Instead of just having a general discussion on SC strategies, I thought it would be useful if I list down a sample SC, and my approach towards tackling it ... I'm sure if others also do the same thing, this thread will be tangibly more beneficial to guys preparing for GMAT ... And don't just list down the right answer, but why you think that answer is right, and the others are wrong ...
Ok ... Let me start off ...
Unlike the lives of Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, subjects of other Troyat biographies, Chekhov belongs to the twentieth century, an age of fretfulness and melancholy skepticism.
(A) Unlike the lives of Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, subjects of other Troyat biographies, Chekhov belongs
(B) Chekhov, unlike the other Troyat biographies of Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, belongs
(C) The life of Chekhov, unlike the lives of the subjects of other Troyat biographies, Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, belongs
(D) Chekhov and his life, unlike that of the other Troyat biographiesPushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, belong
(E) The life of Chekhov, unlike that of other Troyat biographies of Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski, belongs
The first thing I do to an SC when I see it is eliminate the noise ... What do I mean by that? ... let's take the sample sentence above ...
- Pushkin, Gogol, Tolstoi, and Dostoevski can all be replaced by one word - composers ...
- Eliminate "Troyat" - it does'nt add any value ... Biographies will do where Troyat biographies was mentioned ...
- "an age of fretfulness and melancholy skepticism" ... No relevant information, and not even appearing in the answer choices ...
Now the sentence reduces to -
Unlike the lives of composers, subjects of other biographies, chekhov belongs to the twentieth century.
That's it ... That is all the information that is relevant to solving the SC ... This is the meat ... The rest of the noise I have eliminated ... This helps to get focus on the main concept being tested ...
And now to attack the problem ... Analyse each choice ...
(A) ... Unlike the lives of composers, Chekov belongs ... WRONG ... comparing lives with Chekov ... Apples and Oranges comparison ...
(B) ... Chekov, unlike the other biographies, belongs ... WRONG ... comparing Chekov with Biographies ...
(C) ... The life of Chekov, unlike the lives of composers ... Seems right ... proper comparison ... But lets check out the rest of the options ...
(D) ... Chekov and his life - belong to the 20th century ... WRONG ... It's only Chekov's life that belongs, not both of them ... Moreover, comparing Chekov and life with biographies ...
(E) ... The life of Chekhov, unlike that of other biographies ... WRONG ... Comparing Chekov's life to the life of other biographies ...
So the answer is 'C' ... In the analysis above I'm not just identifying the correct answer, but WHY it is correct and WHY the others are wrong ... Apply this same approach sincerely, and you'll see your SC problems melting away before your eyes! ...
Other PGites reading this thread ... Please send in a sample question of your own, with your strategies and approach towards the problem ...