The SP Jain Institute of Management and Research,on the other hand has 81% of the Class of 2014 with experience of average 24 months. According to Professor AbbasAli Gabula, Deputy Director, External Relations and Administration, it would be naive to put a figure or ideate on what should be the right % which should be with or without experience. "It is important to know the batch composition about their career path," Prof Gabula said.

SPJIMR iinsists on specialisation selection upfront on application. Each specialisation has different criteria for shortlisting and final selection. At SPJIMR Marketing has 31% freshers, Finance has 40% freshers, Information Management has 6% freshers and Operations has 100% experienced ranging from 14 to 54 months.

Prof Godwyn Tennyson, Placements Chairperson at IIM Trichy says that work experience is just one of the many components of its selection process.”Whatever mix we see is purely an outcome of the process. However, in certain universities abroad, work experience is a prerequisite for applying to the management programme.” Prof Tennyson added that the ideal intake of the proportion of the freshers is driven by the requirements of the companies recruiting from the campuses. “Some firms strictly look for students with work experience while some look for freshers. From the academic front, freshers add an additional dimension to the diversity of the batch and adds flavor to the classroom learning," he added.

The debate concerning freshers over work-ex is quite a recent one. In the last decade or so, most top schools flaunted huge chunks of freshers, except say for a school like the Indian School of Business, Hyderabad where work-ex has always been a clear requirement.

Another faculty who did not wish to be named said that the need to get in diversity can sometime skew ratios one way or the other. “Since the trend is to take in fewer engineers and more women, the ratio of freshers can always rise. Some of the older IIMs did have huge number of non-work-ex students earlier but the trend slowly shifted towards getting in more work-ex."

One viewpoint is that many of the newer IIMs for their first intake did take in a good portion of freshers, keeping in mind the availability in the source pool and being new at the admission game. The cut-offs for the Common Admission Test were and are also lower with the older IIMs. “But over time even the newer IIMs have been trying to increase the number of work-ex students to attract good companies for placements," said an admissions official from one of the new IIMs.

A faculty member from an IIM in the south said that he would love to see more students from the humanities and social sciences background applying to his school, and if he does get a healthy group of diverse students, he would not mind them not having anywork-ex. . It's ironic that the IIMs have such varied admission criteria in place. While, on one hand the institutes need to be appreciated for being able to retain a personal character, on the other hand, they are letting out confusing signals to the student community at large, more so since the IIMs admit from a common student pool.

Also, the fact cannot be ignored that if the IIMs want to speak to a more global audience, they will have to make work-ex a condition. Yes, most MBA programmes abroad are of a year's duration and often undertaken for a 'change of career path.' In India, the course being two years, it is usually taken to 'build' one's career.

Students themselves however find the contest between freshers and work-ex students baseless. Kavya Amarnath from the current first year batch of IIM Indore says that it does not work negatively to have so many freshers in the class. “There are some subjects that experienced students can add to like operations and marketing. But for subjects like HR etc it is good that s much fresh perspective comes from those without any work ex.

Mainak Bhowmik also from the same batch who has some work-ex says that for many subjects having a new perspective which is not discussed before, adds to the knowledge flow in the class. “Those with work-ex will know things the way they have experienced it but when there is no prior experience, there is no limit to the ideas.” Mainak adds that to really know the worth of work-ex, students should have completed a few years on a job, not just a year or two like what is mostly seen.

An alumnus from IIM Calcutta told PaGaLGuY that it was safer to have a bigger proportion of experienced students in the class because experience at a work place gets in uncommon and many views to a classroom. "While if there are too many freshers, the experiences to be shared are far fewer."