I have similar profile like yours, Manufacturing/metals/good EC/NIT/1 month Intl. experience( 3 countries)
Exception being, I have 12 yrs of experience, average acads, and lower GMAT 700
I have been shortlisted. ProbablY what wokred in my favor is that I have managerial/leadership experience of 6+years and experience of general Management. My other activities and EC are very strong with papers,publications,patents, social service etc.
As u rightly said, on the basis of IIMA application alone, IMO, it may not be possible to judge the true potential of candidate. However probably adcom has its own criteria for selection. By looking at the profiles, IMO, IIMA has not given too much of weightage to GMAT contrary to last year. We have seen profiles with GMAT 680 got shortlisted. This year IIMA probably looked at more work experience, especially in mangerial/leadership position.
I personally feel that it is all important how well one package the IIM application and put in all the relevant details.
I feel your profile is very strong and wonder how u missed the I/V call.
All the best for your PGPEX interview.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_of_Soul Well the main reason for my ding (personal thoughts) is that my profile is not marketable to a top Energy/Metals company.
I mean how will I convince the companies that 1 year MBA is enough reason to recruit me into a leadership position. The first question that will come up is how many people did you lead.. what kind of money did you handle?
Otherwise my IIT BTech. Work with compaies that are all fortune 500. International travel (I have visited 8 countries; other than Latin America and Antarctic I have been to all other continents).
Good EC (social service). Top it with a 760 GMAT score. I cant see any other reason why IIMA will ignore my profile.
Leadership potential is important but kind of difficult to judge from the IIMA application. For IIMA leadership can be demonstrated only thru the interview and essays.
I am ready with IIMA essays. So incase some one wants to buy it from me I will release it (we can discuss the pricing  )
Anyway I feel great to have participated. Infact IIMA essays made my more aware of myself (IIMC and ISB are good too but IIMA is the best). And ding analysis is a good yardstick to measure what I have done till date and what I need to do to achieve my dreams.
All the best guys. |