ShoutBox (Part 1)

@YouMadFellow said:
DOUBT:
@Estallar12 @RoadKill @hanushanand @nits2811 and all Gods ...
All my flowers except 2 are roses. All my fruits except 3 are apples. All my flowers except 3 are lilies and all my fruits except 4 are oranges. What is the minimum total number of roses, apples, lilies and oranges that I have?
Options
1) 7
2) 9
3) 12
4) 15
Explain too
12 ? Easy nahin itna ? :splat:
@YouMadFellow said:
DOUBT:
@Estallar12 @RoadKill @hanushanand @nits2811 and all Gods ...
All my flowers except 2 are roses. All my fruits except 3 are apples. All my flowers except 3 are lilies and all my fruits except 4 are oranges. What is the minimum total number of roses, apples, lilies and oranges that I have?
Options
1) 7
2) 9
3) 12
4) 15
Explain too
waise its an oral question...coz the things complement each other...let flowers be 5 and fruits be 7...taking the sum of all the except things...10 secs and the answer is there...samajhana hain toh explanation dia hain..
@nits2811 said:
Let the total number of flowers be t and total number of fruits be f...
R = T - 2
L = T - 3
A = F - 3
O= F - 4
L = R - 1
O = A - 1
A + L + O + R = 2R + 2A - 2...
so the answer should be an even number...it shld be 12...??
Yeh itna lamba kya kiya hai aapne ? I mean kyun ? 😲 :O
@nits2811 said:
Let the total number of flowers be t and total number of fruits be f...
R = T - 2
L = T - 3
A = F - 3
O= F - 4
L = R - 1
O = A - 1
A + L + O + R = 2R + 2A - 2...
so the answer should be an even number...it shld be 12...??
Bhai Saab!!
@Estallar12 said:
Yeh itna lamba kya kiya hai aapne ? I mean kyun ?
he wrote explain...dusra explanation bhi dia hain...its an oral questn waise toh..
@nits2811 Well, your answer is correct according to TIME, but earlier there was another even option e) 10.. I removed that here. But what is wrong in this:

Total fruits = b
Total flowers = a

Roses = a -2, Lilies = a -3
Apples = b - 3, Oranges = b-4

Now, a >3, b>4

Also, Roses - Lilies = 1
and Apples - Oranges = 1

I assume this scenario:
1 lily, 2 roses, 1 another flower(not known)
1 orange, 2 apples, 2 another type fruits(not known)

This scenario satisfies the given conditions.
Minimum total of roses, lilies, oranges, apples = 6 ! ?
@YouMadFellow wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.. god one
@YouMadFellow should be 9 i think...
@ABISEK said:
@YouMadFellow should be 9 i think...
No, it didn't ask me the total number of fruits.. it asked me about the minimum number of lilies, roses, apples, oranges..
@YouMadFellow ohh my bad.. thn to question controversial ho gaya...
@YouMadFellow said:
@nits2811 Well, your answer is correct according to TIME, but earlier there was another even option e) 10.. I removed that here. But what is wrong in this:
Total fruits = b
Total flowers = a
Roses = a -2, Lilies = a -3
Apples = b - 3, Oranges = b-4
Now, a >=3, b>=4
Also, Roses - Lilies = 1
and Apples - Oranges = 1
I assume this scenario:
1 lily, 2 roses, 1 another flower(not known)
1 orange, 2 apples, 2 another type fruits(not known)
This scenario satisfies the given conditions.
Minimum total of roses, lilies, oranges, apples = 6 ! ?
aise toh there could be multiple answers...
assume this
1 rose 2 another flowers 0 lily
0 orange 3 other fruits 1 apple
so minimum is 2...
@YouMadFellow said:
@nits2811 Well, your answer is correct according to TIME, but earlier there was another even option e) 10.. I removed that here. But what is wrong in this:
Total fruits = b
Total flowers = a
Roses = a -2, Lilies = a -3
Apples = b - 3, Oranges = b-4
Now, a >=3, b>=4
Also, Roses - Lilies = 1
and Apples - Oranges = 1
I assume this scenario:
1 lily, 2 roses, 1 another flower(not known)
1 orange, 2 apples, 2 another type fruits(not known)
This scenario satisfies the given conditions.
Minimum total of roses, lilies, oranges, apples = 6 ! ?
Perfect hai!
@nits2811 Arey paas to lilies hai hi nahi.. ek to hona chahiye.. to make it logically correct.. Bina lilies ke hi .. main bolunga ki mere paas lilies hai.. par wo 0 hai ! yeh kya mazak hai :P
@YouMadFellow said:
Upar dekho.. Mera doubt wo hai..
Yaar aise karoge toh answers can vary with the question. Aap question ko controversial bana rahe ho. Obviously, woh controversial question denge toh nahin and so that means that types of flowers and fruits given are the only present. :)
@YouMadFellow You and I think alike. I had to skip this question after getting an answer lower than each of the options. 😁 Bas ye yaad nahi ki aaya kya tha.
@Estallar12 said:
Yaar aise karoge toh answers can vary with the question. Aap question ko controversial bana rahe ho. Obviously, woh controversial question denge toh nahin and so that means that types of flowers and fruits given are the only present.
nahi..language is definitely ambiguous ....paper setter ne zyada dhyaan nhi dia iss repect mein...
@nits2811 said:
aise toh there could be multiple answers...
assume this
1 rose 2 another flowers 0 lily
0 orange 3 other fruits 1 apple
so minimum is 2...
Haan shayad maine ye nikala tha πŸ˜› Kela ho gaya tha solution dekh ke..
@Estallar12 Yaar , isme agar minimum sum of fruits and flowers pucha hota to kya karte tum ? Batao ?
@YouMadFellow said:
@vikky312 Answer to 12 hai naa ! .. !
12 hai ans kyuki they have assumed only these fruits and flowers are there!! Wo question mei dena chahiye tha

Otherwise 6 is perfect!
@RoadKill Bhai, 0 to nahi le sakte .. kyunki then you are making an illogical statement. I have lilies but I have 0 lilies ! :|