[2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - Page 15
PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA, CAT 2008, GMAT, XAT, IIM
         Home          MBA Forums         PG Office Blog         Contact Us         About Us                  Jobs @ PG
Exclusive Bschool Content:      Interviews      B-School Watch     MBAs speak     Placements     GMAT & MBA Abroad      Form Notifications
» Sponsors





Go Back   PaGaLGuY.com - The Everything of MBA, CAT 2008, GMAT, XAT, IIM > MBA Exams and Institutes - Indian Business Schools > CAT and Related Discussion

Notices
CAT and Related Discussion An Online Community to share and discuss information in regards to the toughest and most exclusive management entrance exam in India. The CAT - The Common Admission Test. Register yourself and start posting.

Tags: , , ,

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#141)
iamleonidas
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 49
Groans: 2
Groaned at 5 Times in 2 Posts
Thanks: 82
Thanked 49 Times in 9 Posts
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Kolkata
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 16-02-2008, 09:28 PM

Puys
my time to do a smallish contribution
so here's my interview of IIM L

Today
10 am
Bangalore

GD Topic
Helping hands are better than praying lips
500 words essay
.. bla bla bla .
then the panelist said abt writing it on a rough sheet .. as this will be your GD topic as well
i din have a paper .. got it from the guy next to me

then the moment the essay ended .. bang ..start your GD
no time to think and recollect .. and a guy started ..
i was second (or third) to enter ..
GD was nice . .full of examples ... a person tried to guide the discussion but alas ..
rest all was fine ... everyone had his/her time to speak ..
no conclusion though .. the only girl in our panel was speaking but was interupted in b/w saying time up .. thanks.. wait out for interview

panel is same as the one in GD
two proffs . P1 (young n smiling guy ) P2 (lil ol ..but .. smiling guy ) both very friendly and cool
n me the chief guest of the session

knock knock ..
M: may i come in (they were talking abt ..personality .. content .. may b of the guy who just left )
P1 : ya please .. take ur seat
P1 : your certis please .. hmm mr jain .. speak something ab jainism for 1min
Me : bla bla bla
P1 : some question related to this . jain food .. y wat etc etc
ME : bla bla bla
more bla bla
P1: ok now speak abt yourself
ME : .. BLA BLA BLA
stopped ..
P1 looking at my face ..
so i started again .. bla blabla
stopped ... then i asked .. do u want something specific

then P2: (the saviour ) started abt my work ..
P2: (not a saviour any more ) .. this that .. streaming .. y how where
how to increase efficiency ...
P1: enjoyin the scene .. or his face is just a nice smiling one.. ..
Me : BLA BLA BLA
P2: wat is mocai (or something similar... i got to lookup now )
ME : dont know
P2: ok .. explain abt streaming
ME : did ..
P2: some more from that ..
ME : i came up with CDN .. that made him happy i guess ..
P2: right right .. example ???
ME : donno ...
P2: i gave that example just now
Me : (fir se de dijye plzzzzz)
P2: mocai ..
P1: jharkhand .. okie when was it formed ..y was it formed .. who's the cm
ME : BLA
P1: who did he replace
ME: mainu nai pata
P1: comon . some munda ..
ME: ..
P1: who's the MLA from ranchi
ME : constipated face .. i knew it .. but forgot
P1: do u vote
ME: no
P1 : Y
ME: bla bla
P1: good .. u r honest

P1: ok .. thats all ..here's your certis

m goin out then suddenly
P1: hey .. how many callls u have ???
ME : the rest 5

okie .. good luck .. all the best
send the next guy



comments ... feedback .. guys .. pour in


FIGHT IS ON
   
Reply With Quote
The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to iamleonidas For This Useful Post:
accenture07 (17-02-2008), akshatagarwal (18-02-2008), ashish abraham (16-02-2008), getneonow (18-02-2008), Jok3r (17-02-2008), Karti (20-02-2008), rjt163 (17-02-2008)
Sponsored Links
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#142)
route_to_perdition
has no status.
Expert PaGaL
 
route_to_perdition's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 100
Groans: 45
Groaned at 9 Times in 3 Posts
Thanks: 311
Thanked 40 Times in 21 Posts
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Bangalore
Age: 26
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 17-02-2008, 04:51 PM

My IIML GD PI experience

16 Feb 2008, 10 am slot
Venue: Hotel Monarch Luxur, Bangalore

Profile
CAT 98.84
10th 78.6%
12th 89.2%
BE(Mech) 59.93% aggregate (Pune University)
Work Ex 43 months - Infosys -> Cisco Systems.

This is the only IIM call I have.. Reached the venue at 9:10 am. To my surprise, most junta was already there, with my friend there asking me how I am so late . Chatted up with people there before the start of the proceedings…

8 of the 10 people turned up in my group..

GD Topic: “Helping hands are better than praying lips”
Was only able to write 3.25 pages of the 4 pages asked of us .

GD was decent.. everyone spoke, no one had really fantastic points.. everyone chipped in with some points.. I got off to a nervous start, language not really flowing smoothly in my first entry… But afterward I spoke reasonably clearly and got in a couple of decent points… Was not really happy with my written or the GD, felt I was not able to make an impression.
Group was same as misnomer, who posted on the previous page.



Interview
Panellist1, 2 -> P1, P2
[Found this later…. P1 was Dr Abhishek Nirjar, of the Strategic Management Group at IIML
P2 was Dr Madusudan Karmakar of the Finance and Accounting Group]

P1: So.. Army Institute of Technology, eh.. Some army connection?
Yes sir… My father is a doctor in the army.
P1: So what happened at this Army Institute of Technology? You had 78, 89% in 10th and 12th, so how did you drop down in academics?
(I had 59.9% aggregate) Spoke about 65% in my BE degree, and that Univ topper was 75%. Also spoke about extra curriculars.. being part of the squash team, doing a certificate course in graphology, more sports..
P1: So did you not think about joining the NDA, IMA? You were scared?
I smiled.. Spoke about how I wanted to be a part of the India growth story by contributing to profits of companies. And while it is a noble service, it is no longer the place it used to be during my father’s time..
P1: Name the top most squash player today..
Said top ranked was Amr Shabana, but the player to win the last World Open was Ramy Ashour
P1: Do you know any Indian player?
Said that there is a 49th ranked player.. Sourav Ghosal
P1: Any other Indians?
Said didn’t know of others
P1: But the army does come up with lot of squash players isn’t it
Spoke about the army’s emphasis on sports
P1: So why did you move from Mech Engg to IT?
Told about my interest in computers, and that I saw opportunities in the booming IT sector, so wanted to be part of it.
P1: But you have studied subjects like CAD/ CAM and other fascinating subjects, why not do something in that?
Spoke about opportunities being available in IT with lot of growth happening in this sector.
P1: What do you at Cisco
Told I was part of the test team for a new router that Cisco is coming out with, and told about my previous and current assignment.. mentioned the award I had got at Cisco

P2 takes over now, P1 lays back on his chair’s backrest and closes his eyes


P2: You have mentioned that you like tracking stock markets… tell us about that
Spoke about my starting to invest in stock markets after starting to earn… as a great way to learn about businesses and make some savings
P2: So do you do trading or are you a long term investor
Said I was an investor, and liked to pick value stocks
P2: So how do you pick the stocks?
Said I looked into the kind of business the company is in, the business environment, the prospects of the business.. (was interrupted)
P2: How do you judge the prospects of the business?
Took the example of IT sector, how it was the favorite a few years ago, and how rupee appreciation has hurt it….
P2: So you will sell your IT stocks?
Yes sir, I have already exited
P2: whats the value of your portfolio?
Investment amount is 2.5 lakh, market value is 3.2 lakh.
P2: You know about GDP.. what is the contribution of agriculture to the GDP
Told it was between 19 and 20%
P2: The government is taking land from agriculture for setting up industries.. Your view?
Told about how farmers are attached to their land and feel they are unfairly dealt with in regards to compensation. However, the govts do this to spur economic growth.. so while I support this, there needs to be better implementation of the same.
P2: What is the current rate of inflation?
Said it was around 3.8 to 4%
P2: You know about the price hike which came into effect yesterday.. Rs 2 for petrol and 1 for diesel.. How do you think this will impact inflation?
Said increase will impact prices of all commodities, so inflation would increase and this is a concern
P2: Whats the trend in inflation?
Said inflation was on the increase, having increased from 3% last year, and that its expected to increase further to 4.5%
P2: But we have been seeing a steady rate of inflation in the past couple of years.. isn’t that good
Said that the concerns are real and that the indicated inflation might not reflect the actual increase in prices…. spoke about how the indicator used - the WPI is questionable on two counts… first, the goods and services taken into consideration are not representative of the basket consumed. Second, the actual prices that the end consumer gets could be much higher than the wholesale prices that we take into account for the calculation..
P2: Ok, I think we are done here.. shall we wrap it up..

P1 pounces..

P1: I have one last question.. You have studied Industrial Management in your engineering.. Do you know of <insert a few unrecognizable terms>
No sir.. don’t know of it
P1: So what did you study in IM?
Said studied about Linear programming, transport problems, queuing, optimization, organizational behaviour…
P2: Oh they only teach you that much in your college..
P2: Ok, thank you and do take your file..
Thank you..



That was it.. No Why MBA, strengths weaknesses, no grilling on academics.. Feel good interview, was satisfied with my answers.


There are 10 kinds of people in this world.. those who understand binary and those that get laid

My IIML interview experience

CAT 2007: 98.84%ile, one call (L)
CAT 2006: 94 %ile, Final admit to NMIMS
CAT 2005: 98.11%ile, no calls
CAT 2003: 98.45%ile, no calls

Last edited by route_to_perdition; 18-02-2008 at 02:17 PM.
  Send a message via Yahoo to route_to_perdition  
Reply With Quote
The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to route_to_perdition For This Useful Post:
accenture07 (17-02-2008), akshatagarwal (18-02-2008), getneonow (18-02-2008), gpat (22-02-2008), Jok3r (18-02-2008), Karti (20-02-2008), rjt163 (17-02-2008), sumitrocks (17-02-2008)
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#143)
misnomer
is zen!!
Expert PaGaL
 
misnomer's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Groans: 9
Groaned at 25 Times in 13 Posts
Thanks: 95
Thanked 191 Times in 43 Posts
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ahmedabad -> Surathkal -> Joka
Age: 21
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 17-02-2008, 07:18 PM

@ route_to_perdition
Good interview man.
I'm pretty sure P2 was Dr. Madhusudhan Karmakar, Director of Finance group or something..

Last edited by misnomer; 17-02-2008 at 07:25 PM.
   
Reply With Quote
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#144)
avi_mba
has no status.
Expert PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 137
Groans: 36
Groaned at 12 Times in 9 Posts
Thanks: 209
Thanked 243 Times in 62 Posts
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bangalore
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 17-02-2008, 07:48 PM

My experience at IIML

Venue: Hotel Monarch Luxur, Bangalore
Date: 16/2/2008
Time: 2:00 pm

Profile: %ile 99.86 (BLACKI)
X - 95.6
XII - 93.8
B.Tech - 8.75/10 (IIT)
Work-ex - 18 months in mobile software

Essay and GD: Necessity is the mother of ALL inventions.

We were a group of 8 people given 30 min to write a summary, which was followed by GD for about 15 min.

I wrote a good essay, and gave good contribution to the group. Brought few ideas like Maslows need hierarchy, invention of the wheel, how invention becomes the mother of neccesity at times (gave the example of Pepsi/Coke), and some others. On two occasions I was at a loss for words, and at one time it was very apparent (pause of abt 5 sec). Still, felt like GD was very good.

PI was very weird, I still dont know what to make of it. Panel had two professors male (P1) and female (P2).
Both were extremely cordial. So much so that I didnt feel it was an interview.

I was the 4th person to be called.

P1: Tell me about yrself.
Me: Blah blah (spoke very fast, I still dont know why, maybe I practiced so much that it felt like I have mugged up )
P1: Why are u speaking so quickly, go slowly.
P2: Are u nervous?
P1: No he's not nervous.
(I shake my head to convey No)
P1: Have u heard of Ramdev?
Me: Yes sir (told a little about him)
P1: Do u watch his shows on TV?
Me: No sir, but my father told him one of his excercises which is to cover on of your nostrils with fingers and blow through the other one, Repeat by covering the other nostril and so on.
P1: Do u know the name of this?
Me: No Sir.
P1: Its called LomVilom, the other one is called Kapal Bharti (explained a little to me)
Me (wondering if I have come to the correct interview .... Ramdev why? was it because I mentioned Coke/Pepsi in GD and hes a staunch opposer of coke, but still I gotta say something): Sir, is Kapal Bharti something to do with head because Kapal means head?
(P2 had the look which said whats going on, but I had to say something)
P1: No, its just a name, if u do these two excercises, 99% of illness will not occur (explained a little more)
Me (listening intently): Acha (Yes I said Acha, I still dont know why, probably because they were so cordial, it felt more of a coffee-table conversation rather than an Interview)
P1: So now tell me about yourself.
Me: Repeated the same stuff, slowing down and taking pause. Told a little about my business family background and how I contributed to it.
P2: So u seem to be a great fan of Maslow, tell me where do u belong.
Me: Ma'm I belong some where in the 3rd (need for love) and 4th (esteem needs). I am yet to achieve self-actualization.
(P2 had the look that I said something wrong about the hierarchy, but she quickly nodded. P1 meanwhile was scanning thru my sheets)
P2: So, business, job and now MBA. Why?
Me: (I rattled the prepared answer, now I feel I again said stuff very fast)
P2: So you would start a business of your own.
Me: I would not start a business immediately, but cannot rule it out of my long-term plans. My short term plan was to work in a company where I can further gain and apply my skills.
P1: Asked me where I live in Calcutta.
Me: Blah
P2: So you spoke something about Pepsi and Coke. Why?
Me: Ma'm I wanted to bring out the point that Necessity is not ALWAYS the mother of invention. Sometimes, its the other way around. Coke/Pepsi was not a necessity for people, but with good marketing they have created a need for it now.
P2: hmmm .. did u know that Coke (or Pepsi, dont remember which 1) was started during war times?
Me: No Ma'm i didnt know it.
P2: And they targeted soldiers. Every soldier should have a bottle within arm's reach.
Me: Perhaps, their strategy failed, but its doing well now.
P2: Yes strategies change.
P2: So why dont you do your PGP in IIM Cal?
Me: Ma'm I have calls from all the IIMs. But as of now I am focussed on performing in the GD/PI to the best of my ability. Once I clear it, I would make a decision blah blah.
P2 and P1: Thanks, you may go.

My feedback: Needless to say I was shocked. No acads, no work-ex, no current affairs. I feel probably I pissed them off my speaking fast even after they pointed me out.
Anyways, would try to do better for the 4 interviews coming up.

Feedbacks are welcome.

Verdict: Converted.

Last edited by avi_mba; 04-05-2008 at 03:22 PM.
   
Reply With Quote
The Following 11 Users Say Thank You to avi_mba For This Useful Post:
accenture07 (17-02-2008), akshatagarwal (18-02-2008), AlpeshChaudhari (21-03-2008), arvindc (19-02-2008), esh.nil (18-02-2008), getneonow (18-02-2008), gpat (22-02-2008), Karti (20-02-2008), rjt163 (17-02-2008), shrijalohade (29-02-2008), yashwanthreddy (25-08-2008)
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#145)
route_to_perdition
has no status.
Expert PaGaL
 
route_to_perdition's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 100
Groans: 45
Groaned at 9 Times in 3 Posts
Thanks: 311
Thanked 40 Times in 21 Posts
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Bangalore
Age: 26
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 17-02-2008, 08:03 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by misnomer View Post
@ route_to_perdition
Good interview man.
I'm pretty sure P2 was Dr. Madhusudhan Karmakar, Director of Finance group or something..
I think you might be right! Do you remember the name from when it was announced? If you are sure, I will edit my post


There are 10 kinds of people in this world.. those who understand binary and those that get laid

My IIML interview experience

CAT 2007: 98.84%ile, one call (L)
CAT 2006: 94 %ile, Final admit to NMIMS
CAT 2005: 98.11%ile, no calls
CAT 2003: 98.45%ile, no calls
  Send a message via Yahoo to route_to_perdition  
Reply With Quote
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#146)
misnomer
is zen!!
Expert PaGaL
 
misnomer's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Groans: 9
Groaned at 25 Times in 13 Posts
Thanks: 95
Thanked 191 Times in 43 Posts
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ahmedabad -> Surathkal -> Joka
Age: 21
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 17-02-2008, 08:18 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by route_to_perdition View Post
I think you might be right! Do you remember the name from when it was announced? If you are sure, I will edit my post

i'm pretty sure it was Dr. Karmakar..
   
Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to misnomer For This Useful Post:
route_to_perdition (18-02-2008)
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#147)
esh.nil
has no status
Hardcore PaGaL
 
esh.nil's Avatar
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 622
Groans: 0
Groaned at 4 Times in 4 Posts
Thanks: 656
Thanked 546 Times in 228 Posts
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Bangalore
Age: 23
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 18-02-2008, 08:59 AM

I went for my first and last call of this season yesterday.

Venue: Hotel Monarch Luxur, Bangalore
Date: 17/2/2008
Time: 10:00 am

Profile: %ile 98.57
X - 90.3
XII - 96.8
B.Tech - 8.62/10
Work-ex - 18 months in Oracle BI

Essay and GD: Thinking about the worst prepares you for the worst.

Wrote a pretty decent essay with lot of examples. 7 ppl were present in the grp of 10. GD was very good with lot of points added, came in 6-7 times. Added few new examples, countered one argument in the most polite way , also tried to help few ppl in the grp adding few words to help them complete their point.
Overall a good GD, better than all the mock GD's that I have seen and attended..

PI:
P1 : A middled aged lady prof.
P2 : A very senior prof.
E : esh.nil

I greet them and take my seat....
P2: How grateful are you to your parents (a pause) for having given you such a beautiful name
E: Explained in detail....
P2: Good
E: also added that my surname is my grandfathers name and it is a tradition
P2: So what will u name your son???
E: The sur-name is decided sir but the first name not decided yet..
P2: haven't u given it a thought??? (smiling)
E : No sir (all smiles)
P1 & P2: discussing what my name means...
E : Interrupted and explained the exact meaning..
P1 & P2 : Good...
(Wow the best start that I could have ever dreamed off)
P1: You are from guindy. What is so spl about that place??
E : Well it has my college, CEG
P1: (smiling) what else?
E : Explained abt what are all present......
P1: Good..
E : (I am the happiest man in the World)
P1: Why MBA??
E : explained.... (my personal best answer of the interview)
P1: looked pretty convinced..
P2: was browsing through my files..
P1: You told your desire is to join ____, what is the contigency plan that you will take if you get a chance there??
E: expl the problem at hand.
P1: what will the contingencey measures E??
E : Explained abt plan A and plan B
P1: nodded and looked convinced..
P2 takes over,
P2: Looks like you have done a course in TQM in your engg..
E : (TQM, TQM who??)
P2: Can you explain what it is for a layman?
E : I would try my best to explain sir!!! and explain blah blah blah..
P2: Ok Esh, do you know any quality gurus??
E : Sorry sir, I don't remember anyone now sir
P2: quotes two quality gurus and asks me if I know these ppl?
E : sorry sir, try to give an excuse for why I have not remembered them.
P2: but you have got an 'A' grade (stumped here)
E: smiled
P1: Do you know of the deming award?
E : sorry mam... I am not aware...
P1: there is one company which has its heaquarters in Guindy and won the Deming award...
E: (Oh no! why did my engg syllabus had TQM) Sorry mam, it is not a valid excuse, but I missed these details somehow mam...
P1: that's ok.. It was TVS groups..
P2: So you confined yourself to only studies??
E : (did i took that studious?? ) smiled and started explaining abt my extra-curriculars(I was the college badminton team captain.. )
P2: seemed pretty convinced...
P2: So this will be a good learning experience for rest 5 calls that you have..
E: (smiled) Sir this is my only call...
P2: (Looks surprised) what's ur percentaile...
E : told.. (98.5-di, 96-ver, 89.95 - qa, oa - 98.57)
P2: So quant denied you calls from other IIM's.. So u are weak in quant..
E : (Sensed a stress, moi quant weak?? no way) explained abt how quant was my strength and what really happened there.
P1&P2: smiling and nodding
E : finally added, though it was tough, I just barely managed to clear the cut-off and grap a call from IIM - L
(smiles all around)
P1: thank you esh, I wish you convert your L call...
E : (little surprised and shocked) Thanks for the time sir and mam.
I wish to see you soon in the near future (I am not sure if I shld have told this sentence, but just let that out)
P1&P2 : big smiles..
Thanked them again and came out...

Overall a very good interview(acc to me).. It started out in the perfect way and was progressing very good until TQM. I am not sure how much effect that is going to have on the final result, but will have my hopes alive until the results are out..

The MBA season is over for me.. All the best to all puys for their L and other interviews...


I don't believe in fate, bcos I don't like the idea that I'm not in control of my life....
http://journeytotheinevitable.blogspot.com/

Last edited by esh.nil; 18-02-2008 at 09:14 AM.
   
Reply With Quote
The Following 26 Users Say Thank You to esh.nil For This Useful Post:
abhrabumba (05-03-2008), accenture07 (18-02-2008), akshatagarwal (18-02-2008), AlpeshChaudhari (21-03-2008), anir-iim2005 (18-02-2008), aravindva (01-03-2008), arvindc (19-02-2008), ashish abraham (18-02-2008), atshubha (18-02-2008), avi_mba (18-02-2008), barunava (29-02-2008), Basilisk (18-02-2008), cl_time (19-02-2008), devang_parikh (18-02-2008), getintoiimb (18-02-2008), getneonow (18-02-2008), gpat (22-02-2008), Greenspan (18-02-2008), krsh.vik (18-02-2008), macora (18-02-2008), Obsessed_bout_mba (20-02-2008), parulbajaj (18-02-2008), RISING (19-02-2008), rjt163 (18-02-2008), route_to_perdition (18-02-2008), shrijalohade (29-02-2008)
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#148)
avi_mba
has no status.
Expert PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 137
Groans: 36
Groaned at 12 Times in 9 Posts
Thanks: 209
Thanked 243 Times in 62 Posts
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bangalore
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 18-02-2008, 01:51 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by esh.nil View Post
I went for my first and last call of this season yesterday.

Venue: Hotel Monarch Luxur, Bangalore
Date: 17/2/2008
Time: 10:00 am

P1 : A middled aged lady prof.
P2 : A very senior prof.
Looks like u and me had the same panel. I still wonder why I wasnt asked anything though! All the Best
   
Reply With Quote
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#149)
shaurya1985
has no status.
Trainee PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Groans: 31
Groaned at 8 Times in 4 Posts
Thanks: 63
Thanked 57 Times in 13 Posts
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Bangalore
Age: 23
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 18-02-2008, 08:27 PM

Hi all

Had my L interview yesterday 10:00 a.m. at Monarch Luxar, Bangalore.

Btech in Mech from IIT D 8.04/10
Exp 7 months

Percentile 99.81 BLACKI

GD - Thinking abt worst prepares for the worst

Wrote a decent essay...tried to analyse diferent dimensions of the topic...as in when worst is bound to happen and you cannot do nything, when u can avert or minimize damage of worst if u plan properly, when u shud not think abt worst..and abt balanced approach when you allocate resources to deal with the worst when it happens..gave examples on these

GD was also pretty gud..I was happy with my contribution.

I was first in my panel.

Panel of 2 ( Was really impressed by the panel; they were really gud)

YP - Young Prof
OP - Old Prof
Me - Me

Greetings etc

YP: Tell me somthing abt yourself
me: blah blah blah ( Also spoke abt my 3 interns during my stay at IIT and my interest in sports)
YP: Tell me abt the internships
me: told...YP went into specifics of my voluntary internship with a NGO after my 2nd year but it was fine
OP: Y do u people do 3 interns? u r only required to do 1 intern? I have specially seen this phenomenon in IID people? every year my mail box gets filled with intern requets?
me: Sir we used to hav 2.5 months vacations every year. I had wasted my 1st year vacations. So wanted to use them in more constructive manner and something which adds to my personality.
YP: What did you do in your first year vacations?
me: Sir I used to play cricket..generally relaxed..
YP: That is not wastage of time..u charged urself..relaxed
me: yes sir..but i did not do anything constructive
YP: I think its only to add something on ur CV
ME: Sir frankly tht is definitely one of the motivations..but also this gives the opportunity to use time in more constructive manner
YP: You hav certificates in football, hockey and cricket
me yes sir..i played in inter hostel sports tournaments during my stay at IIT
YP: what was the final score of Man U vs Arsenel match tht was played last night
me: Sir, it was 2-0 Man U after 60 mins ( Actually it was 3-0)
YP: Fair enuf...it was 2-0
YP: Which was the last book you had read?
me: The other side of the midnight by Sidney Sheldon ( I guess I was over honest here)
YP: What was it abt?
me: Sir it was abt a woman called Miss Page who was very beautiful but from a weak backgrd. As she grew up she realized tht the world is very ruthless especially the male part and she would have to use her beauty to her advantage to survive ( Was actually very embarassing for me)
YP: So u deal with data a lot ( My job profile..I am a domain consultant in a data analytics firm).how wud u interpret this..thr r 2 data sets...both have mean = 6 ...first one has SD = 0.5 and the other one has SD = 6.
me: Sir..the second data set has more variability...more extreme values..( gave an example)..something like 6, 0, 12, -1, 13...
OP: Can u give an example whr we can see such a distribution?
me: Sir probably in an exam which students of very different aptitudes are giving..
OP: But is it possible in a CAT like exam
me: No sir..in CAT like exam the distribution would be more towards normal
OP: So can u give some realistic example?
me: ( thought a lot..after 1.5 mins) Sir in 1971 India pak war, the defence requirements of India in tht year and the preceding year may show tht kind of distribution. ( Still cant believe how could i come up with this!)
(Both panelists laughed)
YP: give me a realistic example of an event whose probability of happening is 1?
me: ( dont know y but nothing concrete striked me..after 1 min) Sir the probability of this panel taking atleat 2 interviews in next 2 hrs is 1
OP: ( Surprized) well u mean to say tht its probability is 1..i can make you sit here for 2 hrs and u will be proved wrong..or there may be fire here and we may hav to stop the process
me: Yes sir
OP: think abt another example?
me: ( tried to think but I was blank..after 1 min) Sir my mobile is switched off..the probability of my mobile not ringing is 1 given the scenario tht I dont switch it on
YP: What if I take your mobile and switch it on and it rings?
me: Sir the domain I am considering here is tht until it is switched on, it wont ring
YP: How would you interpret probability = -0.5?
me: ( Surprised..started thinking in terms of tossing coin but quickly realized it was a trap) Sir its not possible..probability can onlu lie between 0 and 1.
YP: So u mean to say its only a theoretical concept?
me: Sir I havent really come across this even in theory
YP: ( Now the tech part) You must have heard abt Nano? Why is it tht its overall dimensions are pretty small but still it is spacious?
me: Sir I have read a bit abt Nano but do not know very specific details..
OP: Where is the engine of Nano?
me: Sir at the rear ( I was right but not very sure)
OP: What!!! Engine at the back???????
me: I am sorry sir..engine is at front but it is a rear wheel driven car ( This I guess was a blunder...though I was sure abt rear wheel driven thing)
OP: Give examples of other rear wheel driven vehicles?
me: Sir usually these days most vehicles are front wheen driven as they are more stable.
OP: dont go into details..just giv me examples?
me: Sir I am not sure.
OP: gave some examples of vehicles ( Also mentioned bicycles)
me: Sir bicycles..normal cycles are rear wheel driven
OP: Give an example of rear wheel driven automobile?
me: Sir I am not sure
OP: What abt Trucks?
me: Sir..I am sorry.But i dont really have an idea on this
YP: Lets talk abt tyres..why cant we use completely solid tyres in automobiles?
me: Sir may be thr r cost implications...also it will mean additional weight
YP: a car is abt 600-700 kgs..how does wheel weight have major effect ?
me: Sir during steering...it will require extra power.
YP: What if we use a material X which is strong and light?
me Sir I think tht can be a option which can be explored if thr r no major cost iomplications
YP: y do u think it hasnt been explored till now?
me: (Mumbled somthing)
OP: U know i expect certain kind of curousity from people coming from IITs. U r a mechanical engineer frm IIT Delhi. Has something changed in IITs?
me: Sir nothing has changed. But I would like to clarify something. We do not do all the mechanical engg courses at IIT. There are some compulsory courses and some other are electives.
OP: But course on automobiles must be basic for u guys?
me: No sir..it was an elective which i didnt do
YP: Which electives did u do?
me: TQM, Powerplant technologies, mini project..
YP: TQM..hmmm....What is Kaizen?
me: Sir I have heard of this term...One of my frds did his intern with Tata Motors..thr they used to use this..something related to quality...not sure actually
YP: What is JIT?
me: Just in Time..Explained the funda
YP: What is Kanban?
me: Sir...I have heard of it..cant recollect..I am sorry sir
YP: What was ur cat percentile?
me: 99.81
OP: What Calls do have?
me: Sir all 6
YP, OP: Thank you, All the best!
me: Thank you sir

( It lasted for more than 30 mins I guess...What do u think puys..please share your thoughts)

Verdict : Selected

Last edited by shaurya1985; 15-05-2008 at 11:46 AM. Reason: Verdict
   
Reply With Quote
The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to shaurya1985 For This Useful Post:
accenture07 (19-02-2008), akshatagarwal (19-02-2008), arvindc (19-02-2008), esh.nil (19-02-2008), guhan135 (18-02-2008), route_to_perdition (28-02-2008), shrijalohade (29-02-2008)
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences
Old
  (#150)
Cluster-one
has no status.
Newbie PaGaL
 
Status: Offline
Posts: 8
Groans: 0
Groaned at 0 Times in 0 Posts
Thanks: 5
Thanked 8 Times in 1 Post
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Pune
Age: 26
Re: [2008] IIM L GD/PI Experiences - 19-02-2008, 12:17 PM