Back to an old thread
Looking at the last few posts... and my personal experience in a successful startup

in a nice place

I must add a few things...
Its always team team team... Though one super leader is a necessity...
The idea is almost irrelevant... Because frankly most ideas... anyone can come up with... Though some ideas are clearly outstanding... But otherwise its a team that gels together and fits together that works... Now team is important because down the line there will be disagreements and a state of hopelessness even... you better have a team that has the guts to stick thro all this... So while making a team think of the long term whether all of you will stick together in thick and thin. Other than that the abilities of the team members should be complementary. Not all need to be super brains but there need to be a few but importantly all should enjoy working together
Other than that its the scale of your idea and vision that matter... Some people dream of a 0$ company.. a good little wine shop which will make them more than the IIM avg salary every year... Others have 0 billion dollar $ dreams... All have to start at zero
Personally think the MBA is absolutely not needed... but has its advantages in access to smart people and infrastructure and also importantly a brand name MBA will mean in the worst case scenario of your startup tanking getting a job again will be easier
K
PS: Seriously interested folks on this thread can pm me