Pune...which colleges to apply...

[divys]

Originally Posted by r4there

Dear Dev.

I'd like to comment on ur this post. symbi instts r deffinatlty gud, but u can't understimate pumba. it's a gud instt. and followings r sm facts cum personal openion on wht i'd like u to pay bit attantion...

1. PUMBA 36yrs. old instt. that makes excellent alumni
base.
2. it provides degree of mba since starting, wehre SIBM
b'came uni. b4 couple of yrs.
3. Fee of symbi is 5 times more then PUMBA. that states
that return on investment is far higher in pumba then
symbi. ur cash in hand remains half after passing out frm
symbi and after repayment of loan, symbi'ite will find
himself equelent with pumba guy. and meanwhile pumba
get far more cash in hand then a symbi guy.
4. most imp. if sm1 have money and can pay a healthy
amount of cash can make it through ny isntt. of symbi
but not in pumba, can get admission in symbi.
5. PUMBA is low prof. instt. tht doesn't mean it's a bad instt.
where we all r concern highly adv. and marketing done
by symbi. even no. of applications r almost same at both
instt. when PUMBA don't roam around county to sell it's
aplication forms like symbi....
so give thought to various aspects before comparing two colleges.

*Rahul*

Dear Rahul

I never intended to say that PUMBA is bad... My concern is that.. Every B school has its own system and choice of position.. When we talk of Pumba.. the kind of students who go there.. the kind of sectors they chose to work.. the kind of profiles they are offered are much different than others.. I am asking for an objectivity.. for past 1 yr i have remained off the posts because i see lot of people like acadfunda and franky and shanx active from pune.. bt yes i wld look at the fact that we have avoided any comparison nd thats what my concern is..

Regards
Divyendu

(PS: Dear acad.. Prof Pillai's background is well known to us.. But fortunately or unfortunately he is a thing o past for us.. we have moved much above his time period and crossed miles.. The values of insti and the vision mission has taken a new direction.. And yes.. lots of PUMBA faculty have given us so much of knowledge that we can only be indebted to them)

[r4there]

[quote]

Originally Posted by divys

Dear Rahul

When we talk of Pumba.. the kind of students who go there.. the kind of sectors they chose to work.. the kind of profiles they are offered are much different than others..

Here i couldn't get the meaning of word "Different".. i think no one would have get this apart frm u... here again i wud like to clear the things..

the kind of students who go there:- The best candidates among thousands, who appear in MH-CET. diff b/w cut-offs of JBIMS and PUMBA is not very high. so there's no question of the quality of the students who make it through PUMBA.

the kind of profiles they are offered:- Bajaj Auto, Glenmark, iGATE, LG, HCL, TVS, TCS are not bad offers.

the kind of sectors they chose to work:- This is another irrelevent question. They get these kinda offers and these companies r not bad one i think.

and if u don't hv faith on d work of PUMBA guyz then y u left PaGaLGuY and relied upon pumba guyz like acadfunda and dapulsur....??? here "Working for PaGaLGuY" is there choice(that is good one).. not urs.(can't say gud one)

[avinash_9898]

agreed...its not an isbm thread..agreed..but honestly if u ppl see there are varied opinions about it...a person CANNOT make out..one post says ppl gettin 8 lacs and 5 lacs in delhi campus wich is a realtively newer campus..a post says if u r takin kolkata campus advertising and marketing is good...u guys have been there done that or at least possess knowledge wich i dont..so i am pestering u to be a bit more clear..i dont think ki a person gettina 8 lacs package can cum from a okie institute..see my thing i m gettin kolkata campus .the differences are varied as mentioned in the website..while pune campus allows specialisation in finance,marketing,hr,systems...kolkata campus has specialisations in sales and marketing,retailing,financial services and insurance and risk management.again pune campus has 10 weeks internship and other campuses have 6 months internship..i doono if it will make a difference but i m just pointing out what i got from the site.. and another post says ki the average salary last year was 3.5 and highest 5.5(PUNE 2006 data)..i m not a very clever man...or may b i m not so intelligent that i can learn to make one opinion from so many data..still i believe acadfunda and r4therehave come up wid the most reliable data i can depend upon...also pranav..his reply has sort of forced me to think about isb&m..

[r4there]

u ppl see there are varied opinions about it...a person CANNOT make out..one post says ppl gettin 8 lacs and 5 lacs in delhi campus wich is a realtively newer campus..

Dear avinash... i rectified it in one of my last post, given data vd company name and cash in hand. sir, plz do liitle bit bother to go back and read it...

so i am pestering u to be a bit more clear..i dont think ki a person gettina 8 lacs package can cum from a okie institute..

it's 5.8 lac. 35000 pm. in hand this it's a FACT, recruiters won't get on with YOUR THINKING, we r clear wehre acadfunda cont. saying it's a decent instt. and in my last post regarding this i clearly said "go for d instt"...

see my thing...... kolkata campus has specialisations...

we'r concern abt d things tht's y we cud try to guide abt ISB&M...

3.5 and highest 5.5(PUNE 2006 data)..i m not a very clever man...or may b i m not so intelligent that i can learn to make one opinion from so many data..still i believe acadfunda and r4therehave come up wid the most reliable data i can depend upon...also pranav..his reply has sort of forced me to think about isb&m..one post says ppl gettin.... .. a post says if u r....

See man we'r nt throwing comments blindly, ds is student's speaks, nw it's upto u tht u consider it reliable or nt, and it's nt intelligence it's analysis, and remember tht these r not only d posts, these r personal openion, abt u nw i'll say don't do for ny instt. for mba b'coz if u can't come out on an decision after having tht much of data, u can't b a gud manager, and still cursing us for ur lacking in decision manking... I'm sry i can't provide u more reliable data... and plz don't make this thread irrelevent...

[avinash_9898]

Originally Posted by r4there

Dear avinash... i rectified it in one of my last post, given data vd company name and cash in hand. sir, plz do liitle bit bother to go back and read it...

it's 5.8 lac. 35000 pm. in hand this it's a FACT, recruiters won't get on with YOUR THINKING, we r clear wehre acadfunda cont. saying it's a decent instt. and in my last post regarding this i clearly said "go for d instt"...
we'r concern abt d things tht's y we cud try to guide abt ISB&M...
See man we'r nt throwing comments blindly, ds is student's speaks, nw it's upto u tht u consider it reliable or nt, and it's nt intelligence it's analysis, and remember tht these r not only d posts, these r personal openion, abt u nw i'll say don't do for ny instt. for mba b'coz if u can't come out on an decision after having tht much of data, u can't b a gud manager, and still cursing us for ur lacking in decision manking... I'm sry i can't provide u more reliable data... and plz don't make this thread irrelevent...

i am not making this thread irrelevant..with due respect to u i am not cursing anybody..i am not.so better dont make my confusion more miserable for me..

[acadfunda]

Originally Posted by avinash_9898

i am not making this thread irrelevant..with due respect to u i am not cursing anybody..i am not.so better dont make my confusion more miserable for me..

Hi Avi,

Chill dost....maybe due to sum miscommunication or misunderstanding, lets not loose the tempo of this effort. I totally understand ur confusion...as I have spentr good time in the period u r goin thru

Mate, I will try to explain once more what exactly is the advice.-

1) ISBM Pune is a decent enough college for Marketing and Operations (Definitely not FINANCE). It has many companies visiting its campus and with almost equal packages and profiles for similar profile b-schools frm Pune.

2) ISBM Kolkatta is gud for advertising and Mktg.

3) ISBM DElhi---no idea


My colleague frm ISBM Pune 2006 batch of operations n SCM has advised to go ONLY for ISBM PUne and NOT for ISBM Kolkatta n DElhi campus....his premises of this decision mkin is based on his 2 year stint wid ISBM Pune. So the advice does count.

My personal advise was that since u are very young (as I can see frm ur profile)...u can always try another shot to CAT for da IIMs and other affiliated schools, to SNAP for the better institutes in Symbiosis, to CET for the Top 5.....I mean it wud just mean a span of 12 months for a better life right.

Thats it. No further comments..All the best dude....

Cheers

[r4there]

hey avi.. sry if i depressed u... but my concern is tht we just can show u d way, it's u who'll hv to walk on tht road... nw u've whole data... if u've studied statestic then use decision making table, just analyse it and come on a decision and even if u don't know abt ds table then ur mind cn provide u best statestics methods, i also told u d realityof d b-schools tht r equelent to ISB&M, u'll hv to work hard over there...
I told u abt d placement of two delhi guyz.... ISB&M's delhi & kolkata campus r picking up d growth, and i think till 2009(when u'll pass out) it's gonna b'cm far better then 2006... ds yr. it was 1st real batch of Del. and it provided gud placement.. C'mon yaar.. now when u've info. just analyse it, no one else take ur decisions, b'coz u'r d only person who's better aware of ur own strengths and weakneses then ny1 else....

[avinash_9898]

Originally Posted by acadfunda

Hi Avi,

Chill dost....maybe due to sum miscommunication or misunderstanding, lets not loose the tempo of this effort. I totally understand ur confusion...as I have spentr good time in the period u r goin thru

Mate, I will try to explain once more what exactly is the advice.-

1) ISBM Pune is a decent enough college for Marketing and Operations (Definitely not FINANCE). It has many companies visiting its campus and with almost equal packages and profiles for similar profile b-schools frm Pune.

2) ISBM Kolkatta is gud for advertising and Mktg.

3) ISBM DElhi---no idea


My colleague frm ISBM Pune 2006 batch of operations n SCM has advised to go ONLY for ISBM PUne and NOT for ISBM Kolkatta n DElhi campus....his premises of this decision mkin is based on his 2 year stint wid ISBM Pune. So the advice does count.

My personal advise was that since u are very young (as I can see frm ur profile)...u can always try another shot to CAT for da IIMs and other affiliated schools, to SNAP for the better institutes in Symbiosis, to CET for the Top 5.....I mean it wud just mean a span of 12 months for a better life right.

Thats it. No further comments..All the best dude....

Cheers

thanx a lot....that made me happy gain..there is no specialistion for advertising in kolkata vaise...if i m gettin pune ..its okie...or i will appear next year..thanx for helping me to make a decision.and how does internship makes a difference...10 weeks in pune and 6 months in other campuses..i met pramod kumar yesterday..he asked me to meet again on tuesday..if he gives me pune i wud take it..otherwise..buhbye isb&m

[r4there]

Originally Posted by avinash_9898

thanx a lot....that made me happy gain..there is no specialistion for advertising in kolkata vaise...if i m gettin pune ..its okie...or i will appear next year..thanx for helping me to make a decision.and how does internship makes a difference...10 weeks in pune and 6 months in other campuses..i met pramod kumar yesterday..he asked me to meet again on tuesday..if he gives me pune i wud take it..otherwise..buhbye isb&m

ya... tht's wht we'r expecting frm ur side... c'mon u'r only 21 yet... can take drop.. work hard one more year and make it through ny B+ or A grade instt.. ALL THE BEST

[nehss]

is INDIRA PUNE worth applying...and if so whts the proedure 2 apply...thru ATMA