Hi Folks,
Came back today from NITIE.
I Had my GD/PI on 15-03-07. Batch: 49/A/1.
************************************************** ************
Cat: 98.39%ile
work-ex: 35Months (S/w)
Sports: State Level ( But was never asked):satisfie:
Extra Curricular: Decent ( But was never asked, read more to know abt this):satisfie:
************************************************** ************
Stayed at NTIE hostel:
Imagination of a hostel in a B-school: I expect rooms would be fullly air conditioned with internet connectivity to all rooms.
Reality Check: Well I got acco in PGP 3&4 hostel n basement. The condition of room n the wing was in very derelict state that I thought to contribute to make them livable. The rooms are age old, to descibe in modest way. Washroom gives u a good reminder of indian railway 2nd class compartment expcet the graffity missing..
I even took some pics of all these historic monuments.
The rooms were so old as it looks like no body has come here after Britishers left.
It gives u a good sense waht is the differenc between a Govt and a private college and why privatisation is needed. ...
Went straight away to buy Mosquito repelent to fight a night battle which eventually I lost as they won by keeping me awake whole night be playing aroud me.
I was wondering how seniors are managing there? if It all they are living in these hostels (although I doubt) and also that these govt. hostels need lot of money. But at the end what matters is career which Iam pretty sure NITIE Rocks!!!
But being a consumer had to descibe waht i saw, thats it!
Food was quite ok! No complains. Seniors were very helpful. Thanks to them.
************************************************** ************
GD Description:
GD Topic: Organised retail will destroy the small shop keepers
Before even start of GD, one gentleman "Bhaisaahab" was more than eager to meet all ppl so I got a hunch that he has some nasty plans as he is just roaring to go but has no idea that he will go to that extent. Anyways.. it was a omen for things to come...
GD timing : 3 minutes to think..Bell will ring...18 minutes for discussion..bell will ring..2 mins to summarize..end of GD.
After 3 minutes as soon as the bell rang the same "Bhaisaahab' started from the top of his voice and in all the hurry without even opening the topic to the group and also jumped ot his views and was speaking on and on..
suddently his neighbour a decent chap took the charge and game some decent start with some gyan on topic.. Overall he spoke quite well in GD but spoke too much not gave enough chance to all. But was the best of lot.
I tried to jump to give some stats on the current rules ans regulation in India abt retail but was cut down n then almost every body started speaking jumping to staright away Wallmart etc( I could sense ppl were just hiding this word and was looking to speak this word "wallmart" as soon as thet could)
So by GODS (sitting in GD) grace we entered in a complete fish market where all crap was being discussed even GDP growth which I thought was a bit tangent ..still...
the same "Bhaisaab" even asked one very intelligent q to all " How many of us go to Big Baazaar??" I guess hardly any""
" I wanted to reply to him but thought not to waste my time for this sily thing
Amidst all this I knew I have to give only 3-4 SOLID entires but as we all know nothing happens as per plan..so in my case I realize the ppl are not ready even to give me a minute to put my point across,. I tried very hard to enter in this mayhem but every time ended in "Excuse me, let me complete" Still somehow manage to raise 2 good points in GD on which there was atleast some discussion.
all in all very very Bad GD as per my opinion. No rules, no manners simply blood bath..
as soon as the time ended the panel asked to sum up but there also every body started giving his version. Even I fall in this trap.
One poor chap was so scared of all this that he not even mumbled a single word. I could undersrand his position.:(
but even after all this one lady in Panel said" we enjoyed the discussion and that's y we gave u one extra minute" not sure if she was ridiculing...
here also that "bhaisaaahab" said "No ma'm actually we got emotional so it has to be like this" ...Gawd damn it...
GD end....................
************************************************** ************
PI: Here is brief abt my " brief" PI which came after a long hiatus of close to 5 hours of wait..
was getting signals that work ex peole were asked a lot and PI is cool..
so was pensive but then here is mine rendezvous with NITIE..
I heard that there is one prof of Quailty n he is asking abt quality since I have good knowledge of 6 sigma so felt a bit confident but was of no use...discussion was very abstract.
Panel of 4 profs... ( 1 quality prof P1, 1 fin prof P2, 1 oerations prof P3, 1 no idea P4)
I : Me
Entered in the room...
Greeetings exchanged ..
P3: Come in mr..xxx. Please take the seat
I: Thank you sir,
p1: So what is the meaning of ur name?
I: answered
p1: Explain in Hindi
I: Answered in Hindi but now I think was it right to speak in Hindi , but sicne they asked specifically so I didnt have much choice.
P3: So u have 2.5 years work ex
I: sir, I will complete my 3 years next month.
p2: How much is your salary?
I : Answered
p3: Give me exact gross monthly and yearly figure
I: gave
p2: How much is u take home?
I: Said it varies due to variable components.
P3: Waht are those?
I: Expalined.
P2: So waht is the highest salary u ever got? with a huge grin
I: said last month
P3: y? is it because of tax clearace?
I : yes sir.
p2: When is your sal going to increase?
I: told that we just finised our appraisal cycle.
P3: Tell me howz this compensation decided in ur proj?
I: told him abt CRR stuff in comp?
P2: So is it kind of leg pulling amonst ur peers for this?
I: Told them abt healthy competition etc....
Are bhai Band karo ye salary waala interview ask sth abt me yar!
p3: What is the attrition rate of your comp? comapre with Wipro
Thank God atleast some change in Qs either wise I was wondering why so many q on salary?????
I: Told
P3: What is ur HR doing to stop especially for those who r going for higher studies?
I: I said they are not doing much because they encourage ppl to go for hige studies.
P3: So if they want to do what should they do?
I: Gave some details
P1: So if a company has a attrition rate of zero is it good or bad?
I: I said it is not possible.
P1: I am telling u there is one such comp, so what's ur take is it good or bad?
I: I said its not good for company, although couldnt expalin properly
P1: What should be the ideal attrition rate in any company?
I: Sorry sir, no idea.
P3: What all calls u have?
I: told..
P3: Why not IIMs?
I: told.
P3: wahts ur preference between MDI and NITIE?
I: gave some fundas abt mumbai advantage and students community.
P1: dont u think these live projects and field work are distractions?
I: explained him..hell lot of gyan on this.. was nodding was quite convinsed said..quite true 2-3 times.
P3: Ok thank you XXxx
I: thank you sirs.
P1: Good day xxx
I: Good day sirs.
Overall 10 mins!! thats all
Oh Gawd! Gimme abreak is this a inteview abt me or my salary.. please yar band karo ye torture.. ask some thing relative..
No Intro, No MBA qs. NO acads, no extra curricualr . I have good exta curricalur so wanted to tell them but not even a single qs on that.. buh.. buh..:( :( :(
I don't know what to read out of this whole PI as it was nothing abt me specific where I could demonstate my edge! not sure how they are going to asses me out of this where there were not even a single q to check my comptency..
Sab moh maayaa hai bhaiya.. In my final analsis I feel Luck factor is the most important factor to get success.
so lets c If I am lucky here!!
C yao!
Best of Luck to others!
Roark007
Disclaimer: The views expressed are entirely personnal and expression of instant feelings.