K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - Page 3
PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA, CAT 2008, GMAT, XAT, IIM
         Home          MBA Forums         PG Office Blog         Contact Us         About Us                  Jobs @ PG
Exclusive Bschool Content:      Interviews      B-School Watch     MBAs speak     Placements     GMAT & MBA Abroad      Form Notifications
» Sponsors





Go Back   PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA, CAT 2008, GMAT, XAT, IIM > MBA Exams and Institutes - Indian Business Schools > CAT and Related Discussion

Notices
CAT and Related Discussion An Online Community to share and discuss information in regards to the toughest and most exclusive management entrance exam in India. The CAT - The Common Admission Test. Register yourself and start posting.

Tags: , , ,

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#21)
sukritmunjal
waiting for the world to change
Hardcore PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 320
Groans: 29
Groaned at 86 Times in 13 Posts
Thanks: 214
Thanked 494 Times in 136 Posts
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: bangalore
Age: 22
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 25-02-2008, 11:21 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by tvn47 View Post
Hi puys,


I was in the same slot as "srikutmunjal" was and all the process from 1 to 4 was a replica of the same(copy paste the same ).BUt my GD group was different from his.
its sukritmunjal...nd as for the results..i don't see how results would be out as they still have gd/pi process in mumbai in the last week of march


No matter how much i struggle or strive, i won't get out of this world alive.
Mocking Bird Change the username
Moi on IHT
  Send a message via Yahoo to sukritmunjal  
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#22)
ashwinc20031
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 46
Groans: 1
Groaned at 1 Time in 1 Post
Thanks: 8
Thanked 12 Times in 7 Posts
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Hyderabad
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 07:47 AM

Slot:24th Feb 1:30 PM
Step 1: Registration for the GD/PI
Step 2: Written communication test

Topics: 1)Will the slow down of the US economy affect the Indian economy as well?
2)Will Tata 'Nano' prove to be a boon or a bane?

Wrote on the second one...filled up both the pages they had given

GD: Case study about the recent shootings in schools which took place in Gurgaon and some other place in MP..Was on the verge of getting into a fish market..but was decent..managed to speak thrice..gave some valid points..average GD on the whole

PI: Two people on the panel..one was a marketing faculty(P1) and the othr was alumni(A)

P1: DO u have any work -ex?
M: No sir, Im a fresher

P1: Very good, Excellent

A: Tellme about urself in a minute.
M: Started off by telling them where I was born and brought up and directly jumped into why I wanted to do MBA..

P1: So ur from Hyderabad. What is special abt Hyderabad.
M: The Hyderabadi Biriyani if ur a food lover

A: What if im a vegetarian?
M: The veggie brand of Hyderabadi Biriyani couldnt think of anything else at that point of time ..

P1: Tellme two bad and 2 good things about India.
M: Started off by saying that our country is undergoing a cultural transition of sorts and people are unable to decide to which culture they should align themselves to and the advent of BPOs was adding fuel to all this and ws cut short by P1
P1: Yes, u r right..these days the girls smoke more than boys in BPOs
P1: SO u say that BPOs are bad
M: Not completely sir..they're revenue (cut short by P1)

P1: I asked u about 2 bad things
M: Yes sir, I was just elaborating on the 1st point..a brief silence and after that I ask if I can continue and they say yes

M: and talked abt the infrastructure not growing on par with earning capabilities of people...and was cut short..this time by A

A: SO in a nutshell u wish to say that infrastructure is bad in India

M: started off to say good things about India..said that people here are more adaptable and can face unprecedented situations than people outside..in the process brought in Geert Hofstede's analysis which shows the same.

A: Where did u come across Geert Hofstede's analysis?
M: SIr, I also worked as a freelance writer and had the opportunity of going through the cultural analysis in one of my projects.

A: So ur also a writer( while jotting down something)
M: Yes sir

A: SO what do u read?
M: Books

A: What do u read..I meant novels or magazines or wot?
M: I occasionally read novels sir

A: What was ur last book?
M: FPS

A: Who's the author?
M: Chetan Bhagat.

A: What's his background?
M:He had done his B.Tech from IIT-D and went on to persue MBA from IIM-A.

P1: What was the major learning from that book?
M: That one should'nt mess around with his or her acads

P1: Oh! I thought it was the other way round. I thought the moral was one can come out successful even if he/she messes around with acads.
M: That happens very rarely and the author wanted to add in some commercial value. We Indians wouldnt like tragic stories

P1: What was ur last movie?
M: blah

P1:Learning, if any from that movie?
M: blah

A: What's ur goal in life?
M: To start an IT consulting firm

A: But there r so many firms in the market.How do u think u make someone approach u ?
M: Sir, that depends on how well I makrket my organization and that's precisely why Im here to take a course in marketing

A: SO u were a mamber of AIESEC. weRe u on the national level of AIESEC or on the local chapter?
M: Was on the local chapter as Team Leader.

A: What's the strength of AIESEC in Hyderabad?
M: Its arnd 40 at the moment sir.

A: Its increased so much

P1: Ok Ashwin! 1 last question..this time u ask us a question.
A: Asked them abt the composition based on the backgrounds of students and how often the grp tasks are conducted.

That's it
P1: Call in the next person after 2 mins...

That's abt it puys..what do u say? no acads..no technical questions..no certificates asked except the somaiya form..
  Send a message via Yahoo to ashwinc20031 Send a message via MSN to ashwinc20031  
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#23)
tvn47
SIMSR -PGDM -2008-10
Expert PaGaL
 
tvn47's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 181
Groans: 2
Groaned at 2 Times in 2 Posts
Thanks: 32
Thanked 69 Times in 43 Posts
Join Date: May 2007
Location: chennai
Age: 24
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 08:53 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by ashwinc20031 View Post
Slot:24th Feb 1:30 PM
Step 1: Registration for the GD/PI
Step 2: Written communication test

Topics: 1)Will the slow down of the US economy affect the Indian economy as well?
2)Will Tata 'Nano' prove to be a boon or a bane?

Wrote on the second one...filled up both the pages they had given

GD: Case study about the recent shootings in schools which took place in Gurgaon and some other place in MP..Was on the verge of getting into a fish market..but was decent..managed to speak thrice..gave some valid points..average GD on the whole

PI: Two people on the panel..one was a marketing faculty(P1) and the othr was alumni(A)

P1: DO u have any work -ex?
M: No sir, Im a fresher

P1: Very good, Excellent

A: Tellme about urself in a minute.
M: Started off by telling them where I was born and brought up and directly jumped into why I wanted to do MBA..

P1: So ur from Hyderabad. What is special abt Hyderabad.
M: The Hyderabadi Biriyani if ur a food lover

A: What if im a vegetarian?
M: The veggie brand of Hyderabadi Biriyani couldnt think of anything else at that point of time ..

P1: Tellme two bad and 2 good things about India.
M: Started off by saying that our country is undergoing a cultural transition of sorts and people are unable to decide to which culture they should align themselves to and the advent of BPOs was adding fuel to all this and ws cut short by P1
P1: Yes, u r right..these days the girls smoke more than boys in BPOs
P1: SO u say that BPOs are bad
M: Not completely sir..they're revenue (cut short by P1)

P1: I asked u about 2 bad things
M: Yes sir, I was just elaborating on the 1st point..a brief silence and after that I ask if I can continue and they say yes

M: and talked abt the infrastructure not growing on par with earning capabilities of people...and was cut short..this time by A

A: SO in a nutshell u wish to say that infrastructure is bad in India

M: started off to say good things about India..said that people here are more adaptable and can face unprecedented situations than people outside..in the process brought in Geert Hofstede's analysis which shows the same.

A: Where did u come across Geert Hofstede's analysis?
M: SIr, I also worked as a freelance writer and had the opportunity of going through the cultural analysis in one of my projects.

A: So ur also a writer( while jotting down something)
M: Yes sir

A: SO what do u read?
M: Books

A: What do u read..I meant novels or magazines or wot?
M: I occasionally read novels sir

A: What was ur last book?
M: FPS

A: Who's the author?
M: Chetan Bhagat.

A: What's his background?
M:He had done his B.Tech from IIT-D and went on to persue MBA from IIM-A.

P1: What was the major learning from that book?
M: That one should'nt mess around with his or her acads

P1: Oh! I thought it was the other way round. I thought the moral was one can come out successful even if he/she messes around with acads.
M: That happens very rarely and the author wanted to add in some commercial value. We Indians wouldnt like tragic stories

P1: What was ur last movie?
M: blah

P1:Learning, if any from that movie?
M: blah

A: What's ur goal in life?
M: To start an IT consulting firm

A: But there r so many firms in the market.How do u think u make someone approach u ?
M: Sir, that depends on how well I makrket my organization and that's precisely why Im here to take a course in marketing

A: SO u were a mamber of AIESEC. weRe u on the national level of AIESEC or on the local chapter?
M: Was on the local chapter as Team Leader.

A: What's the strength of AIESEC in Hyderabad?
M: Its arnd 40 at the moment sir.

A: Its increased so much

P1: Ok Ashwin! 1 last question..this time u ask us a question.
A: Asked them abt the composition based on the backgrounds of students and how often the grp tasks are conducted.

That's it
P1: Call in the next person after 2 mins...

That's abt it puys..what do u say? no acads..no technical questions..no certificates asked except the somaiya form..

Hi ashwin,

Nice Post .Well you told the famous things in Hyderabad as I had in mind.But some fine tuning for future....
1."PARADISE BRIYANI" - CHICKEN/MUTTON/EGG/VEG
2.IRANI CHAI
3.PEARLS....
Thats My understanding correct me if any....


MY CALLS IN 2007

IIMs - A,B,C,K,L,I

S.P.JAIN,SIBM,XLRI,XIMB,SCMHRD, GREAT LAKES,IIFT

!!!!UNFORTUNATELY ALL WERE MISSED CALLS!!!

TVN
   
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#24)
tvn47
SIMSR -PGDM -2008-10
Expert PaGaL
 
tvn47's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 181
Groans: 2
Groaned at 2 Times in 2 Posts
Thanks: 32
Thanked 69 Times in 43 Posts
Join Date: May 2007
Location: chennai
Age: 24
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 08:54 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by sukritmunjal View Post
its sukritmunjal...nd as for the results..i don't see how results would be out as they still have gd/pi process in mumbai in the last week of march
Hi,

I think I have said that GDPI process ends on 30.03.8 in one of the posts.
The results will be out only then...


MY CALLS IN 2007

IIMs - A,B,C,K,L,I

S.P.JAIN,SIBM,XLRI,XIMB,SCMHRD, GREAT LAKES,IIFT

!!!!UNFORTUNATELY ALL WERE MISSED CALLS!!!

TVN
   
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#25)
ashwinc20031
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 46
Groans: 1
Groaned at 1 Time in 1 Post
Thanks: 8
Thanked 12 Times in 7 Posts
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Hyderabad
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 09:35 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by tvn47 View Post
Hi ashwin,

Nice Post .Well you told the famous things in Hyderabad as I had in mind.But some fine tuning for future....
1."PARADISE BRIYANI" - CHICKEN/MUTTON/EGG/VEG
2.IRANI CHAI
3.PEARLS....
Thats My understanding correct me if any....
Oh yes! I forgot to mention..there was also a mention of paradise..apparently the marketing faculty was from Hyderabad and stayed near the paradise area in Hyd..and yeah, I couldve brought Irani Chai into the discussion ..though didnt know much abt pearls n all
  Send a message via Yahoo to ashwinc20031 Send a message via MSN to ashwinc20031  
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#26)
nihit
thinking!!!
Addicted PaGaL
 
nihit's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 1,247
Groans: 9
Groaned at 15 Times in 14 Posts
Thanks: 141
Thanked 377 Times in 241 Posts
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Mumbai > Hyderabad > Gandhinagar
Age: 23
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 10:36 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by ashwinc20031 View Post
Oh yes! I forgot to mention..there was also a mention of paradise..apparently the marketing faculty was from Hyderabad and stayed near the paradise area in Hyd..and yeah, I couldve brought Irani Chai into the discussion ..though didnt know much abt pearls n all
Yeh buddy...

Pearl was the most important thing... Infact ppl outside hyd knows hyd bcoz of 3 things...

1) Hyderabadi Biryani...

2) Hyd main moti acche milte hain (i.e Pearls)

3) Hyd ki Biscuits (i.e Karachi Biscuits)


!! Nothing Is ImpOssiBle tO a WillinG hEart !!


!~ ~¤§wêʱ°ñ°§ôû®¤~ ~!


Think and move on, rethinking leads to confusion and confusion leads to half hearted efforts which finally leads to half hearted results.

  Send a message via Yahoo to nihit  
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#27)
ashwinc20031
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 46
Groans: 1
Groaned at 1 Time in 1 Post
Thanks: 8
Thanked 12 Times in 7 Posts
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Hyderabad
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 11:04 AM

hmm..true..shouldve brought in pearls as well..lekin kya kare?? wo time ko kuch yaad nahi aaya

Quote:
Originally Posted by nihit View Post
Yeh buddy...

Pearl was the most important thing... Infact ppl outside hyd knows hyd bcoz of 3 things...

1) Hyderabadi Biryani...

2) Hyd main moti acche milte hain (i.e Pearls)

3) Hyd ki Biscuits (i.e Karachi Biscuits)
  Send a message via Yahoo to ashwinc20031 Send a message via MSN to ashwinc20031  
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#28)
rhetoric
has no status.
Newbie PaGaL
 
rhetoric's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Groans: 0
Groaned at 0 Times in 0 Posts
Thanks: 6
Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Chennai
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 12:24 PM

Hiya All,

Am a lil late in posting my experience (23rd, 1.30 slot!!!)......
but still, better late than never
of course, all u guys must have got a fair idea of the proceedings..
--registration
--presentation on SIMSR
--written communication (I chose the Indian cinema topic...did ok..)
--psychometric test
then comes the splitting into diff groups for GD/PI
had the Heena case study for GD...

Well...when it was my turn to give the one min intro (2nd in line) I gave an overall pic abt the case study...didnt start off with my view points...but instead mentioned that the scope of discussion cld be abt the education system's merits and demerits....etc...etc....
I thot it made more sense to discuss in general than to start off with my points (wat wld i do while discussing then??!!!)
As usual, we started off with some valid points but a lil later seemed to be bickering over nothing (fish/meat market..watever!!) n so the panel decided to end it....no summarization...nothing....ppl who saved it for the end..well it wasnt their day!!!
I was the only gal in the group....n of course I do have a loud voice...I think i butted in a couple of times (with valid points??..err...)....so do put two n two together to gauge my performance (coz am !!!)

Now comes the PI....well 2nd in line didnt work here...the panel decided to start from the last person....so had a looooong wait....
finally went in....my panel had two members..no ladies...
P1(even b4 i sat down!!!):ure from Wipro...wats diff abt Wipro?? frm the other top companies??
me:told abt leading in R & D....told abt our WASE initiative.. COE..etc... (i think i did justice..coz i had prepared for this ques)
P2: abt my client?
me:answered...
P2:abt my career goal?
me:elaborated (FYI....i want to start a management institute)
P2:there are already 20 odd bschools doing nothing....u want to add to that list??
me:i told them i was interested in spreading education...my bschool wld gather students who r interested in propagating education to every nook n corner...not usual placement oriented bschool...etc..etc....
P1:so then u can start a school?y bschool??primary education is imp rite?
me: if i start a school i wld cater to only a small sector instead i am trying to bring out number of administrators who can in turn spread education...and this wld be more effective and wide spread....
P2:started talking abt how KJ somaiya was also helping out rural ppl..thru their Sugar industry....students involvement..etc..etc..etc.abt green technology..i managed to say a lil abt tata nano (here again only one liner.. mind ya)..etc..etc...etc.....(spoke for quite some time!!!)...finally said something like good..very good for my goals?! (smilingly!!!)
P2: questions?
me(shocked!! thats it???thats it??????): i asked 2 ques....for which i got a detailed answer...


Well guys....i really dont have much to say except ALL THE BEST....
i am kinda confused....did i do well??didnt i do well???no clue.....any kind hearts have words of consolation for me?? am all ears!!!!!!!




   
Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to rhetoric For This Useful Post:
coolsumeet (07-03-2008), loveekansal (26-02-2008), sb29 (07-03-2008)
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#29)
loveekansal
has no status.
Hardcore PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 526
Groans: 7
Groaned at 9 Times in 8 Posts
Thanks: 29
Thanked 255 Times in 170 Posts
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Noida
Age: 24
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 12:35 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by rhetoric View Post
Hiya All,

Am a lil late in posting my experience (23rd, 1.30 slot!!!)......
but still, better late than never
of course, all u guys must have got a fair idea of the proceedings..
--registration
--presentation on SIMSR
--written communication (I chose the Indian cinema topic...did ok..)
--psychometric test
then comes the splitting into diff groups for GD/PI
had the Heena case study for GD...

Well...when it was my turn to give the one min intro (2nd in line) I gave an overall pic abt the case study...didnt start off with my view points...but instead mentioned that the scope of discussion cld be abt the education system's merits and demerits....etc...etc....
I thot it made more sense to discuss in general than to start off with my points (wat wld i do while discussing then??!!!)
As usual, we started off with some valid points but a lil later seemed to be bickering over nothing (fish/meat market..watever!!) n so the panel decided to end it....no summarization...nothing....ppl who saved it for the end..well it wasnt their day!!!
I was the only gal in the group....n of course I do have a loud voice...I think i butted in a couple of times (with valid points??..err...)....so do put two n two together to gauge my performance (coz am !!!)

Now comes the PI....well 2nd in line didnt work here...the panel decided to start from the last person....so had a looooong wait....
finally went in....my panel had two members..no ladies...
P1(even b4 i sat down!!!):ure from Wipro...wats diff abt Wipro?? frm the other top companies??
me:told abt leading in R & D....told abt our WASE initiative.. COE..etc... (i think i did justice..coz i had prepared for this ques)
P2: abt my client?
me:answered...
P2:abt my career goal?
me:elaborated (FYI....i want to start a management institute)
P2:there are already 20 odd bschools doing nothing....u want to add to that list??
me:i told them i was interested in spreading education...my bschool wld gather students who r interested in propagating education to every nook n corner...not usual placement oriented bschool...etc..etc....
P1:so then u can start a school?y bschool??primary education is imp rite?
me: if i start a school i wld cater to only a small sector instead i am trying to bring out number of administrators who can in turn spread education...and this wld be more effective and wide spread....
P2:started talking abt how KJ somaiya was also helping out rural ppl..thru their Sugar industry....students involvement..etc..etc..etc.abt green technology..i managed to say a lil abt tata nano (here again only one liner.. mind ya)..etc..etc...etc.....(spoke for quite some time!!!)...finally said something like good..very good for my goals?! (smilingly!!!)
P2: questions?
me(shocked!! thats it???thats it??????): i asked 2 ques....for which i got a detailed answer...


Well guys....i really dont have much to say except ALL THE BEST....
i am kinda confused....did i do well??didnt i do well???no clue.....any kind hearts have words of consolation for me?? am all ears!!!!!!!
i am yet to appear for my gd/pi... i hv a few queries...
1. wht was the avg. duration of PI at ur centre?
2. during GD, do we hv to start by giving our intro or just start on the topic given?
   
Reply With Quote
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience
Old
  (#30)
rhetoric
has no status.
Newbie PaGaL
 
rhetoric's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Groans: 0
Groaned at 0 Times in 0 Posts
Thanks: 6
Thanked 6 Times in 3 Posts
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Chennai
Re: K.J Somaiya 2008-2010 GD/PI experience - 26-02-2008, 01:35 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by loveekansal View Post
i am yet to appear for my gd/pi... i hv a few queries...
1. wht was the avg. duration of PI at ur centre?
2. during GD, do we hv to start by giving our intro or just start on the topic given?
1. i guess it was 10-15 mins.... though there was a person in our group who was in for 30+mins!!!!
2. in our gd they had specifically allotted 1 min per person for intro/our view point of the case study and then they started the discussion.....
hope this helps.....
   
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump