You have to read through the posts ,,, there are a number of occasions where I have mentioned the selection criteria ... why there's a waiting pool and no waitlist number ... how the things work.. how are students called from the wait list... everything is here .. all you need is to go through it ... :sneaky:


but lastly ... whoever selected will praise the college .. who did not might have different views ... so nothing unexpected but am only replying because the things you are pointing finger at are our 1 year of hard work to select the best possible batch ..

but ATB to everyone :biggrin:

SCMHRDian my friend, its not about being "selected" or "rejected". Its about a transparency level that a good college is expected to maintain. Trust me, just for once (though its hard to believe that you will), SCMHRD's way of giving result phone calls, the imaginary pool of selected students, the lack of courage to display the wait list numbers, the so called seniors disclosing "not selected list of candidates" on PG, and the college not finding tym to update the portal are few instances that raise a serious doubt over the transparency level of "YOUR COLLEGE".

Anyways, happy studying mate, enjoy life to the fullest, after all you also must have worked really hard for "1 year" on studies to reach this level. I will assume in the meantime that there is probably something better in store for me.

Take Care
Varunn Kaushik

I was a bit inactive in this forum over the last one and a half months or so because of final semester examinations and project submissions etc. I came back today and I was shocked to see people maligning the name of this institution by saying utter rubbish, and why? just because they haven't got through the waitlist or the waitlist hasn't moved???

First things first, I just wanna ask you ppl one thing? Are you seriously MBA aspirants or u r doing an MBA just because you saw your friends doing the same or due to parental pressure? If any of the two mentioned reasons in the case, I accept your case on the ground that you have a false perception about the course.

But if that is not the case, I just wanna ask one thing. Why? My heartfelt sympathy to those who couldn't convert or had been waiting anxiously for these 2 months waiting for a convert only to face rejection later but is this the way to vent out your frustration? It has been repeated umpteen times in this forum that there is a different selection criteria as far as waitlist is concerned. Still there are people asking repeatedly about why the waitlist number is not given. Why will an institute change it's policy? And SCMHRD is not a run-of-the-mill MBA college. Do a bit of a market survey and you'll see for yourself how reputed the college is in the corporate sector. And if you have that much complaint regarding thhe movement of waitlist and you expect something "fishy" is going on, I just wanna ask you ppl one question, have you ppl ever thought whether there is anything fishy regarding the normalization process applied in computation of CAT scores? That I guess is more fishy than SCMHRD's waiting list and if not more, of equal gravity. Even the normalization process applied in NMAT score computation, isn't that fishy? Think ppl think.

And regarding placement, do you ppl consider b-schools as placement agencies where you walk-in, deposit fees and roam around for 2 years and after that, you'll be placed in Proctor & Gamble? If dats your conception, I really doubt you ppl's maturity level for an MBA. You ppl are busy discussing about those "unplaced" students (data collected from you ppl's posts only, not my own conclusion) but no one is discussing about the companies that came, the profiles they offered and the people who walked away with a good job. And it is being repeatedly said that admissions committee members are away on summers still they are being mocked at by some people. What showcase of class!!

And to end on, if you ppl you arre far more better than SCMHRD's students, you are free to take another shot at CAT,XAT,etc and next time, dun apply to scmhrd. simple. I dunno what joy you derive by maligning the name of an institute. Even I cudn't crack CAT but never have i maligned the institutes under cat even though upon deep inspection, it will be found that even they are plagued by problems.

A request:- pls let this thread be one where the waitlisted candidates can know their status and where ppl can share their doubts and queries instead of a thread of mudslinging. Cheers.


Sandipan Deb
MBA 2012-2014
SCMHRD

Dude, congrats for being an SCMHRDian. All the best and I hope you scale great heights.

One more thing my friend...dont get emotional...stop defending a place where you have not even started....

Check with your seniors if you can:
are they supposed or allowed to disclose the rejected candidates list on the web on a platform like PG, if yes, its an amazing insti, students get such rights...great?

If possible, ask yourself, what must be a reason to first change the deadline of form submission and secondly the reason for not disclosing any wait list numbers. Thirdly, forget the portal, they call up students, "Aap hamare lucky draw ke winner hai, u are selected". Why cant this B school hire a staff easily available in the market for Rs. 5k to update the portal...

No hard feelings mate, I am still wait listed, but trust me, there are a lot more grey areas than expected.

kamal8782000 Says

when did u got the mail???/ just 2 days back scmhrdian told that ur name is not on the list....... so 4th list chalu ho gaya kya????

Finally received mail from SCMHRD .... converted!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin::grin:
Just cant believe it bt yes i hv made it!!!!

MUBARAK HO BHAI...

it is not something like this insti is bad n al. This insit has some insane policies which are out of my bound,i am rejected kewl in that.If i would have got to knw this 2 months back things woud have been better n smooth now,rather dan waiting blindly for waitlist moment without any clue.. this is ridiculous.

2nd tym i dn want myself to b in same situation.
Either i am in or out,that should b clear in 1 simple shot.Ample of colleges are there who disclose such things candidly,i woud prefer dose in future.If SCMHRD is not interted in such way kewl I am out.
2,3 saal baad mera bhi kahi ho hi jana hai n SCMHRD would also incorporate 240 students in upcoming batches.SO NO big deal for any of the one..

1. nEver expected any of these weird policies from them...consider the college not good enuf 4 u my friend...

2. Replace an engineer with an engineer, BA guy with a BA girl...
are you joking my friend...can someone ask the great SCMHRD college,
y dont you publsh on the website... Engineering wait pool, BA wait pool..oh...and after that please hold a lucky draw.....

and above all, publically a student of this college writes that mr. X is not selected in 3rd list....kasam se yaar..heights hai....

Whats the waitlist movement for the DA category, has IIMS released any list today ?

yatinkumar Says

Can we file a RTI for final scores of everyone for SCMHRD??... Some guys had got the whole final mark list for IIFT through RTI...

Dude ji, I have heard that people get their scores even from IIM Lucknow by filing an RTI...

But, SCMHRD se aisa karwana mushkil hi nahi, naa mumkin hai...(private colleges are still not under the RTI sphere I guess)

Yaar, leave IIM A, SIOM bhi list pe list lapete pada hai,

par hamare janaab ki taraf se koi jawaab nahi hai....

Y this Kolaveri D?

Kya yaar, what is the definition of 1st week.....

skscsr Says

How can we help you?

just wanted to know, till wat position the wait list has moved for PH category

Hello IIM Convertees,

can you please tell me, wat is the waitlist movement for the Physically Challenged candidates (IIM Shilong...)

koi bata do yaar, My admission in a different institute depends on the wait list movement of ph category...please let me know

Hello IIM Convertees,

can you please tell me, wat is the waitlist movement for the Physically Challenged candidates (IIM Shilong...)