puys do any of u have IMS test pack for XAT? if yes then cud u pls tell me is it worth buying?? I mean if the mocks in the pack are same as last years' questions then it wud be useless for me. pls reply soon.

"The statesman who should attempt to direct private people in what manner they ought to employ their capitals would not only load himself with most unnecessary attention but assume an authority which could safely be trusted to no council and senate whatever, and which would nowhere be so dangerous as in the hands of man who have folly and presumption enough to fancy himself fit to exercise it."

This was the XAT 2011 essay...........
Can any1 explain me what it asked xactly???

spiritofmars Says

It's an excerpt from Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, if I remember correctly. You need to present your views on the statement. You can talk about the consequences of license raj in India, deregulation in 1991-92, abuse of economic power by citing multiple examples of corruption & misuse of authority... there are multiple approaches.

I think the excerpt has been nicely put in other words by spiritofmars...
My take on such kind of essay writing would be either u go against it or for it...give 2 to 3 examples with 2 to 3 facts...

cognizant_81 Says

well let me explain with small illustration you see petrol/deisel prices rising randomly irrespective of stable international prices still here at national there is volatility in oil prices.all due to government has given free hand to ONGC,IOC an dother private players to manipulate prices for their profits.result you can see by yourself due to rising pricves in oil it has immediately affected torise in prices in cereals,vegetables,fruits,dry fruits.

i think the topic implies to Totalitarianism or a totalitarian leader (like kim jong ll).....

"The statesman who should attempt to direct private people in what manner they ought to employ their capitals would not only load himself with most unnecessary attention but assume an authority which could safely be trusted to no council and senate whatever, and which would nowhere be so dangerous as in the hands of man who have folly and presumption enough to fancy himself fit to exercise it."

This was the XAT 2011 essay...........
Can any1 explain me what it asked xactly???

well let me explain with small illustration you see petrol/deisel prices rising randomly irrespective of stable international prices still here at national there is volatility in oil prices.all due to government has given free hand to ONGC,IOC an dother private players to manipulate prices for their profits.result you can see by yourself due to rising pricves in oil it has immediately affected torise in prices in cereals,vegetables,fruits,dry fruits.

Hi can someone please tell me where to search XAT score calculator apart from 2009 and 2011 of test funda?

XAT 2005
The demand for a product (Q) is related to the price (P)
of the product as follows:
Q = 100 2P
The cost (C) of manufacturing the product is related to
the quantity produced in the following manner:
C = Q2 16Q + 2000
As of now the corporate profit tax rate is zero. But the
Government of India is thinking of imposing 25% tax on the
profit of the company.
38. As of now, what is the profit-maximizing output?
(A) 22 (B) 21.5
(C) 20 (D) 19
39. If the government imposes the 25% corporate profit
tax, then what will be the profit maximizing output?
(A) 16.5 (B) 16.125
(C) 15 (D) None of the above


Plz help

Below is the solution:

Q=100-2P
Hence, P=/2(100-Q) where P stands for the price
Cost , C = Q^2-16Q+2000
The profit= Revenue - Cost = > Revenue =P*C = Q*(100-Q)/2 = (100Q-Q^2)/2
Profit = [ (100Q-Q^2)/2-(Q^2-16Q+2000)]
= [100Q-(3*Q^2)+32Q-4000]/2
= [132Q-(3*Q^2)-4000]/2
For Profit to be maximum or minimum, we need to calculate the first differential
dP/dQ= 132-6Q = 0
=> Q=132/6 = 22

That answers your first question

3 A

Now , for next question, since the govt is imposing tax on the profit and not the output, hence, output remains unchanged

39) D since, non of the options is 22

Puys I came across(posted by XLRI students) this link thought it might help u...

The last week guide to XAT 2012

thanks a lot it indeed is very beneficial

Well, you will need to surf around - I doubt you can find a tailor made essay to this particular statement. That being said, you can easily get a huge amount of material on this topic on blogs. You can even take a contrarian stand and argue that the multiple failures of the economic system indicate some amount of regulation is necessary & one cannot let capital deployment be solely a matter of individual choosing.

Really, the best guide is you & your thought process - you will be convincing & eloquent if you are arguing for your own opinions.

can u tell if it can be obtained frm any site???

It's an excerpt from Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, if I remember correctly. You need to present your views on the statement. You can talk about the consequences of license raj in India, deregulation in 1991-92, abuse of economic power by citing multiple examples of corruption & misuse of authority... there are multiple approaches.

"The statesman who should attempt to direct private people in what manner they ought to employ their capitals would not only load himself with most unnecessary attention but assume an authority which could safely be trusted to no council and senate whatever, and which would nowhere be so dangerous as in the hands of man who have folly and presumption enough to fancy himself fit to exercise it."

This was the XAT 2011 essay...........
Can any1 explain me what it asked xactly???

refer to the attachment for the figure, it wld look something like this. blue wala line is first eqn and red wala is 2nd wqn.

just making a wild guess. is th answer 1:1??
thought the figure is not symm. but hunch hai. :p

for solving a parabola u need to know higher maths...this question requires use of integration...a basic formula of integration
integration of x^n=x^n+1/n+1
in this question u have to integrate it upon x axis....first by solving the equation
the 2 parabolas meet at 1/2,1
the area of the triangle formed is 1/4.integrating the first parabolic exuation we get 4x^3/3
integrating second we get root2(2/3)x^3/2.put 1/2 in these 2 equations we get 1/6 and1/3.now subtract area of traingle from 1/3 and 1/6.taking mode of the two(as area cant be negative) and dividing them we get 1:1 ratio.....

XAT 2005
The demand for a product (Q) is related to the price (P)
of the product as follows:
Q = 100 2P
The cost (C) of manufacturing the product is related to
the quantity produced in the following manner:
C = Q2 16Q + 2000
As of now the corporate profit tax rate is zero. But the
Government of India is thinking of imposing 25% tax on the
profit of the company.
38. As of now, what is the profit-maximizing output?
(A) 22 (B) 21.5
(C) 20 (D) 19
39. If the government imposes the 25% corporate profit
tax, then what will be the profit maximizing output?
(A) 16.5 (B) 16.125
(C) 15 (D) None of the above


Plz help

Hello deepak ,
Option 38 A
and 39 A..

I am not pretty sure can I have OAs.

XAT 2005
The demand for a product (Q) is related to the price (P)
of the product as follows:
Q = 100 2P
The cost (C) of manufacturing the product is related to
the quantity produced in the following manner:
C = Q2 16Q + 2000
As of now the corporate profit tax rate is zero. But the
Government of India is thinking of imposing 25% tax on the
profit of the company.
38. As of now, what is the profit-maximizing output?
(A) 22 (B) 21.5
(C) 20 (D) 19
39. If the government imposes the 25% corporate profit
tax, then what will be the profit maximizing output?
(A) 16.5 (B) 16.125
(C) 15 (D) None of the above


Plz help

well coaching insitutes are sometimes spoil the temp after giving couple of mock XATs in IMS, when i started giving Test funda mock XAts found DM/AR section and few quant Qs repetitive spoiling the tempo of test environment.based on my experience i advice Puys to take up IMS CL TIME mocks.Test funda mocks individual wise Q solving to improve one's concepts but its mocks not reliable to be solved upon as i feel its wastage of time energy is re solving the solved Qs once.

the XAT05 para questions

Taxonomy can be described as the orderly classification of organisms according to their presumed natural
relationship, Three distinct steps are involved. First, each species must be identified, described, and
named. Second, each species is placed in its correct phylogenetic position relative to other species. Third,
keys or means allowing the Identification of species by non-taxonomists need to be prepared. To ensure
reproducibility and generalization that form the foundation of all social and biological! studies, a sound
understanding of all three of these steps is required.
Reproducibility the potential for other worker to repeat apiece of work is fundamental to all scientific
research, and whether the discipline is biochemistry, physiology or ecology, the identity of the species
studied is essential information.
Observations, of themselves, are of little value to science. Only when facts are placed in a proper context
can generalizations be made or tested, From the observed similarities and differences between the studied
species and closely related or distantly related species, the significance of the observed facts can be
discussed and more accurate generalizations developed. Sound taxonomy, then, is a critical prerequisite of
the work of all biologists.
It has as well its service functions. Taxonomy supplies through the delineation of phylogenetic
relationships within and between groups, the basic data for developing and testing ideas on pattern and
mechanism in the evolutionary process and in biogeography.

160. Observations, of themselves, are of little value. to science, because,
They are without any purpose
For generalization, they have to be related to other facts
They are not systematic and are not, therefore, amenable to scientific interpretation
They can be given meaning only if they are collected by a scientist

161. Which one of the following statement is the closest to the central idea of the passage?
Taxonomic classification is necessary for the identification of the species
Reproducibility and generalizations are the basic criterion for judging the value of a scientific
research
Taxonomy provides the base for the placement of Observations in the right perspective for
generalizations
It is very-necessary to understand well the steps in taxonomic classification in order to conduct
scientific research in biological sciences


162. How does taxonomy help in biogeography?
It guarantees proper identification of species
It discharges a service function
It supplies the basic data for developing and testing specific ideas
It helps in relating man to the physical environment


163. According to the author, which of the following information is considered essential for research in
life sciences?
Hypothesis regarding species
Reproducibility of species
Generalizability of species
Taxonomic classification of species
Guys, I don't have the OAs.. If someone with the hard copy has it, post it later..

My answers r in bold..can we have OA....
Explanations PLZZ:)

the XAT05 para questions

Taxonomy can be described as the orderly classification of organisms according to their presumed natural
relationship, Three distinct steps are involved. First, each species must be identified, described, and
named. Second, each species is placed in its correct phylogenetic position ........................
mechanism in the evolutionary process and in biogeography.

160. Observations, of themselves, are of little value. to science, because,
They are without any purpose
For generalization, they have to be related to other facts
They are not systematic and are not, therefore, amenable to scientific interpretation
They can be given meaning only if they are collected by a scientist

161. Which one of the following statement is the closest to the central idea of the passage?
Taxonomic classification is necessary for the identification of the species
Reproducibility and generalizations are the basic criterion for judging the value of a scientific
research
Taxonomy provides the base for the placement of Observations in the right perspective for
generalizations
It is very-necessary to understand well the steps in taxonomic classification in order to conduct
scientific research in biological sciences


162. How does taxonomy help in biogeography?
It guarantees proper identification of species
It discharges a service function
It supplies the basic data for developing and testing specific ideas
It helps in relating man to the physical environment


163. According to the author, which of the following information is considered essential for research in
life sciences?
Hypothesis regarding species
Reproducibility of species
Generalizability of species
Taxonomic classification of species

Guys, I don't have the OAs.. If someone with the hard copy has it, post it later..

My Take
option 2
option 4
option 2
option 4



The OA is given as

option 2
option 4
option 1
option 1

Can some one please explain the reasoning for Q3 and Q4..PLZ

Hi Puys,


Below is a question set.

Four students Promila,Qadir,Rita ans Sridhar each working under the supervision of one of the 4 professors - Anand,Bose,Chandrashekhar and Deshpande ,made their final year MBA project presentation one by one ,one each in the areas of finance, marketing, HRM and Systems. Given that each professor is an expert in only one of the above 4 areas and supervised exactly one of the 4 students in his own area. The following clues are provided:

(i) First presentation was made by Rita
(ii)Prof Bose works in Finance
(iii)Prof Deshpande was Promila's supervisor
(iv)The last presenation was in systems area
(v) Sridhar's project was in HRM
(vi)Prof Bose's student's presentation followed that of Prof Chandrashekhar's student's presentation

!) In which area was Rita's project?
a) Marketing
b) Finance
c) Systems
d) Can't be determined
e) None of these

2) What is Prof Deshpande's area of expertise?
a) Marketing
b) HRM
c) Systems
d) can't be determined
e) None of the above

3) In which area was the 2nd presentation given?
a) Finance
b) Marketing
c) HRM
d) Can't be determined
e) None of the above

4)Which student's project did prof Bose supervise?
a) Qadir
b) Rita
c) Sridhar
d) can't be determined
e) None of the above

5) What is Prof Anand's area of expertise?
I.HRM II.Systems III.Marketing
a) Either I or II
b) Either I or III
c) Either II or III
d) Neither I nor II nor III
e) None of the above

Answers :

1) a
2) c
3) d
4) a
5) b

Puys I came across(posted by XLRI students) this link thought it might help u...

The last week guide to XAT 2012

the XAT05 para questions

Taxonomy can be described as the orderly classification of organisms according to their presumed natural
relationship, Three distinct steps are involved. First, each species must be identified, described, and
named. Second, each species is placed in its correct phylogenetic position relative to other species. Third,
keys or means allowing the Identification of species by non-taxonomists need to be prepared. To ensure
reproducibility and generalization that form the foundation of all social and biological! studies, a sound
understanding of all three of these steps is required.
Reproducibility the potential for other worker to repeat apiece of work is fundamental to all scientific
research, and whether the discipline is biochemistry, physiology or ecology, the identity of the species
studied is essential information.
Observations, of themselves, are of little value to science. Only when facts are placed in a proper context
can generalizations be made or tested, From the observed similarities and differences between the studied
species and closely related or distantly related species, the significance of the observed facts can be
discussed and more accurate generalizations developed. Sound taxonomy, then, is a critical prerequisite of
the work of all biologists.
It has as well its service functions. Taxonomy supplies through the delineation of phylogenetic
relationships within and between groups, the basic data for developing and testing ideas on pattern and
mechanism in the evolutionary process and in biogeography.

160. Observations, of themselves, are of little value. to science, because,
They are without any purpose
For generalization, they have to be related to other facts
They are not systematic and are not, therefore, amenable to scientific interpretation
They can be given meaning only if they are collected by a scientist

161. Which one of the following statement is the closest to the central idea of the passage?
Taxonomic classification is necessary for the identification of the species
Reproducibility and generalizations are the basic criterion for judging the value of a scientific
research
Taxonomy provides the base for the placement of Observations in the right perspective for
generalizations
It is very-necessary to understand well the steps in taxonomic classification in order to conduct
scientific research in biological sciences


162. How does taxonomy help in biogeography?
It guarantees proper identification of species
It discharges a service function
It supplies the basic data for developing and testing specific ideas
It helps in relating man to the physical environment


163. According to the author, which of the following information is considered essential for research in
life sciences?
Hypothesis regarding species
Reproducibility of species
Generalizability of species
Taxonomic classification of species

Guys, I don't have the OAs.. If someone with the hard copy has it, post it later..

Puys I just saw a couple of Para based questions in XAT 2005(hard copy). The questions and the choices given are so irritating and turning me mad. I cannot even call it difficult, but its way beyond it.
If some one has the soft copy of XAT 2005 papers plz copy paste the para based questions on taxonomy
the one on "concept.."
Lets discuss the questions

I have the proper ebook version of Critical reasoning bible. (arnd 1.4 mb).
PM me your mail ID and I will send it across.

hi,
i hv sent my mail id to u...waiting for ur Ebook...

hey, plz send me that ebook...

Dude posting ur mail id is against PG rule. Please PM it.

chugh.manisha Says

Will check it from some other source and confirm !!

Yeah me too came across the same prob in one mocks, the explanation is not clear. Option a-d is not fitting.
However, I will suggest one link for a typical problem. manisha's problem reminded me of that-
Of Cubes and Matchsticks - Logical Reasoning Tricks for CAT 2011 | PaGaLGuY.com - Indias biggest website for MBA in India, International MBA, CAT, XAT, SNAP, MAT

can anyone suggest me any ebook for LR????

manoj1986 Says

the key is probably incorrect.

Will check it from some other source and confirm !!

chugh.manisha Says

Had (b) been the correct option, your logic would have sufficed but I fail to understand and fir in ur logic with 4 as the starting move for A

the key is probably incorrect.

let me clear what i hv got as solution..

let A make 2,,,
(after this whatever B makes A has to make this pair equal to 11)

therefore 2+11+11+11+(here comes the winning move,,it is B's turn whatever he choose A ll make it to 46)

hope m clear..

correct me if m wrong :)

Had (b) been the correct option, your logic would have sufficed but I fail to understand and fir in ur logic with 4 as the starting move for A

dont know, I still think there is something wrong with the question. It doesnt clearly mention anything about same number/different numbers. moreover, options are like A must start with 2,4 so on but not "A must select/choose 4"

Hi Puys,


Below is a question set.

Four students Promila,Qadir,Rita ans Sridhar each working under the supervision of one of the 4 professors - Anand,Bose,Chandrashekhar and Deshpande ,made their final year MBA project presentation one by one ,one each in the areas of finance, marketing, HRM and Systems. Given that each professor is an expert in only one of the above 4 areas and supervised exactly one of the 4 students in his own area. The following clues are provided:

(i) First presentation was made by Rita
(ii)Prof Bose works in Finance
(iii)Prof Deshpande was Promila's supervisor
(iv)The last presenation was in systems area
(v) Sridhar's project was in HRM
(vi)Prof Bose's student's presentation followed that of Prof Chandrashekhar's student's presentation

!) In which area was Rita's project?
a) Marketing
b) Finance
c) Systems
d) Can't be determined
e) None of these

2) What is Prof Deshpande's area of expertise?
a) Marketing
b) HRM
c) Systems
d) can't be determined
e) None of the above

3) In which area was the 2nd presentation given?
a) Finance
b) Marketing
c) HRM
d) Can't be determined
e) None of the above

4)Which student's project did prof Bose supervise?
a) Qadir
b) Rita
c) Sridhar
d) can't be determined
e) None of the above

5) What is Prof Anand's area of expertise?
I.HRM II.Systems III.Marketing
a) Either I or II
b) Either I or III
c) Either II or III
d) Neither I nor II nor III
e) None of the above

can anyone explain me...Prof Bose's student's presentation followed that of Prof Chandrashekhar's student's presentation means what??
prof bose student comes after chandrashekhar's student??

chugh.manisha Says

Hey, i agree with the 35 but what is the trick when one backtracks from 35 to 24 or 15? Please share the logic.

Actually it is like,
46-(10+1) = 35 needed
35 - 11 = 24 needed
24 - 11 = 13 needed
13 - 11 = 2 needed



..............................................

manoj1986 Says

oh I tought A can choose different numbers in different iterations

Dats what...One needs to nail the backtracking knowledge to arrive at 4 as the answer!

chugh.manisha Says

OA is option (d) A starts with 4

oh I tought A can choose different numbers in different iterations

Two players A and B play the following game .A selects an integer from 1 to 10 , inclusive of both. B then adds any positive integer from 1 to 10 , both inclusive , to the number selected by A.The player who reaches 46 first wins the game.If the game is played properly, A may win the game if:

a) A selects 8 to begin with
b) A selects 2 to begin with
c) A selects any number greater than 5
d) A selects 4 to begin with
e) None of the above

OA is option (d) A starts with 4

if A select 2 then B will play intelligently and make 4..after that it wud be imposible for A to win.
coz after 4 B will make 15 and then 35

A-2,B-4,A-7,B-x,A-11-x
I dont see A losing, can you provide the entire path? assuming A plays well and chooses 11-the number chosen by B

manoj1986 Says

I think b is correct too, can you give ma counter example to prove b wrong..oops intended for sujamait

Iteration 1:
A chooses 2 ,B chooses 9 (suppose) total =11
Iteration 2:
A again chooses 2 , B chooses 8 | total = 21
Iteration 3 :
A chooses 3 this time , B chooses 9 | total = 33
Iteration 4 :
A chooses 1 this time , B doesn total = 35
Iteration 5 :
Now no matter what A chooses, B will win the game


Correct me if I'm wrong!

manoj1986 Says

I think b is correct too, can you give ma counter example to prove b wrong..oops intended for sujamait

if A select 2 then B will play intelligently and make 4..after that it wud be imposible for A to win.
coz after 4 B will make 15 and then 35

manoj1986 Says

I think b is correct too, can you give ma counter example to prove b wrong..oops intended for sujamait

manoj answer is b in any case,,
I hope manisha confirms the same

manoj1986 Says

I think b is correct too, can you give ma counter example to prove b wrong..oops intended for sujamait

If A starts with 2
Ist iteration : A chooses 2
B can

To:pankaj

The last week guide to XAT 2012

this link ll help u a lot

chugh.manisha Says

Hey, i agree with the 35 but what is the trick when one backtracks from 35 to 24 or 15? Please share the logic.

I think b is correct too, can you give ma counter example to prove b wrong..oops intended for sujamait

Hi I have one question regarding XAT..... What will be the exact format of XAT paper .... Is there any essay that we r supposed to write for exam ... any link regarding this will help .... Thanks in advance..

A need to make 35 or 15, so it has to select 4

................................

Hey, i agree with the 35 but what is the trick when one backtracks from 35 to 24 or 15? Please share the logic.

Two players A and B play the following game .A selects an integer from 1 to 10 , inclusive of both. B then adds any positive integer from 1 to 10 , both inclusive , to the number selected by A.The player who reaches 46 first wins the game.If the game is played properly, A may win the game if:

a) A selects 8 to begin with
b) A selects 2 to begin with
c) A selects any number greater than 5
d) A selects 4 to begin with
e) None of the above

A need to make 35 or 15, so it has to select 4

................................

manoj1986 Says

ans is b. a must select 2 to win. because that will assure he will get to 13,24,35,46

manoj.. if u used sm formula..
plz share..

manoj1986 Says

in the same way I arrived at 35 from 46. subtracting 11 we get to next level

But the answer is d and not b

chugh.manisha Says

Well, i agree to your knowledge of leaving B with a total of 35 to win .however, how are we backtracking to 24 and 13 and 2 ?

in the same way I arrived at 35 from 46. subtracting 11 we get to next level

manoj1986 Says

ans is b. a must select 2 to win. because that will assure he will get to 13,24,35,46

Well, i agree to your knowledge of leaving B with a total of 35 to win .however, how are we backtracking to 24 and 13 and 2 ?

Two players A and B play the following game .A selects an integer from 1 to 10 , inclusive of both. B then adds any positive integer from 1 to 10 , both inclusive , to the number selected by A.The player who reaches 46 first wins the game.If the game is played properly, A may win the game if:

a) A selects 8 to begin with
b) A selects 2 to begin with
c) A selects any number greater than 5
d) A selects 4 to begin with
e) None of the above

ans is b. a must select 2 to win. because that will assure he will get to 13,24,35,46

Manisha.. firstly this ques was a bit incomplete.. btw ratios of roots of both eqn were equal was implicit..
sol) equate ratios of both eqn
apply C and D
squaring both sides
DONE :)

Hey, this was straight from one of the mock test with nothing per my knwledge missing. But, yes implicit assumption is required to solve it.

Two players A and B play the following game .A selects an integer from 1 to 10 , inclusive of both. B then adds any positive integer from 1 to 10 , both inclusive , to the number selected by A.The player who reaches 46 first wins the game.If the game is played properly, A may win the game if:

a) A selects 8 to begin with
b) A selects 2 to begin with
c) A selects any number greater than 5
d) A selects 4 to begin with
e) None of the above

chugh.manisha Says

That's correct!! U r such a rockstar I must say Can you please xplain this one ?

Manisha.. firstly this ques was a bit incomplete.. btw ratios of roots of both eqn were equal was implicit..
sol) equate ratios of both eqn
apply C and D
squaring both sides
DONE

chugh.manisha Says

If I go by your logic, shouldn't d be 10 and not 20?

no in first case roots are 5,1 ratio is 5
in second case roots are 10,2 ratio is 5
(x-2)(x-10)= x^2-12x+20

chugh.manisha Says

That's correct!! U r such a rockstar I must say Can you please xplain this one ?

let the roots of the 1st eqn. be p and q

p+q=2a
pq=b

(p+q)^2=4a^2 divide this by pq=b

do the same with the 2nd equation

and solve...

one way to solve is by example.
x^2-6x+5=0 and x^2-12x+20=0
a=3,b=5,c=6,d=20
comparing the options, you can see that c is right

If I go by your logic, shouldn't d be 10 and not 20?

If the ratio of roots of the equation x^2-2ax+b=0 is equal to x^2-2cx+d=0 ,then
a)(a^2)*b = (c^2)*d
b)(a^2)*c = (b^2)*d
c)(a^2)*d = (c^2)*b
d)(d^2)*b = (c^2)*a
e)None of these

My take...

If the ratio of roots of the equation x^2-2ax+b=0 is equal to x^2-2cx+d=0 ,then
a)(a^2)*b = (c^2)*d
b)(a^2)*c = (b^2)*d
c)(a^2)*d = (c^2)*b
d)(d^2)*b = (c^2)*a
e)None of these

is it ratio of roots of eq1 equals ratio of roots of eq2 ? i didn get it.
if yes then option C

..................................

ImaRebel Says

my take in bold!!!

That's correct!! U r such a rockstar I must say Can you please xplain this one ?

If the ratio of roots of the equation x^2-2ax+b=0 is equal to x^2-2cx+d=0 ,then
a)(a^2)*b = (c^2)*d
b)(a^2)*c = (b^2)*d
c)(a^2)*d = (c^2)*b
d)(d^2)*b = (c^2)*a
e)None of these

one way to solve is by example.
x^2-6x+5=0 and x^2-12x+20=0
a=3,b=5,c=6,d=20
comparing the options, you can see that c is right