[crazyphoton]

Originally Posted by vaibhavthakur

Some "crazy" guys sure attracted lot of attention away from the main purpose of discussion of this thread. Now lets get to the topic and ignore the distraction guys.

Me and my friend were just discussing this issue when a doubt came to me. Plz clarify puys. It is evident that this govt will definitely implement OBC reservation if not this year then next year. And because of SC's activity in this issue i believe they won't be able to apply this with creamy layer. Now my question is-shudn't the percentage of creamy layer be taken into account while giving reservation. I mean, say 25% of OBCs qualify under creamy layer then doesn't this automatically reduces the reservation by 25%.

And on the lighter side, can't IIMs declare results on their websites and then call it a "human mistake" later??
Something similar happened last year and so i hope it can happen again


Vaibhav

wot vibhav? sad that attn got diverted frm u to somebody else? neways directing the attn back to u, your estimates of the proportion of creamy layer are highly exaggerated. there is no way it could be even close to that figure or even significant enough to alter the percentage of reservation.

[the.bombardier]

Originally Posted by akshay_jain

your maths seems to be top notch to me.... 22 - (> is 15!!!!

lemme now list the assumptions that u have made
1) crazyphoton has passed out of iim
2) he has worked for more than a year
3) his personal details (age 22 is correct)

i don even want to comment how stupid/baseless these assumptions are...

please re-evaluate ur "fake" claim before shouting it out

please go thru the previous posts before u criticise someone next time.here r the facts:
1.his profile says his age is 22.
2.it also says he is in iiml.(must have at least finished 1 year)
3.he himself claimed he was working before joining iiml.(which means he had at least a year between his engineering and mba,whether he worked for that long or not)
4.he claimed he spent 5 years in some iit.
now simple maths would tell u
22-(>1+>1+5)<=15
now the only point being made is that he is lying bout either being in an iim,or having worked,or at least his age.
i wouldnt give a hoot bout it,but i think u r not supposed to give fake details at a community.

[soumyajyoti]

Originally Posted by crazyphoton

gr8 calculations! gr8 assumptions! u ll bcum a good manager!

Did I make any calculation... I actually left it to you to calculate

[anandeinstein]

Originally Posted by akshay_jain

your maths seems to be top notch to me.... 22 - (> is 15!!!!

lemme now list the assumptions that u have made
1) crazyphoton has passed out of iim
2) he has worked for more than a year
3) his personal details (age 22 is correct)

i don even want to comment how stupid/baseless these assumptions are...

please re-evaluate ur "fake" claim before shouting it out

dude, your posting style is so similar (at least the stupidity there!) that it makes me wonder if you are actually crazyphoton!!
Experienced puys, i am sure it is possible to create duplicate profiles, isnt it? At least crazyphoton posting from a fellow IIML's profile seems a definite possibility.

[soumyajyoti]

Originally Posted by piyushs

guys.... in case of doubt, read the heading of the thread....

this is not a place to be calculating someones age.... if you find someone unuseful or offensive, groan.... dont post again and again countering some attention seekers baseless arguments... just focus on the essence of discussion....


and if u really really wanna whoop some, go open a thread in the chit chat section!

I am sorry buddy ...bu this guy is irritating. Let us ignore him.

[ismbaneeded]

Originally Posted by crazyphoton

akshay dude! these ppl think their lives hang over 2 days. as if by delaying the results govt is playing with their lives. they need time for personal arrangements like packing their stuff etc. their lives hang on all such things. mebbe on my age too ... who knows!

Let me try and explain.
You are talking about someone who has cleared the final call. He still might forget the pain of this delay. Not sure though....eg... my landlord has asked me to vacate the house by 1st May and my next house depends on the call. If I get it , my parents shift to Indore, If I dont its Pune. Do you understand what the delay can do to my plans??

Spare athought for the one who will not make it to the final list.
He has sacrificed onsite opportunities , good appraisal , any good work in the project and this delay will add to his woes. It is very important to know your results on time.

If you still dont understand, well then I doubt you are in IIML too...(cannot believe all personal details you see )

[anmolsethy]

Just heard on cnbc awaaz that IIMCal guys are saying that they might delay the results. But that would need all IIMs to meet once and build a concurrent strategy.
Lets see now ......

[akshay_jain]

Originally Posted by vaibhavthakur

Some "crazy" guys sure attracted lot of attention away from the main purpose of discussion of this thread. Now lets get to the topic and ignore the distraction guys.

Me and my friend were just discussing this issue when a doubt came to me. Plz clarify puys. It is evident that this govt will definitely implement OBC reservation if not this year then next year. And because of SC's activity in this issue i believe they won't be able to apply this with creamy layer. Now my question is-shudn't the percentage of creamy layer be taken into account while giving reservation. I mean, say 25% of OBCs qualify under creamy layer then doesn't this automatically reduces the reservation by 25%.

And on the lighter side, can't IIMs declare results on their websites and then call it a "human mistake" later??
Something similar happened last year and so i hope it can happen again


Vaibhav

HUMAN MISTAKE.....................

u stupid person.. have u ever taken a look at the newspapers the day after the results are announced of such important exams.... u will find numerous cases of suicides of kids/people....who did not make it..

are u honestly suggesting that they issue out one list and then revise it.... only to find a couple of ppl who are "missing"

please take a moment to think what u are penning down... and not say something for the sake of lengthening the threads length

[rakesh_tp]

Originally Posted by mufasa

I dont think any of the IIMs will be able to give a clear answer to THE question..... The news of 23 April has just come out... Logically the next steps would be the HRD sending another letter to the IIMs... If such a letter arrives, there would be another conf among the IIMs, and then they will be able to give a reasonable reply... Till such a letter arrives, the status quo doesnt change for the IIMs... I know I am just putting common sense into words... But I think we are panicking and that aint gonna be of much use...
I am putting moi money on 21st

-Mufasa Resurrected

completely agree with this one.
Thats why I was asking for the HRD response to the court decision.
But I am not optimistic enough to put my money on 21st.
The attitude shown by the HRD so far, makes me believe they will send another letter to the IIMs. Though I sincerely hope, my fears will be proven wrong.

[crazyphoton]

Originally Posted by soumyajyoti

When I posted for the last time I did not know about this person's achievement of passing IIT in 5 years..

And one more thing since you @ crazyphoton did not know that in IIT JEE screeing ranks are given . He must have appeared for IIT JEE before 2001.

god god! apart from a gr8 maths and analytical mind, u ve gr8 comprehension skills too. now instead of suggesting others to go back n read some of ur stuff, can u urslf go n chk out something. i nvr said i dint know screening RANKS r not given.

u hv an analytical mind, gud, but kindly chk the validity of ur assumptions bfore u recommend nething.

and it wud be in ur interest only NOT to talk abt my achievements. believe me dear analyst, u hv absolutely no idea abt ne of it.