Is CAT fair now?
-No way!
Will the CAT ever be fair if we continue to adhere to the onl9 format?
-NO way!
consider the shortcomings::
1) It is absurd to believe tht prometric ppl would be able to conduct an exam for 2.5 lac students in a span of 10 DAYS, unless IIM's themselves have thr own testing labs whr 500 students can take the test at the same time..
2) PRometric ppl have only a fraction of blame to be shared , it is solely IIM's fault consider this :: even if prometric ppl have been able to conduct the test properly was thr a gurantee tht the invigilaters would have adhered to a strict code of conduct thr have been reports tht invigilators were very uncooperative , had thr cell phones in the testing labs, how do u put an end to it?
prometric also conducts exams like GRE ( so they r very credible)
3) To start with CAT was always a very unstructured exam ..by tht i mean write CAT 3 times u can have a percentile range frm 70-99!(many ppl actually have tht kindff range and mind you i am not saying tht thr scores increase gradually ..they just are all over the spectrum! so end result the LUCK FACTOR is a hugh thing whn it comes to CAT!
4) my most serious question which no one so far has put up...wht abt the misprints/incorrect questions..?
It was unfair evn in the PBT format whn IIM ppl made one single ppr, the were miprints but since tht ppr was taken by all the candidates it was still justifiable , now with 20 pprs it is redicuolus to assume tht IIM ppl would not make mistakes in setting the ppr..so it all boils down to the SLOT u picked tht's gonna decide ur fate..in an exam whr in CAT 2008 a 51 in VA could have got u an IIM -A and a 47 in VA with 99.85 percentile would have not helped u in getting tht seat!
Q) wiLL the things change next yr?
- my ans to tht question is read abt IIM-S these days , tht elucidates how serious IIM ppl are , moreover they don;t give a crap if ur future is at stake the fact is india is a pool of innumerous talent , if one deserving candidate goes out of the compt. for no fault of his own thr is always the next DESERVING guy waiting in line!
only advice:: " Be ExcEPtioNaL OR bE gOne"..FOR CAT 10