[2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - Page 3 - PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA in India and Abroad, CAT 2009, GMAT, XAT, MAT
PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA in India and Abroad, CAT 2009, GMAT, XAT, MAT
Forum Rules
» Sponsors
  PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA in India and Abroad, CAT 2009, GMAT, XAT, MAT > MBA Exams and Institutes - Indian Business Schools > CAT and Related Discussion
[2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences
CAT and Related Discussion Discuss information and B-schools under the toughest and most exclusive management entrance exam in India. The CAT - The Common Admission Test.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

» Post Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  (#21)
karthikm karthikm is offline
..............
Trainee PaGaL
 
Posts: 47
Join Date: Apr 2009
Age: 24
Groans: 3
Groaned at 0 Times in 0 Posts
Thanks: 95
Thanked 13 Times in 10 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 06-04-2009, 07:20 PM

Hi guys,

This is my first post in PG . I had my GD/PI yesterday April 5th in IIM B.

PROFILE:

Acads:
X - 93.2
XII - 96.9
Undergrad Major - 93.7%

Work-Ex:
Consulting - 8 months till now

CAT %ile:
DI - 89.XX
Quant - 80.XX
Verbal - 93.XX
Aggregate - 93.39 ( was surprised to get to a call !! )



Extra curricular/ Hobbies/Interests(if you have mentioned them)
Choreographer of college dance team.


CASE/GD : case study
Topic:
Mr S.Mani has been delegated a responsibility of scheduling trains on time for one zone. But he found out that due to bad tracks, and unproper maintainance of the engines, there is delay in the trains. Top management not happy with the performance and keeps forcing this issue on Mani..what should Mani do ?
Number of Ppl present : 8
Time: 5mins prep + 15min discussion + 5mins summary writting
Brief Snapshot of Discussion:
At the start it wass fish market kinda discussion. After a few min everything started falling into place. As the case was brief teh discussions were revolving around almost same points. Got good air time and think it was good overall

Though they gave 5mins to write the summary i think they took back the sheets in3-4mins
PI
Panel Members Intro: No intro was given my the members

Questions:

I was the last one to be interviewed in that panel
Average interview time of my panel was 30mins. Mine was only for 15mins . dunno what to decide based on that

There we three members in the panel. Of which one did not open his mouth during the entire interview.

P1: Can you tell me about your work profile?
Me: Explained
P2: (was always looking angry!!1 ) there is no connection between what you do and what you have studied, Mechanical?
Me: I tried to explain that after 3 years you can become functional guy that needs knowledge about some Indus Engg stuff that i have learnt blah blah
P2: Ok you studied finite element analysis?
Me: yes sir
P2: give me a practical example where you use it?
Me: Explained by saying about construction of crane arm blah blah.. Dont even know if they use FEA in that but u sounded convinced.
P2: Do you know boiler?
Me: yes sir
P2: Do they use FEA there
Me: said thermodynamics is also involved. Effect of heat and pressure ont he material is to be analysed too
P2: Can you tell me the laws of thermodynamics?
Me: I told him zeroth and 1st law. Told that i cant recollect exactly what the thrid law is, but it has to do with entropy
P2: Ok, ill ask you the last qs. My fav one to mech engg. How do you manufacture a pencil.
Me : I tried explaining something with drawing process, but was basically some bull shit. Accpeted that i do not know it
P2: ok. Sir you can take it now ( to P1 )
P1: what client are you working for right now?
Me; said
P1: Your company has been accussed of unethically hiring people from PWC?what do you have to say about it
Me: I think it might be the tax firm that you are talking abt sir. I am part of the consulting arm and I dont think what you say is happ in our firm.
P1: ok. Why si there diff arms for the same firm?
Me: I said because of Enron sir. ( My mistake to have brought that up)
P1: can you explain abt the Enron case
Me: (thout i knew abt it when i started, later on couldnt complete it) started off tryin to explain but cudnt quite finish like i wud have liked to!
P1: ok then. what were hobbies in college?
Me: i dance for the college dance team sir
P1: what style of dance?
Me: nothing in particular sir. We as a group choreograph dnaces that we are each good at.
P2: (cuts in!!) do you know hip-hop
Me: have not attended classes for it, but have done few performances in hip hop sir
P2: do ou know the origin of hip-hop? what is the meaning of each move ( was totally stumped!! )
Me: i do not know that sir
P2: ok
P1: can you tell about your last responsibility in your job?
ME: Explained....
P1: ok then . thank you

All 3 thank me and i do the same.

I think my intervie was bad and Gd was good. Dunno what conclusions to draw, so going to wait for the results!

Any comments/suggestions ??
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to karthikm For This Useful Post:
diablorulez (06-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (06-04-2009), sarvshwet (06-04-2009)
Sponsored Links
  (#22)
atshubha atshubha is offline
dead but kicking
Hardcore PaGaL
 
Posts: 358
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Bangalore
Groans: 8
Groaned at 6 Times in 4 Posts
Thanks: 432
Thanked 264 Times in 86 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 06-04-2009, 08:02 PM

PROFILE:

2 april 2009 , Bangalore

Acads:
X - 91.4
XII - 84.4
Undergrad Major - 88.4

Work-Ex:
IT - 3 years (almost)
Telecom + ERP

CAT %ile:
DI - 95.XX
Quant - 94.XX
Verbal - 97.XX
Aggregate - 98.73



Extra curricular/ Hobbies/Interests(if you have mentioned them)
Reading , literary, watching plays

CASE/GD : case study
Topic:
A students council starts an initial store, with Rs 3000, recovers Rs 1500 in the initial 2 months or so ( dont remember ) , decides to extend its services to the
non student community , raises 15000, 8000 at 18 % interest , 5000 borrowed at two equal monthly installments.

There is a protest in the student community. sales decline and non student community also does not turn up.

What should the Students council do.

Discussion :

Since noone in my group was ready to start the discussion i started defined the problem briefly and what we can discuss.
Pitched in a few more times with some more calculations.


Panel Members Intro: No intro was given my the members

Questions:

My interview was 30 minutes probably one of the shorter interviews in my panel.

There we three members in the panel.

P1: Introduce yourself.
Me: Did so short and sweet.
P1: What is your work about?
Me: Since i just got a promotion mentioned my new position and my work and responsibilities.
P3: (I think ) He asked me do you remember abt of your IT.
Me : Yes sir the basics.
P3 : Maths
Me :Yes sir i do.
P3 : What should i ask you ?
ME : Anything sir.
P3 : No name a topic
Me : Probability
P3 : SO its your strength ?
Me : No sir , its my nemisis, but since its not formula based i can apply my brains.
P3 : OK so If i have two bags and 2 red and 2 white balls in the bag , if i pick two balls what is the probability that they are of the same colour ?
Me : I tried to calculate ,i was thinking aloud he asked me to just not think aloud and give him the answer initially i gave him the wrong answer.
P3 : Then he said something and i said 1/3 ( i had not discounted the similar cases , either both red , both white , or one red one white and since the balls a
are similar )
P3 : SO now what next ?Continue wiht probability ?
Me : YEs sir.
P3 : Ok same thing pick up balls with replacement
ME : WW , RR, WR , RW 1/2
P3: This thing above your head ?
Me :Fan sir ?
P3 :Its not a fan its a ..
Me : Look up , projector sir.
P3 :Probability of it falling on your head ,either it will fall or it will not ...
1/2 ..
Me ..hmm
P3 :So run for your life.
Me :Smile its conditional sir , its tied by something. ..
P1 :SOmehow the discussion went to literacy ? % ? Why difference between states ? Why is it important ?
ME : I said it is important for a general sense of awareness, its like a set of tools to buid something ,lots of gyan .
P1 :Literacy programes by the govt.
Me :I remembered 2 - 3 gave the name ( A screw up here , i forgot about the Right to Education bill and said that it is a directive principle of state policy)
Its actually a fundamental right since nov 2008 .... It was a big screw up i guess .... ( it wasnt in the top of my mind thats all)
P1 : questioned me particualrly on Directive principals of state policy , why this 6 - 14 age group ( which i was mentioning since it was in my head but i just
could not remeber the right to education bill )
ME: I said some thing. i just said that i remeber basic things like education , healthcare ...
P2/P3 : What are the flagship programes on health care govt ?
Me : National rural health mission , i only remembered this ...
PX: Ok so, have you heard of stagflation.
ME : I had heard it i didnt remember it clearly so said , YEs sir , i think when the inflation stagnates .. ( its actually low growth high inflation ).
P3: So what is the inflation rate .
Me : Less than 1 %.
P3 :So is it good.
ME : Prices have not come down they are only not rising as steeply as they were till last year , the index of comparison + oil prices ...
P2 : What is the price of oil ?
Me : 40 - 50 $ a barrel ..
P3 :SO is it good inflation ?
Me : ITs not good/bad , japan has been a deflationary economy for years and its also not good. depends on the economy.
P3 : Ok so you must have heard about brazil ,it had a high inflation ?
Me :Sir , are you talking of the 1970s ?
P3 : Yes
Me: No sir , they had a huge debt (Latin american crisis )
P3 :So what is debt
ME :Borrowing from other countries IMF etc.
P3 : What is bad about debt, the US has a huge debt they say its fine .
ME : Yes sir , trillions of dollars, they say its fine .
P3 :ITs not ?
Me : Sir the world saves and the US spends ....
P3 OK fine we are done.
ME : Thanks pick up my folder and bbye.

Regards


Dont know what to make of it ...


There is no magic in magic ,it's all in the details.
Walt Disney

http://www.thedarknessisbutme.blogspot.com/


Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to atshubha For This Useful Post:
diablorulez (06-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (06-04-2009), sarvshwet (06-04-2009)
  (#23)
gjag gjag is offline
has no status.
Newbie PaGaL
 
Posts: 2
Join Date: Jul 2007
Groans: 0
Groaned at 1 Time in 1 Post
Thanks: 0
Thanked 8 Times in 2 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 06-04-2009, 08:23 PM

Hi Guys.. sorry for late reply ..
i had my interview on 3rd april 9 o clock slot at IIM B

Profile:
Acads:
X - 78.6 (UP board)
XII - 85.6
Undergrad Major - 89.3%

Work-Ex: 32 months

CAT %ile:
DI - 86.XX
Quant - 97.XX
Verbal - 89.XX
Aggregate - 96.57


Extra curricular/ Hobbies/Interests(if you have mentioned them)

GD/Case study :
There are 24 students called for each slot i guess.19 people turned up.They started at sharp 9,splitted us into 2 groups.10 in grp 1 and 9 in grp 2.I was in grp 2.

we were taken into 2 diferent rooms,the panel was same for the GD and the interview for me.after the GD they devided the grp into 3 parts ,i stayed with the same panel.
It was a case study.We were given 5 minutes to read the case,15 min to discuss and 5 min to write the summery.

The case was about a commerce graduate called Prabhakar.He has a manufacturing company JMI in Bhuvenashwar and he looks after the money matters while his 2 brothers look after the customer and the employees.Over the years they have done biz only with 2 companies which are TMC (tamilnadu manufacturing company) and defence out of which they did more biz with TMC.There product quality was low earlier n was rated 50 on the scale of 100 by TMC bt later they improved n rated 100.
The demand from TMC is falling and the biz with defence is also drying up.He has taken a loan from some Mr.Savant and he is also now pressing him to pay back the loan of 2 lakhs.He might get a good contract from a new company bt that will take another 8 months.He came in to manufacturing biz against the will of his family so family is also not supporting.In d same area few other companies also turned sick n went out of biz.
What prabhakar should do in such a situation?

pretty weird case,nothing much to discuss. we were 9 ppl there- 3 girls and 6 boys.one guy started.wasnt a good start.. girl picked.was good.. i spoke third.
i entered the discussion around 4 times and gave 4 different ideas.it was peaceful GD.no cross talks,no cutting each other ,no fish market,
In the start only they specified that the summery shudnt b bullet points but should be in paragraph format.

PI: I must say puys frightened me to the core bt actually the PI wasnt too bad.. in fact i liked it a lot.

i was 5th out of 6 candidates for the interview in that panel.waited around 2 n half hrs before my turn came. every interview was on avg 30-40 min.mine was also arnd 35 min.Other panels were strict & were grilling a lot on technical stuff.My panel was cool,friendly and cordial luckily.

There are 3 prof .one was from IIM B (B1) , and 2 were from shillong,one old (S1) and one young (S2). and me.

(B1) : so you are an engineer?
me: yeah (i thought he said it sarcastically.. may b not.. who cares )
(B1) : which kind of eng are u? (again sarcasm )
me : electrical engg
(B1) : from where?
me:MNNIT allahabad
(B1) : we have a colleague of urs here.
me: i said yeah (took his name)
some more talks abt him
(B1): temme what is the difference b/w OCB n ACB
me : it took me few seconds to recall wht is OCB (prof ke zamane mein use karte honge) .still told 3 differences.satisfied.
(B1):we also have MCBs ,what type of breaker is it?
me:told
(B1):i now stay in india bt i stayed in US,temme why they use different voltage there than india. (trying to show off ,eh ?)
me:i dont kno sir
(B1):asked abt star and delta connection,why and wr we use them,which law they follow.
me:told
(B1):what all transmission losses r there?
me: (totally blank) .started giving funda which was wrong bt i corrected it soon,he gave a smile. (nice fellow )
(B1):y the voltage are alwaz 110,220,440 . why not 100,200 etc
me:told
tried to grill me more on it. bt was ok.
now he turned to other profs to grill me.
(S1): if u have to design a website for ur company,how would u design it.
me: told some funda (he was nodding intermittantly as i was talking)
(S1)k tell us the recipe of any thing which is your favourite to cook. (i wrote my hobby as cooking)
me:told.he seemed bored (may b he knew himself,stopped me in between)
(S1):choose any current scenario on which we can have a chat.
me:i told anjali waghmare taking kasab's case.
(S1):so the lawyers are free not to choose?
me:yeah
(S1):r they forced?
me:no (i dunno if i was rite or wrong.. i guess i m rite.)
(S1):why,u think she chose to take kasab's case?? to gain the glory n attention of media
me:gave funda
(S1):what comes first job ethics or patriotism?
me:gave more funda
looked at the 3rd prof n handed me over to him.
(S2):so tell us some thing about ur US trip.
me:told abt the project,y we were sent n how long (prof B1 looked interested n asked where were i in US)
(S2):how do u judge your performance in GD?
me:i said i was good.justified that. (i was actually good )
(S2):you have talked abt tecruitment in your form,temme what do u look for in a candidate while interviewing him.
me:told.he was counting on his fingers whatever i was telling.and nodding simultaneously.
(S2):what do you think we look in the candidates for IIM S interview.
me:told. gave the funda.. all 3 profs gazing at me. at other times the prof B1 was burried in his papers after he was done with me.
(S2):why we should not take u for IIM S?
me:gave some more funda
(S2):temme wt was the sensex yday,the exact figure.
me:i said dunno,i kno tht it has increased by some 300 points today,bt no exact figure.
he smiled.. in fact the prof S2 was very friendly and assuring ,as he was nodding when i was talking.
(S2):i see that you had accounts and financial management as ur optional,tell something abt accounting.
me:told abt balance sheet ,profit n loss account,ledger ,journal etc.
(S2):asked more on balance sheet ,y its called balancesheet,how it is different from P L account n abt the entries made.
me:told (looked satisfied)
(S2):what more do u rem'ber from the subject.. i nodded in negative .He continued ,hav u heard about break even point.
me:i was happy to hear tht coz i knew... i told.. <yay>
(S2):what is better : low BE point or high BE point.
me:told and explained. (seemed satiesfied)
(S2):what is our national song?
me:jan gan man
(gave me what-r-saying look)
me:vande matram
(S2):who wrote it?
me:vankim chand chatterjee
smiled and looked at other profs n said ok thanks and best of luck.

i left.. over all it was good exp..

must say a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiig post ..

ciao puys and best of luck for the rest to be interviewed..
dont get scared.. its gonna b fun 4 sure.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to gjag For This Useful Post:
anupal (07-04-2009), diablorulez (06-04-2009), Friendly Fire (07-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (06-04-2009), sarvshwet (06-04-2009), srivanchiyam (08-04-2009)
  (#24)
R.M. R.M. is offline
has no status.
Newbie PaGaL
 
Posts: 3
Join Date: Nov 2008
Groans: 0
Groaned at 12 Times in 1 Post
Thanks: 6
Thanked 4 Times in 1 Post
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 06-04-2009, 08:27 PM

PROFILE:

Acads:
X: 86.6
XII: 87
Undergrad Major - GPA/%age: 88.4

Work-Ex:
IT/2.5

CAT %ile: 91.86
DI - 93
Quant - 84
Verbal - 81
Aggregate

Extra curricular/ Hobbies/Interests(if you have mentioned them)
Basket Ball and Cooking

CASE/GD : Case Study
Topic: About a Purchase Manager who receives the request from supplier to raise the price of components.
Number of Ppl present: 10
Time: 5(to read) + 15 min (to discuss) + 5 min (to summerise)
Brief Snapshot of Discussion: Everyone got opprtunity to speak. A peaceful discussion
Other Salient Details: As whether summary was asked to be written or not, Time given, and other stuff.

PI
Panel Members Intro: Not given
Questions:
A very hectic interview. Lasted for more than 45 minutes. Asked everything, in and out.
Below are from my profile:
1) What is law of large numbers?
2) How will you analyze the risk of a chunk of coal being transferred through ship.

From hobby:
What are different types of cheese?
How can we benefit from your hobby of cooking. What all does you cook?

Technical:
What is your favorite subject at engineering?
Showed some equation asked about it's curve?

Shillong:
Tell us about shilliong?
How will you reach shillong?

Any other detail:-which you would like to provide:
Just be cool and patient.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to R.M. For This Useful Post:
diablorulez (06-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (06-04-2009), sarvshwet (06-04-2009)
  (#25)
deepcat2008 deepcat2008 is offline
has no status.
Expert PaGaL
 
Posts: 132
Join Date: Apr 2008
Groans: 1
Groaned at 2 Times in 2 Posts
Thanks: 1
Thanked 65 Times in 21 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 06-04-2009, 08:35 PM

Hi Guys,

Sorry got delayed..I would consider this as my toughest int so far
Int - 4th April, IIMB

P1,P2,P3

P1 - ok why mechanical to IT
me - blah blah
P1 - so u get exposure in core insutries also
me - bla bla
p1- ok u were interted in programming. asked me about pointers, data stacks.
me - i have not touched C/C++ since 5 years..i am working on Mainframes.
p1 - fav subject
me - thermodynamics
p1 - every mechanical engg says thermo or IC engines.tell me some subject where u read management pricnciples
me - decision modelling
p1 - what u read?
me - blah blah
p1 - tell me the m,arket strategy for selling a water bottle in rural area
me - after thinking gave some answer.grilled for 15min
p1 - technology used for water purificaion
me - no idea
p1 - i dont know how the int shifter to refrigeration..what are the refrigerants used.
me - freon
p1- thats obsolete..no longer used.
me - clueless
p1 - how u manufacture a pencil
me - shocker..no clue..gave some stupid answer.
p1 - whats drill bit..angle/
me - shocker..no clue at angle.
p1 - gear used in vehicle/car
me - stupid answer again

finally we got frustated and passed to p2

p2 - tell me abt the countrys economy
me - blah blah
p2 - gdp since 1980 -85-90-95-00-05-09
me - blahj blha
p2 - what M&A? recent
me - blah blah
p2 - if u r at onsite..will that come in GDP
me - blah blah

he gave me 4-5 similar cases and asked me whether it will come under GDP or not...was grilled for 10min on GDP..

p2 - where u stay?
me - blah blah.
p3 - I am from Rourkela..who is the MD of RSP?
me - no clue.
p2 - ok..again GDP..will investment comes under GDP?
me - blah blah
p2 - Head of UNO
m - Pascal lamy

passed to p3

p3 - what u hate abt urself the most
me - haha..

thats the end...

It was a shcoker of an interview..I never expectd of such kind..I am 3 years wrk-ex and 60% int was techical ..35% economics and 5% gk...not a single questions from work-ex..i wasn;t satisfied at all..

Hope this helps...
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to deepcat2008 For This Useful Post:
diablorulez (06-04-2009), Friendly Fire (07-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (06-04-2009), sarvshwet (06-04-2009), srivanchiyam (08-04-2009)
  (#26)
nikhil8k nikhil8k is offline
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Posts: 66
Join Date: Sep 2008
Age: 22
Groans: 9
Groaned at 7 Times in 3 Posts
Thanks: 57
Thanked 23 Times in 15 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 07-04-2009, 11:46 AM

I had my GD-PI in Bangalore on 6th

Gd-Casestudy based

PI -had 3 panelist , i was last to be interviewed
went on and on for around 35 mins . 2 profs were from IIM A
Diptest Ghosh IIMA>Faculty & Research>Faculty>Details
Raghuram IIMA>Faculty & Research>Faculty>Details

whole thing had a mixed bag feeling .
there were surely some weird questions. like
capital of kazakthan ?
headquarters of EU ?
EU and Turkey relationship ?
Switzerland and EU relations ?
name 3 cities in switzerland ?

was asked about the books i had recently read ?
Asked about some Rajat gupta , previous MD of Mckinsey ?

other than this
Was asked about Operations Research ?
was asked to solve a queing model prob

Diptest ghosh IIMA>Faculty & Research>Faculty>Details
asked me hell lot of mechanical engg .question , especially from fluid flow
Bernoulli , Navier Stroke etc ..
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to nikhil8k For This Useful Post:
atshubha (07-04-2009), diablorulez (07-04-2009), Friendly Fire (07-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (07-04-2009), sarvshwet (07-04-2009)
  (#27)
tintin&snowy tintin&snowy is offline
SP Jain beckons
Expert PaGaL
 
Posts: 171
Join Date: Mar 2007
Groans: 5
Groaned at 2 Times in 1 Post
Thanks: 228
Thanked 235 Times in 90 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 07-04-2009, 12:27 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by nikhil8k View Post
I had my GD-PI in Bangalore on 6th

Gd-Casestudy based

PI -had 3 panelist , i was last to be interviewed
went on and on for around 35 mins . 2 profs were from IIM A
Diptest Ghosh IIMA>Faculty & Research>Faculty>Details
Raghuram IIMA>Faculty & Research>Faculty>Details
Same panel for me...and the questions asked something like...
Capital of mangolia?
Where is the city p***..haven't even heard the name.
whom did vijay amritraj beat in wimbeldon q/f?
which country did len hutton play for?
who has the highest score in first class cricket?
top 5 female tennis player?
one brother-sister..playing international tennis..currently..
kim clisters ..plays for which country
chandrashekar..which constituency...does he contest elections?

though i managed a few..others were all bouncers..


_____________________________________________

PGDM 09-11 SP Jain Mumbai
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to tintin&snowy For This Useful Post:
atshubha (07-04-2009), diablorulez (07-04-2009), Friendly Fire (07-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (07-04-2009), krsh.vik (08-04-2009)
  (#28)
karthikm karthikm is offline
..............
Trainee PaGaL
 
Posts: 47
Join Date: Apr 2009
Age: 24
Groans: 3
Groaned at 0 Times in 0 Posts
Thanks: 95
Thanked 13 Times in 10 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 07-04-2009, 04:02 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by deepcat2008 View Post
Hi Guys,

Sorry got delayed..I would consider this as my toughest int so far
Int - 4th April, IIMB

P1,P2,P3

P1 - ok why mechanical to IT
me - blah blah
P1 - so u get exposure in core insutries also
me - bla bla
p1- ok u were interted in programming. asked me about pointers, data stacks.
me - i have not touched C/C++ since 5 years..i am working on Mainframes.
p1 - fav subject
me - thermodynamics
p1 - every mechanical engg says thermo or IC engines.tell me some subject where u read management pricnciples
me - decision modelling
p1 - what u read?
me - blah blah
p1 - tell me the m,arket strategy for selling a water bottle in rural area
me - after thinking gave some answer.grilled for 15min
p1 - technology used for water purificaion
me - no idea
p1 - i dont know how the int shifter to refrigeration..what are the refrigerants used.
me - freon
p1- thats obsolete..no longer used.
me - clueless
p1 - how u manufacture a pencil
me - shocker..no clue..gave some stupid answer.
p1 - whats drill bit..angle/
me - shocker..no clue at angle.
p1 - gear used in vehicle/car
me - stupid answer again

finally we got frustated and passed to p2

p2 - tell me abt the countrys economy
me - blah blah
p2 - gdp since 1980 -85-90-95-00-05-09
me - blahj blha
p2 - what M&A? recent
me - blah blah
p2 - if u r at onsite..will that come in GDP
me - blah blah

he gave me 4-5 similar cases and asked me whether it will come under GDP or not...was grilled for 10min on GDP..

p2 - where u stay?
me - blah blah.
p3 - I am from Rourkela..who is the MD of RSP?
me - no clue.
p2 - ok..again GDP..will investment comes under GDP?
me - blah blah
p2 - Head of UNO
m - Pascal lamy

passed to p3

p3 - what u hate abt urself the most
me - haha..

thats the end...

It was a shcoker of an interview..I never expectd of such kind..I am 3 years wrk-ex and 60% int was techical ..35% economics and 5% gk...not a single questions from work-ex..i wasn;t satisfied at all..

Hope this helps...

hey Deep. I think we both were interviewed by the same panel. Was a bit hostile! i got the "how to manufacture a pencil?" too
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
  (#29)
Explorer_Gagan Explorer_Gagan is offline
Life is a joke, but who's playing it?
Expert PaGaL
 
Posts: 183
Join Date: Feb 2009
Age: 24
Groans: 21
Groaned at 47 Times in 11 Posts
Thanks: 191
Thanked 657 Times in 117 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 07-04-2009, 07:50 PM

PROFILE:

Acads:
X: 91.0
XII: 84.2
Undergrad Major - CS - CGPA 9.71/10 (Thapar Institute of Engineering)
Work-Ex: 5 months as on Dec 31.

CAT %ile: 97.56
DI - 75.77
Quant - 96.02
Verbal - 96.67

Extra curricular/ Hobbies/Interests(if you have mentioned them)
Played Cricket at the Under - 16 State Level.

CASE/GD : Case Study
Topic: About a representative of India to the WTO. He had to take the side of either of 2 groups. 1 group was in favour of genetically modified crops, the other wasn't. Some other details about the groups were there which I've forgot till now.
Number of Ppl present: 8
Time: 5(to read) + 15 min (to discuss) + 5 min (to summerise)
Brief Snapshot of Discussion: Discussion was good, no fish market stuff. I started the discussion and chipped in in between 4-5 times. There was 1 guy who didn't speak at all. But overall it was good.

PI:-
I was the last one to be interviewed in my group. For the guys that went in earlier, they were taking 30 mins and it kept decreasing. My interview went on for 15-18 mins max.
3 panelists. P1,P2,P3.

P3:- A faculty member of IIM shillong. Have seen him in the pics. Looks a bit like Narendra Hirwani (The fat Indian leg spinner who took 16 wickets on debut against the West Indies).
P2 was fairly old. I felt he was a IIM A prof.
P1:- No details known. But he was the best out of the 3. He smiled sometimes in between. P3 had a blank look throughout the interview.

P1:- How's the weather outisde.
Me:- Told

P1:- So you're the last guy, by now u must be knowing all what we are asking inside. What have the others been saying about what we're asking.
Me: Told

P3(was looking at my marks sheets):- So you've studied Thermodynamics and Organizational Behaviour. Can u relate entropy with organizations.
Me:- Told that entropy deals with the randomness of a system. More the randomness, more the stability. Similarly if u've an organization with flexible timings, where the employees aren't too much binded by timings and all, PROVIDED THEY'RE DOING EVERYTHING ON TIME, the employee satisfaction will be more and the stability will be more.

P3:- What are the different stages of formation of a group (As i'd studied Organizational Behaviour)
Me:- Told him that in 1st stage this happens, in 2nd stage this happens and so on.

P3:- What are the names of these stages?
ME:- Sir, I don't remember the exact names.

P2:- Is there any difference between a group and a team?
Me:- (Why the hell does it even matter if there's a difference between the two?) Since i couldn't think of any answer i told no. (In hindsight i thot that there are a lot of differences, but again the question remains, what is the use?)

P3:- Ok you've studied IPR (Intellectual Property Rights) in ur college. Can u tell me some controversy / criticism of the same.
Me: Told

P2:- What is Data masking? Is there a difference between Data Masking/ Data Encryption
Me: (Folks, this is what i work on, Data Masking.) I told that there's no diff, it's just for marketing reasons we call it Data Masking.

P2:- Asked something related to How Data Masking is done.
Me: Explained.

P2:- Do u do bit by bit Masking
Me: yes

P2:- Ok so bits can be Masked only in 2 ways, 0 or 1. So u have only 2 options that means.
Me:- (It just kind of skipped out of my head that we dont do bit by bit Data masking) Sir, we don't do bit by bit masking but character by character masking.

P2:- How many bits does your character occupy.
Me:- It depends on the encoding. For ASCII it is 8, for UTF-16 it is 16, for UTF-32 it is 32.

P1:- Ok so your father is an IAS officer, didn't he tell you to go into the IAS
Me:- Told that why i wanted to do an MBA and why IAS wasn't the way to go.

P1:- Ok how many seats are in the Lok Sabha?
Me:- 543, though I'm not sure sir.

P1:- Rajya Sabha?
Me:- 250.

P1:- How many of them are nominated by the Prez?
Me:- 12

P1:- How're the other 238 elected?
Me:- Answered, was 75% correct in the answer.

P1:- Why don't you join Politics if you want to help the society?
Me:- Told.

P1:- Ok, your father is Director Lotteries. Aren't lotteries bad, only a few states have Govt. Lotteries? Why does the Govt. run the Lottery business.
Me:- Explained in detail the differences b/w Govt. and Private Lotteries.

P3:- (Since i had told earlier that i wanted to start a Microfinance organization to help reduce the poor) Asked me about some companies dealing with MicroFinance
Me:- Didn't know.

P3:- How much % is charged on Microfinance loans?
Me: Don't know the exact figure but it is significantly lower than the commercial banks.

P3:- Can u give an estimate?
Me:- Close to 4%

P3:- Asked 3-4 more questions related to Microfinance. These weren't related to How it operates (what I'd prepared for) but related to some facts like what're the various companies and all?
Me: Kept saying no.

P3:- Ok, just tell me what is microfinance?
Me:- Told.

P3:- A guy from Bangalore is very famous in this? DO u know who?
Me:- No (again), but i Know of Mohammad Yunus of Bangladesh who started the Grameen Bank.

P2:- Who is Lee Corbuzier?
Me:- The Architect who designed Chandigarh (Asked me this since I'm from Punjab and my dad's posted in Chandigarh).

P1,P2,P3: Ok u can leave.
Me:- (Aayein?? It's only been 15 minutes).

Puys,
I don't know what to make of this. There are 2 issues that're keeping me worried.
1. I gave a lot of No's as answers aboout stuff related to Microfinance,something that I should have known about since I mentioned I plan to take it up.

2. My interview lasted only 15 mins. I wasn't questioned from very few domains.

Seniors, will point number 2 harm me in any ways??
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Explorer_Gagan For This Useful Post:
Friendly Fire (08-04-2009), garg04 (09-04-2009), jinesh_249 (08-04-2009), sarvshwet (07-04-2009), srivanchiyam (08-04-2009)
  (#30)
Explorer_Gagan Explorer_Gagan is offline
Life is a joke, but who's playing it?
Expert PaGaL
 
Posts: 183
Join Date: Feb 2009
Age: 24
Groans: 21
Groaned at 47 Times in 11 Posts
Thanks: 191
Thanked 657 Times in 117 Posts
Re: [2009-2011]IIM Shillong GD/PI Experiences - 07-04-2009, 07:56 PM

Sorry, there was a Typo in the post above

-->I WASN'T questioned from very few domains. @@ I WAS questioned from very few domains.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usStumble this Post!
» Quote
» Post Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

Forum Jump

» Sponsors

PaGaLGuY.com is not responsible for the views and opinions of the posters.
PaGaLGuY.com is an Inzane Labs Private Limited production.