SAIL 2012 MT(T/A) discussion

Jobs & Careers
1587
@killer20 Sir,

Based on data you provided, these are the possibilities. You can go through and opt for whichever way you find comfortable.

Point 0:

HAL = Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd.
SAIL = Steel Authority of India Ltd.

Conclusion: Totally different industries so, comparison is of no use.

Point 1:

SAIL - you are not sure. Even no one is since, results are yet to come.
HAL - you are selected.

Conclusion: So, you must go to HAL as taking risk is not recommended in this situation.

Point 2:

HAL is related to aeronautic industry where metallurgy people have a little work to do.
SAIL is related to Steel industry and best meant for metallurgy people.

Conclusion: SAIL is better fit for your skills.

Point 3:

HAL - joining date is 31st December 2012.
SAIL - Result not OUT

Conclusion: You can wait till 28th December 2012; 18:00:00 hrs for SAIL result. If result not comes till then, you go for HAL.

Point 4:

HAL - bond of 5,00,000/- ; 5 years. ( @kplight Sir said that. )
SAIL - bond not directly mentioned. BUT 5,000/- per month to be deducted from total emoluments during training (2 years only).

Conclusion: So, you can join HAL now. After 5 years, re - apply for SAIL.

These are various possibilities, you review these and find out which one is suited for you.
1588
@killer20 If I were you I would join HAL, you will get a city life and you don't have to work with 1500 C temperatures

Also money should not be the only deciding factor, yes HAL gives little less money but as a career its a better bet than SAIL
1589
@prassibhai said:
@kplight aapka mumbai tha na intrvw ...... es ka kab tak aayega.......................
@prassibhai mera to chennai me hua........ aur aapka??
1590
@User.000 said:
@killer20 Sir, Based on data you provided, these are the possibilities. You can go through and opt for whichever way you find comfortable.Point 0:HAL = Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. SAIL = Steel Authority of India Ltd. Conclusion: Totally different industries so, comparison is of no use. Point 1: SAIL - you are not sure. Even no one is since, results are yet to come. HAL - you are selected.Conclusion: So, you must go to HAL as taking risk is not recommended in this situation. Point 2: HAL is related to aeronautic industry where metallurgy people have a little work to do.SAIL is related to Steel industry and best meant for metallurgy people.Conclusion: SAIL is better fit for your skills.Point 3:HAL - joining date is 31st December 2012.SAIL - Result not OUTConclusion: You can wait till 28th December 2012; 18:00:00 hrs for SAIL result. If result not comes till then, you go for HAL. Point 4:HAL - bond of 5,00,000/- ; 5 years. ( @kplight Sir said that. )SAIL - bond not directly mentioned. BUT 5,000/- per month to be deducted from total emoluments during training (2 years only).Conclusion: So, you can join HAL now. After 5 years, re - apply for SAIL. These are various possibilities, you review these and find out which one is suited for you.
superb elaboration sirji...... hats off :-)
1591
@kplight chennai mein kab hu apka??
1592
@ramshyam1 said:
@kplight chennai mein kab hu apka??
24th nov..... aur aapka??
1593

29 nov ...apka general ???

1594
@kplight said:
24th nov..... aur aapka??
mera mumbai 2nd dec...........
1595
@prassibhai Sir, 2nd Dec ko bhi interview chala? It was a Sunday.

Extremely Shocking revelation.

Anyways, any idea - interview ki last date kyaa thi?
1596
@killer20 said:
People my frnds I really need ur advice here..please do help me...I am a metallurgist..got selected in HAL But wanted to Join SAIL But the SAIL result is pending and we don't know when it will be out...meanwhile the HAL is up my ass and joining is 31st December...what should I do..HAL also having that BOND thing which you all might be aware of..I am in real trouble here so please , please help me out ..I need some prudent opinions...
bhai ..... u can join hal ..... i would have done so if i were u....... but one thing u should keep in mind that if at a later stage u want to switch to other psu hal has a less priority than others..... so dcide carefully...............
1597
anyone can please help me with electronics bhai gate ke liye electronics k questions kahaan se solve kar rahe ho aap log..........
1598
@prassibhai Sir,

please check thy messages. I have not put GATE material here since this isn't right post. Check your message list.

Thanks...
1599
@User.000 ..bhai..ur observation is quite right..i do feel the same...after that much discussions over the SAIL result , I am devoid of hunches now..it seems utmost uncertain and hence i am not left with any option but to join HAL..for now !!! but I do hope that my dilemma will end as this year ends..and for all as well..we can't be merely the instruments of fate..although at this time it looks like that..
1600
@sateeshin ...SAIL also have city postings like bhilai and Bokaro..and perhaps it is also not about standing in front of a blast furnace or a helicopter..but one curious thing i noticed..SAIL people looked more friendly and flexible than HAL people...It might be the working culture also that matters..I am accustomed to work in a free environment (Myself also passed out from IITB )
1601
@User.000 3 dec 2012
1602
@killer20 U CONFIDENTLY join HAL now..... once u get selected in SAIL and willing to join it, Ask for extension in date of joining from SAIL mentioning how only a days before u joined HAL. Once SAIL approve ur extension (100% they will) u serve a notice period with HAL and say bye with honour.....
1603
@killer20 dude go with HAL i dont know much about it but work culture and evrythng is good in HAL i didnt make it to final list but i wanted to join hal more than any job ...it was my scnd priority aftr BHEL....
1604
@killer20 Sir, OK

I guess SAIL result will be out by 3rd Jan 2013. Bcoz I remember the exact words :::

Interview और Result में एक महीना तो लगता ही है।

Regarding work culture, you know Japanese companies have world's worst work culture, even then top in terms of innovation and quality. So, they may be extracting best from you that way. They are preparing you for giving your best. (Anyways, I am not sure about it.)
1605

if selection is based upon who has visited sail recruitment most number of times....then i wud surely top the list :D....seriously hope that they declare results before 31st....dont want to welcome new year in a confused state of mind....

1606

i meant sail recruitment website....