI have any special focus or emphasis on your stream of specialization?

Its always a difficult choice to make as both are great B schools.

[pec2006]

Hi

What i am doing is not disregarding or disreputing any B school .It's
just as an outsider i really don't know very much in detail

So as far as i am not disreputing any particular B school
I have every right to hear other seniors opinion as well as puys who know both in detail

[nitish4u]

Originally Posted by pec2006

Hi

What i am doing is not disregarding or disreputing any B school .It's
just as an outsider i really don't know very much in detail

So as far as i am not disreputing any particular B school
I have every right to hear other seniors opinion as well as puys who know both in detail

Dude No offences...
Just to inform you that such comparision on any thread is not encouraged ...
However you have evry right to know about the insti but use PM facility to do this. Dont do this publicially on any thread or forum.
MODS please correct me if i am wrong

[sharang]

Originally Posted by pec2006

Hi

What i am doing is not disregarding or disreputing any B school .It's
just as an outsider i really don't know very much in detail

So as far as i am not disreputing any particular B school
I have every right to hear other seniors opinion as well as puys who know both in detail

I know ur nt disreputing any insti..wat they mean is that comparison of B-Schools is not encouraged...esp on the official thread of a college...start a new thread for it if u want...cuz as it is u wudnt get the right perception here...i mean its not correct to ask a clg how it is compared to anodr one
Sharang

[anvayonline]

Originally Posted by Parasuram NA

Buddy,

Thats wat we call oppurtunity cost . U miss out on something if u pick up something else.
Of course, even I feel that SJMSOM is quite underrated in ratings but that can be accounted to the fact that it takes mostly engineers and hence isnt widely known to most poll takers outside the engineering world...
Just as u hv mentioned abt fees and placements, i wd also like to point out that SJMSOM is also a gud place if u aspire to be an entrepreneur... plus the IIT atmosphere and n/w shd b added advantages for anyone studying in SJMSOM.
I am nt in a position to comment for/against MDI so i can just present one side of the story ...that too my version..
Bottomline is that its ur personal decision and plzz dont base it on some B-school ratings... (atleast I wont!!!)

Anyways all the Best to all Puys for the result...
Kab aayega yaar result.. :confused:

Hope it helps!!
Cheers!!!

I totally agree with you. After visiting SJMSOM I was wondering quiet a bit on credibility of public polls as they potray a false picture. What more can explain the rank 20 of SJMSOM on pagalguy. Another cue is that govt. colleges facts and figures are never manipulated as is the case with private institutions . So this fact must also be kept into account while making a decision.

[siddharth.mah]

I have been following this new discussion. I think the In-Take capacity has also got a lot to determine the rankings for the B-Schools. Moreover the expertise in some field cannot pull the business schools up on the rankings as it happens that one of the best HR School, TISS is un-noticed in all the rankings.
With a batch strength of 80 (approx), its going to be difficult for SJMSOM to be compared with insti's like SPJain, MDI, NM, IMT etc.
Thus I think more than the ranking the industrial contacts of these insti's are more important.
Said that, we, the aspirants do care about the brand names more than anything else.
For this reasons we give these rankings very high importance rather than finding the different parameters those were considered to draw the rankings and also parameter which were overlooked.

[Parasuram NA]

Originally Posted by anvayonline

I totally agree with you. After visiting SJMSOM I was wondering quiet a bit on credibility of public polls as they potray a false picture. What more can explain the rank 20 of SJMSOM on pagalguy. Another cue is that govt. colleges facts and figures are never manipulated as is the case with private institutions . So this fact must also be kept into account while making a decision.

I think doubting the credibility may not be the right approach... infact since PG ratings itself showed SJMSOM @20, it means that even B-school aspirants dont perceive SJMSOM as a top notch destination....
May be the school can do with some gud word-of-mouth reviews... also maybe the school mite want to market itself more aggressively within the students(read aspirant) community.. just as it has done with the corporate...

Just my point of view..
Comments welcome.

Cheers!!

[floyd&vodka]

Originally Posted by pec2006

I have a small query I can't decide which one to chose between MDI and IIT B

The thing that goes in favour of IIT B is its placements and very less fees

Why SJMSOM?


Besides placements and fees, there are a lot more significant reasons to be a part of SJMSOM, IIT Bombay.



I am elucidating some of them here:


Very strong industry orientation:
-Diksha: Guest lecture series where CEOs and MDs are invited to share their knowledge
-Leadership Lectures: Series of lectures organized by the faculty and the students
-Continuum Series: A rolling seminar series for all domains of management. Check out the Systems seminar and Consulting Seminar.
-Industry Seminars: SMF Convention, HCM Seminar, Civil Aviation Seminar
-IIT Events: Plethora of IIT events where SOM is closely involved. For eg. PAN-IIT, Distinguished Lecture Series, Eureka etc
-SOM has close association with NEN, TiE, CII and is a part of various events organized by them


Student Activities:
Inspite of being a small batch, there are numerous events which are completely organized solely by the students. You have already seen this in the admission process which was managed by the students. Even the placements is being managed by students. Additionally, the students take part in the organization and participation in various IIT events. Hence, all students get a holistic experience in management and gain invaluable experience in event management and people management.


Here are some of the events:
-Avenues: Our flagship bschool festival
-Industry seminars like Diksha and Continuums
-L!VE: The student magazine of SJMSOM
-Ecell Activities: Eureka, Eweek
-Barcamp: An unconference and an excellent platform to interact with Entrepreneurs and VCs. A new trend started by the current batch and would be held 2-3 times a year
-Mood Indigo, the IIT cultural fest: People from SOM participate in events like Dance, Rock Show, Fashion Show and much more!
-Theatre: Plays, Skits, Drama. Check out a pic from a drama SOM performed yesterday
-Dance Competitions: SOM team has participated in most of the IIT level dance competitions like Gyrations, AIDS
-Sports: SOM regularly participates in Inter IIT Sports meet, PG Sports, Hostel Sports
-Besides the above events where SOM has participated or been a part of the core organizing team, there are a plethora of events where we have the privilege of listening to great speakers or just having fun as spectators. Some of them are: esummit, Techfest, GJ events etc

Interaction with SJMSOM PhDs:


SJMSOM has a distinguished PhD program and some of the students include IPS Officer, CEOs, Directors of corporate houses. To name a few Mr Arvind Agrawal (CEO, RPG Spencer’s), Mr Nandkumar Saravade (IPS) - Director - Cyber Security and Compliance, NASSCOM, Mr Pankaj Phadnis (Group Vice-President, Wadia Group). A few alumni include Mr Ganesh Natrajan (Deputy Chairman and MD, Zensar Technologies Ltd.), Mr Hasit Joshipura (President and ED, Johnson & Johnson Ltd). It’s a great experience to have few of them as your classmates as the PhDs attend a lot of SOM courses.

Strong Entrepreneurship Culture:


SJMSOM has very strong entrepreneurial culture reflected through very strong initiatives like:
-Organizing events by Eclub SJMSOM
-Organizing of various events with Ecell, IIT Bombay
-SOM has consistently been in the Top 5 teams in Eureka: The biggest bplan competition in Asia
-Close association with NEN and TIE
-Entrepreneurship seminar Navonmesh in Avenues
-Being in close contact with the IIT B incubator SINE
-Some of the faculty are themselves entrepreneurs


Infrastructure:


I don’t need to say much about it as most of you have already seen the IIT B campus. You can see some images here and here

Brand IIT:


Regarding Brands, although the brand IIT is more known for its technical excellence for its UG course, the brand in itself carries a lot of weight. Its highly regarding in the industry, specially outside India. This helps us to attract excellent faculty and eminent speakers and guests for our seminars. The weight of this brand is palpable when we attend seminars, IIT alumni meets and other similar forums.


Please Note: I have not spoken about the excellent faculty, pedagogy, course content, ability to take courses from other IIT depts etc at SOM. Academics is something which every college would claim to be good at. However, we strongly believe that the academic rigour at SOM is one of the best across bschools in India.

About the rankings, it has been discussed at length how SOM had a significant disadvantage in the PG ranking due to the perception based crowd sourced methodology. We wont discuss that further. At the end of the day, its not the rankings, but the actual quality and the industry perception which matters!



Cheers
Ramesh

[arpitzwurld]

Originally Posted by floyd&vodka

Why SJMSOM?


Besides placements and fees, there are a lot more significant reasons to be a part of SJMSOM, IIT Bombay.

About the rankings, it has been discussed at length how SOM had a significant disadvantage in the PG ranking due to the perception based crowd sourced methodology. We wont discuss that further. At the end of the day, its not the rankings, but the actual quality and the industry perception which matters!



Cheers
Ramesh

well all the above being absolutely true...as was told to us during the presentationa nd introduction before the start of gd/pi process in the morning...also the kind of student mix we get at iit...not considering the sjmsom individually...but talk about the tech school..btech and mtech ppl..phd ppl and the magagement students...and just step in once the campus itself ur bowled over by it...my special likings r inclined towards the tam tam which is a feature unique in itself...also talk about the alumni nwetwork of iit again...unbeatable...many of other best intitutes in the country would find it difficult to match..

also kindly not go by the rankings too much...every ranking is prepared by considering some criteria as absolute or correct...which itself can b very subjective..in the case og pg rankings they r based on preferences of students etc...magazine ratings are based on the very fact that how many insti's wud pay the mag for considering the instt for the same

[arpitzwurld]

repeat post