[2012-2014] FMS Delhi GD-PI Experiences

All the best to everyone for their FMS-MBA(FT)interviews starting today. Please do post in your experinces. For the benefit of everyone concerned, please keep the format like this: PROFILE: CAT PErcentile OA VR & LR QA & DI …

All the best to everyone for their FMS-MBA(FT)interviews starting today. Please do post in your experinces.

For the benefit of everyone concerned, please keep the format like this:

PROFILE:

CAT PErcentile
OA
VR & LR
QA & DI

Acads:
X
XII
Undergrad Major - GPA/%age

Work-Ex:
NIL/Sector - Number of Years

GD:
Topic:
Number of Ppl present
Time:
Brief Snapshot of Discussion:
Other Salient Details: As whether summary was asked to be written or not, Time given, and other stuff.

PI:
Panel Members Intro:
Questions:
Extempore Topic:
Questions asked-
Interview experience-

Misc Details-
Documents required, total duration of whole process etc..

Surprises(if any) add Overall Experience-

Verdict-

Request:
1. Kindly do not post anything other than your experiences of FMS-MBA(FT)GD-PI.
2. Please do mention your background and hobbies as it might help us understand why a specific question was put up to you.
3. For appreciating an interview post use thank button, or if you want to show more, use PM.

Additional Info:-

Previous year experiences:
2011-13: http://www.pagalguy.com/discussions/2011-2013-fms-gd-pi-extempore-experiences-25063873

2010-12: http://www.pagalguy.com/forum/other-...ms-mba-ft.html

2009-11: http://www.pagalguy.com/discussions/2009-2011-fms-mbaft-gd-pi-experiences-25038257

All timings have been changed. mine has gone from 11 am to 3 30 pm. there are 3/4 sets of timings/day now. there are 3 batches for every timing and each batch has 15 students. what a drag

invinciblesk Says
All timings have been changed. mine has gone from 11 am to 3 30 pm. there are 3/4 sets of timings/day now. there are 3 batches for every timing and each batch has 15 students. what a drag


just had my interview and Putting end to all speculations.... yes there are 4 slots.... 10 am, 11:30, 2 pm and 3:30....
the document verification starts at 8:30 for 10 am slot... after that group leaves for the next slot... i was 10 am wala slot...my interview was at 12 pm and i was just 5th in the group of 10 and after that the 11:30 wala was supposed to have their gd...so u guys do the maths....
the distribution as it seemed was random.... there were some 8 am guys in 3:30 slot as well... though they did make some adjustments and made changed there time to 2 and 11:30 slots....

they are not entertaining any request for Slot change... but u guys can try

u need to take originals of ....X XII(marksheets) XII(certificate)...GRAD MARKSHEETs(clearly indicating ur grades or percentile)...CAT SCORE CARD....FMS CALL LETTER....CASTE CERTIFICATE (if ANY)...for verification.....!!! and i dont think they r looking at our files bundled with certi's !! keep it to be on a safer side.!! that's it..!!

invincible_2010 Says
Is the panel wise list of students put up for all other dates as well?


naaa just todays list was on the board...


extempore is there everyone got a topic... more or less related to themselves....
mine was the colour black- i guess coz of my blazer colour...

GD pi exp of one of the candidates posted on the FB page....

the gd was decent.... it was "in democracy the foreign partnership in print media necessary"... just 10 of 16 ppl had turned up... it almost became a fish market... interviews were short and mine was like 5-8 mins... 4 panelist... all pretty seniors 2 male proffs and 2 female proffs... my extepore topic was- the colour black and interview was very generic.. why fms, which business books u have read, wat other options, whr u work and similar lines.... though mine wasnt that good... anyhow... yes there are ppl divided in 4 slots randomly... 10, 11:30, 2:00 and 3:30... it totally depends onur luck ki kaun se slot main atke ho... they are not entertaining request of slot change also... just take water and something to eat u will be fine... those coming from outside ticket as late as possible karwana....:).... turn out wasnt that much owing to 5 iims result but yeah decent enuff

@yash
what was the duration of gd?


the gd was 30 seconds to think and 10 minutes to discuss...

and yes there is a simple form u are required to fill out... very basic details... name dob grads marks etc... no SOP or anything
mayurbhakar Says
did they have your sop while interview??? were they asking questions from it??


see they had the SOP in my file wen i went in... infact one prof kept reading it all the time... they might ask if they find something interesting or they might not... totally depends....

@trier... they had it in the file along with personal data form and the photocopies we sent with them.... so again as i have mentioned its all luck

@aabhishek
https://www.facebook.com/groups/fmsshortlist2012/

1. What is conversion factor?
2. all academic certificates means-- only mark sheets or ALL documents starting from 10 (FMS has not asked to carry any doc!)??


if u are an engineer who get GPA there is usually a factor of multiplication prescribed by your college that converts ur gpa to a percentage, that is conversion factor

take 10th, 12th and grads marksheet, degree if u have

Right, hello people. I am finally home. as mentioned before my slot was 3 30, batch III. i reached the place again at 2 30 (after reaching first at 11). i found out that the 11 30 batch was still on. the 2 pm batch started at 3 30 and ours started at 5 15 pm after proffs started taking 5 mins interview. they were for 10 mins earlier. ppl who had flights were allowed to go in first, however these were ppl whose flights were at 8 pm and they were still scared that they would miss it. for all those flying back: it will take about 1 hr fr airport using the metro for T3 and 90 mins for T1.

the gd was no. of ppl X mins + 1 min. it wasnt a fish mkt but wasn't the smoothest either. interviews were exactly 5 mins including extempore. they didn't really know much about us except our college. don't know about freshers, but for work ex ppl it was mostly about the experience, and they asked for my specialization.

As mentioned before, there are 4 batches, and for some reason each set of 15 students has been given 90 mins which defies logic. it was a long tiring day. outstation ppl , try to keep your flights as late as possible.

ps- in the middle of the gd all 3 panelists started talking to some ppl who came in which was weird. in the middle of my interview one walked out yawning widely. the admin ppl also kept cribbing that they would not work beyond 6.

pps- just found out that i got through MDI

Hello people...

Had my interview in 10 a.m slot today...got postponed from the 8 a.m slot...as far as i know..there werent any indications abt tomorrow's slots...i wud advise people to go to da campus at 8/9 am n have a look at the notice boards...

GD started at arnd 10.30 am..the topic was ' Good managers are not always engineers' or something on those lines...it wasnt a bad fish-market...it was a gud fish-market, and one panelist made sure we were aware of it...13 people were supposed to b in da GD or so i remember...4-5 did not turn out..been da trend for the whole day i think...

we were asked to take a 5 min break after da GD...the same panelists held da PIs for our group...they called candidates one-by-one afta da break..went in..random question on my name..then P1 explained da structure of the PI..gave my extempore topic..' I admire Steve who created many jobs'...this was regarding wat id written on my SOP...Interview started off wid a couple of IT questions...i jus shook my head...then he asked one q from mech. engg...answered...then some Anna Hazare questions...some questions regarding marketing/advertising...nd my opinion abt MNREGA...ended wid a 'wat other calls do u have?' question...

the total time dedicated to one candidate is abt 23 min...including the GD...nd verification process took..arnd 2 hrs...so go in prepared...ATB..:cheers:

Wht was d format for extempore ??? Is it 10 secs to think and 60 secs to speak ?
Do we need to take of time or the panel will take of that ?



It was a 0 sec to think...talk off the tip of ur tongue format.......for 1 min...u dont need to keep track of time..there's a stop clock on da table 4 dat purpose...nd ur not allowed to touch it... :nono:

PROFILE:

CAT PErcentile
OA : 99.33

Acads:
X : 90
XII : 90
Undergrad Major - 8.36 GPA/%age

Work-Ex: NIL

GD:
Topic: Gandhi and his principles are not practical in modern world
Number of Ppl present : 9
Time: 9 + 1
Brief Snapshot of Discussion:
1 min to think
9 mins to discuss
People got out the usual points
Non violence
Truth
MunnaBhai MBBS
Simple Living, high thinking
Arab Spring
Instability
Terrorism

Other Salient Details:
Summary was asked in the end to be presented.
No order prescribed.
Was a mess for some, a haven for others.

PI:

Extempore Topic: Astrology is my passion
Questions asked-

Who was the 1st Astrologer?
How is Astrology useful to you?

What is the minimum intensity required to cause destruction in a region?
Methods of earthquake protection

How is Astrology useful for earthquake protection?

They were very amused by all my answers
and at this point P1 realized that astrology was not my hobby but rather a random test on my creative skills.

As I was about to leave,

P3: Name some Japanese, German, USA based automobile company.
Name 5 Indian Industrialist
Which stream do you wish to choose?
Which Biz field interests you?
What is heavy engineering?

As I was about to leave yet again,

P1: What is FDI?
Difference between FDI n FII?
What is better for India?

I think he was quite entertained by the last answer of mine.

Misc Details-
Bring original certificates of all educational qualifications.

Surprises(if any) add Overall Experience-
Unprofessional.

Verdict- Reject as gd was average and pi turned horrible.

Additional Info:- Brush up current affairs as the ratio of rejection would be close to 1:10
Best of luck to all!

Finally done with my 9th and last ever MBA interview and it marks the end of journey that begin with IMT on 7th Feb and the end on 21st April!
And am pretty happy that am no longer a B-School Aspirant just converted MDI :biggrin:
Here goes my GD,PI,Extempore Experience..

PROFILE:

CAT Percentile
OA - 99.04
VA & LR - 97.30
QA & DI - 98.28

Acads:
X - 89.73
XII - 84.17
Undergrad Major - GPA/%age - Engg, 78.44%

Work-Ex: Nil

GD:
Topic: Gandhi and his Principles are not practical in today's world
Number of Ppl present: 9/16 (ABCL effect was pretty evident with some panel having only 50% attendance)
Time: 1 min to think + 9 mins to discuss + 1 min to summarise
Brief Snapshot of Discussion:
It was one of the better GD i have attended.. Hardly a fish market. People allowed everyone else to speak and only couple of times more than 2 people were speaking and that too none of them was aggressive, so it was pretty good.. The topic was not exactly objective and thus it was expected that discussion too would be on same lines.. Some said they are relevant some other they aren't.. I too made good number of entries and made some decent points. I was the Ist one to start the conclusion and felt i concluded pretty well.. Hopes that too has that brownie points

Other Salient Details: They informed when to start the summary..

PI:
Panel Members Intro:
2 Female, 1 Male (F1,F2,M1) Your Truly(YT).. They were seated on sofa in semi-circular manner.. M1 was to my left (who seemed was not impressed with my answers) followed by 2 other female panelists, one of whom didnt ask me single Q and only controlled the Stop-Watch during Extempore...

F1: Tell me about yourself..
YT: spoke everything as i knew FMS PI's are pretty short and will give them enough things to ask during the PI.. Acads,ECA, Hobbies,Internship etc...
F1: Okay we'll have an Extempore.. You wont be given time to think.. 1 min to speak..
Extempore Topic: MBA is overrated
Spoke well... Hype around MBA is mainly due to placements, salaries which should be reduced.. Managers reqd in industry.. B-school about learning, skills, knowledge sharing etc etc...
Just when i was about to conclude, ma'am said okay done...
F1: Where did you do your internship? And what was the work?
YT: Told... (it was start-up firm)
F1: Asked me something related to start-up firms in general and i said am not aware of it...
F1: Then asked me about Venture Capitalists.. Told.. But when she asked too much in detail and other stuff, i said it a short 3.5 week internship and i dunno details of the same...
F1: What do u do in your spare time...
YT: told about my hobbies and framed my answer in a way to invite questions...
( but strangely no questions at all:nono::nono:)

Now M1 came in
M1: What is WiMax? (Elec & Telecom Engg)
YT : told..
M1: diff between 3G and WiMax?
YT: Told but he didnt seem convinced and i dunno why as i gave a pretty decent answer..
M1: Why MBA?
YT: Gave a well prepared and a very good answer
M1: Seemed pleased to some extent.. Asked me to define Business in lay man's term..
YT: did...
M1: Then said anyone can do this? You dont need MBA for it...
YT: Said you told me define in layman's term so gave a very simplistic definition.. Then said there are various verticals and complex functions involved which requires Managerial skills...
M1: What is your career goal?
YT: told about interest in consulting...
M1: asked 1 or 2 questions.. gave decent answers..
Done....

Lasted about 8-9 mins.. For some odd reason that man didnt seem interested or convinced with my answers.. So in many ways it wasn't one of the greatest PI's i have attended...

Misc details:
Bring all supporting documents of details filled in 2nd form.. CAT score card, Grad marksheet, Xth, XIIth marksheet, photo ID proof...

P.S- It was one of the worst managed admission process ever... Though it was Ist day but still the organisation of FMS Admin wasn't great at all...

P.P.S- CAT weightage in all probability in 70% and 10% each to GD,PI,Extempore...

Verdict (after GD,PI) - Not too many hopes after below par PI... Felt i could have done a lot lot better... Disappointed with my performance....:-(:-(:-(

All The Best Puys!


Verdict : Reject (as expected)

Sosaho1 Says
I didnot get the call letter .. Do they allow people who have not received their call letters , But had their names in the list of candidates of GD/PI


well they were asking for letters but few ppl today also didnt have their letters but were allowed to sit.... get a soft copy if u have... or else i dont think thats such an issue....
mayurbhakar Says
did they have your sop while interview??? were they asking questions from it??


I had my interview today. I confirm that they will have your SOP during d interview.

And for me one of the proffs read it out very attentively and found out a flaw from it as well.
Please go through the SOP that you have posted earlier 2 FMS.

Hope it helps..

CAT Percentile
OA 99.88


Acads:
X 91
XII 86
Undergrad Major - GPA/%age 75

Work-Ex:
Sector - Telecom
Number of Years - Reaching 3

GD:
Topic: Access to Education should be a Fundamental Right
Number of Ppl present : 9
Time: 10 min (9 + 1 for summary)
Brief Snapshot of Discussion:
Was a very good GD at 2-3 instant turned fishy but then came back to normal

Other Salient Details: I had thought FMS GD's are Machee Markets but mine was far better than I expected even though of such Globe Topic :cheerio:

PI:
Panel Members Intro: 2 lady Proffs, 1 Male Proff (1 Lady Proff(F1)was the lead here)

Questions:

Extempore Topic: Trifurcation of MCD

Questions asked-
F1: So which company are u from ?
Me: Told abt the company and its business in brief.

F1: Dude u did not changed your company even after 3 years
Me: (The company was my @college placement) Mam the company is worth it. :thumbsup:

F1: Given CAT before ?
Me: Yeah 3rd year in the running. Finally got the bounty

F1: What all IIM calls do u have ? Any other converts ?
Me: Told

M1 comes into picture

M1: This is a pen, convince me to change it
Me: 1. Pen did not had a cap
2. Change the grip for better feel and hold

M1: Anything else
Me: You can change the design of the body of the pen.more streamlined such that better hold and feel of the pen. More fluent and easy writing.

F1, F2 , M1 Oks we are done.
F1: Best of Luck......

Hope it helps :cheers:




Interview experience- Good

Misc Details-

Documents required - CAT scorecard and College Final percentage

Total duration of whole process : It was expected to start @11 am but I was given the 2 pm slot but my chance came @3pm slot. Process was completed in 1 hour though was the 5th to get interviewed.


Surprises(if any) add Overall Experience - Nopes

Verdict- Converted....Rank 10......

Hi everyone...
I had my interview yesterday... and was one of the victims of the rescheduling thing... But actually there was some mistake in the list, so all confusion... GDPI for 8:00 AM slot began at 10:00 (Certificate verification started at 9:00). the interview may last upto 2:00PM for this slot, mine ended at 12:30.
Certificates to carry: 10 class, graduation, caste, only these were being asked for...
Coming to my experince:
GD Topic was: Did Chinese economy supress the traditional western business model...
Extempore: Black...
They didn't even let me to introduce myself... as soon I entered the room, they gave me the topic and started the timer....
PI: very few questions may be 5 or 6... total interview did not last even for 5 mins...
All the Best...