Any one applying for hostel and laptop provided by college???

Btwn me applying for both.

I am against fraud.

Mods please look through the postings on this thread and then make up your mind whether or not to close this thread.

You seem to be classic example of third front......Some are against MBS...some are for MBS (such as me)...and you want to altogether stop MBS thread...I think you have misunderstood our posts...By the way i am sanket desai ..You can check my details on MBS selected list....Is saying for or against any college a fraud..i do not think so ..No one is paying me for posting on this forum.....People will come on this forum and will come to know about MBS but that does not mean it is done intentionaly for marketing purpose but it is inherent quality...

Please keep up healthy discussion on this forum...This is meant for sharing views on MBS and i think it should go on...

I am against fraud.

Mods please look through the postings on this thread and then make up your mind whether or not to close this thread.

mbaguide,
I think you are also an insider, just pretending to be presenting the opposite view.
I think this thread deserves to be closed in my view.
It is simply a promo

Hey Dude,
If i would have been an insider, i would have spoken only good things about the institute.Did you in any of my quotes find that i am supporting such B Schools?

I am very particular about the B Schools that i speak for.I am only for ISB and IIM's in India.I am least bothered about any other institute.

Moderators,
We are genuine guys and dont care if someone calls us Insiders.It sounds soo funny someone calling a person as insider who is actually speaking against going to setting up B Schools...

Mr Nothing1954,
Closing the thread does not solve the problem.Someone else will open another thread.If you dont like the B School speak out against it.If you like then speak for it.Either you are for it or against it not IN BETWEEN THE TWO...

Cheers
Roly

Moderators,
Please look through the postings on this thread.
I think it is simply a clever gimmick to promote a schools on PG by a group of people or even possibly just one or two people, with different IDs, concertedly posting some thing or other but with out much useful information.

I request that you kindly close this thread.
Many of the postings on this thread don't seem to be genuine- but just a promotion campaign.

hi,
I dont know how do you felt like this, u r saying that there is a different ids of just one or two persons & all we are fake.........it is a ridiculous, you can check our profiles by our gmail ids or any other ids, my ids is same as my name i.e. Ninad Borse, even my gmail id is ninadborse@gmail.com, & i m posting here as a name "ninadborse" only, you can check my profile on MBS site also, i have taken admission to MBS as a student & not as a promotor, & plz as a roly said our all previous post are not for promoting MBS but giving explanation to those people who are against of out institution, & I think there is nothing wrong in it, if anybody is writing negative about ur school then as a student it is our duty to aware that respected person that what we are thinking & why we took admission in that particular Inst. we were doing the same thing........is it wrong ?
You can check my posts u'll find the same above thing nothing else like promoting, still if you want u can check my orkut profile ie
orkut -
if u want to do further inquiry, u can contact me on my gmail mail, & just prove me fake........? & find out original Ninad borse......if you think thats not me.....:p
& i m appealing all my other friends that please dont stop posting here just bcoz of some hurdles, & prove ur identity as we are not fake.....

regards,
ninad.

regards,
ninad

mbaguide,
I think you are also an insider, just pretending to be presenting the opposite view.
I think this thread deserves to be closed in my view.
It is simply a promo

Moderators,
Please look through the postings on this thread.
I think it is simply a clever gimmick to promote a schools on PG by a group of people or even possibly just one or two people, with different IDs, concertedly posting some thing or other but with out much useful information.

I request that you kindly close this thread.
Many of the postings on this thread don't seem to be genuine- but just a promotion campaign.

Dude,
Every thread has insiders.So what is the whole fuss about promoting a B School???? Every Forum has such activity. If you do not endorse such B Schools then speak out rather than putting up such ridiculous quote to close the thread.

Except me and a few others, there is total positiveness for MBS primarily bcos they are those guys who have taken up admission.If you would have been in their place, you too would have done the same thing .Nobody wants to hear bad about his/her B School.

Let the thread continue so that we can have healthy discussions.

Moderators,
Please look through the postings on this thread.
I think it is simply a clever gimmick to promote a schools on PG by a group of people or even possibly just one or two people, with different IDs, concertedly posting some thing or other but with out much useful information.

I request that you kindly close this thread.
Many of the postings on this thread don't seem to be genuine- but just a promotion campaign.

Hey Nothing1954, great point made.

I didhave my doubts but then I could never be sure then.
Guys, I have confirmed with multiple sources about the credibility of the team...nd I am sorry to inform u that the responses are really pathetic.

I had my doubts with Roly's post - an investment banker it seems...but I didnt post because this was a new school.

Anywazs...I am sure basis conviction... 99% of people posting here are fake guys...u r Promoting MBS.

By the way...I have dropped a mail to Mr. A Mahendren and Dr. Sunil Rai and I believe I will soon get an opportunity to meet Dr. Bala (My fiancee has got through Kellogg, so some discussion ahead related to her career) and will discuss the questionable dubious marketing strategy adopted here.

Wwill keep you all posted.

I missed out on something...

Being an Investment Banker helps you to make a calculated decision.I have spoken to my Seniors, My Colleagues, My Elder Brother (who heads F&O; in one of the Top Investment Bank), Brother's Friends (Industry Seniors with decades of experience). Not even one of them gave a thumbs up to MBS. They say it all Bogus Stuff (People out to make money).... .

Market Leaders are advising aspiring MBA students to go slow on their admissions and wait for the economy to stabilize.

I speak on behalf of those who are putting their hard earned money in such B Schools. Some of my friends who have already done their MBA from B Schools like SP Jain, IIFT, IMT (Ghaziabad),JBIMS are planning once again to do their MBA.When asked why so, there is only one reply "Brand is what we require".Not that they are criticizing their previous B School, but have understood the significane of an IIM/ISB Brand.

Take a Chill-Pill Guys and dont waste your/your parents hard earned money on new B Schools.

All those who will take my advice will come back on this same forum for thanking me.

Roly

Hey Nothing1954, great point made.

I didhave my doubts but then I could never be sure then.
Guys, I have confirmed with multiple sources about the credibility of the team...nd I am sorry to inform u that the responses are really pathetic.

I had my doubts with Roly's post - an investment banker it seems...but I didnt post because this was a new school.

Anywazs...I am sure basis conviction... 99% of people posting here are fake guys...u r Promoting MBS.

By the way...I have dropped a mail to Mr. A Mahendren and Dr. Sunil Rai and I believe I will soon get an opportunity to meet Dr. Bala (My fiancee has got through Kellogg, so some discussion ahead related to her career) and will discuss the questionable dubious marketing strategy adopted here.

Wwill keep you all posted.

My Dear Friend,
Are you agreeing with my views on MBS or trying to speak against me???? I guess you had also spoke for MBS when i was asking people to refrain...

All such forums are primarily to promote B Schools.Hence, you will always find people talking only good about the institute.Well I can understand that for an established B School but when it comes to a new B school being set up, I too have my serious doubts about people commenting on this forum.

If you have carefully followed my earlier posts, I spoke from the viewpoint of industry.I feel bad for those who go for names and shell out huge cash....

I have always felt and will always maintain that you should do your MBA from very well established B Schools.Speak to industry people, your ex-bosses, your ex-colleagues and try to find out about the B School as to what they think about it future prospects, then make a decision.At the same time, wait for the first batch to come out cos the alumni are the best people from whom you will get an honest feedback.

All those who have joined MBS, I wish them all the best

For those who haven't, wait for the first batch to pass out and then join.It is better to wait then take the plunge during such market conditions....

regards,
Roly

Some thing is fishy about this thread.
It is constantly being kept at the first page middle of this forum.

I get the feeling that PG is being made use of to promote this school by some people who have all joined pg very recently, posting some thing or other in a concerted fashion.

Mods, kindly look into this; is this some kind of clever strategy to promote a particular school!

Hey Nothing1954, great point made.

I didhave my doubts but then I could never be sure then.
Guys, I have confirmed with multiple sources about the credibility of the team...nd I am sorry to inform u that the responses are really pathetic.

I had my doubts with Roly's post - an investment banker it seems...but I didnt post because this was a new school.

Anywazs...I am sure basis conviction... 99% of people posting here are fake guys...u r Promoting MBS.

By the way...I have dropped a mail to Mr. A Mahendren and Dr. Sunil Rai and I believe I will soon get an opportunity to meet Dr. Bala (My fiancee has got through Kellogg, so some discussion ahead related to her career) and will discuss the questionable dubious marketing strategy adopted here.

Wwill keep you all posted.

roly (aka mba guide) u might want to answer the question i asked u about addtional add on certification with an MBA.

I mentioned about FRM and PRM... coz am specializing in Fin from MBS and have chosen the field of Risk Management.

Happy Easter!!

neerav_v Says

There's another B-School which started in 2002. Aegis School Of Business & Telecommunications, Aegis School of Business and Telecommunication offers One year MBA, MBA IT, Executive MBA, Part Time MBA, MBA Telecom, MS Computer Science. The reason i'm bringing this is because, Career Launcher promotes this school as well. Would like Roly to comment on Aegis School of Business. Then, Rai Business School, Chetna Mumbai and a lot more B-Schools which are promoted by other coaching institutes, be it IMS, TIME, Career Forum, PT or anything else.. Well since these coaching institutes are promoting the colleges and asking students to join these as well. Would you like to join in those??? Roly, your point regarding the first batch of MBS is taken. If you go through my earlier posts, i have said the same thing as well that the only factor which makes me give a second thought is that it's the first batch of MBS. But there were a lot of other factors which made me finally decide upon joining the school. It's not that i didn't have offers from other B-Schools. I've had a tough time to convince my folks about MBS as well, especially my brother who's an ISB Alumni, 2005 Batch.

Hi Neerav,
You are very true about the B Schools you have enlisted here.I admire your guts dude when you say that you have convinced your family.Guess your brother would totally agree to my knowledge about B Schools:-)

Hope your bet pays of well.

Roly

Some thing is fishy about this thread.
It is constantly being kept at the first page middle of this forum.

I get the feeling that PG is being made use of to promote this school by some people who have all joined pg very recently, posting some thing or other in a concerted fashion.

Mods, kindly look into this; is this some kind of clever strategy to promote a particular school!

Advice from coaching institute consultants can be used as one of the inputs, but not as the last word on a business school. Especially in these days of B-schools owned by coaching institutes. Would IMS have given the same advice about their Praxis Business School when it started out? Of course not. Which proves the validity of seeking advice from a coaching institute. It might have been a great idea two years ago, but not anymore.

Something i missed in my earlier post regarding coaching institutes promoting colleges. We need not look anywhere else, check Roly's post where he/she's has posted reply from IMS. Would you want to join Praxis Business School? Total fee is around 7 odd lacs and the placements so far show that it could manage package around 5lacs. So in your terms it's a loss proposition. No return of investment. Irrespective of the fact that the school was incepted 2 years earlier. Then there's another B-School Proton in Indore, PT's concept. What about that?

tarunminocha Says

I have also got the offer letter from the school ,but i am still confused whether to join it or not . i have not still paid RS 1 lac admit fee.Can somebody help me with some more information except that given on their website

tarun @ can you come out with queries in open so we can do our best to help you out

There's another B-School which started in 2002. Aegis School Of Business & Telecommunications, Aegis School of Business and Telecommunication offers One year MBA, MBA IT, Executive MBA, Part Time MBA, MBA Telecom, MS Computer Science. The reason i'm bringing this is because, Career Launcher promotes this school as well. Would like Roly to comment on Aegis School of Business. Then, Rai Business School, Chetna Mumbai and a lot more B-Schools which are promoted by other coaching institutes, be it IMS, TIME, Career Forum, PT or anything else.. Well since these coaching institutes are promoting the colleges and asking students to join these as well. Would you like to join in those??? Roly, your point regarding the first batch of MBS is taken. If you go through my earlier posts, i have said the same thing as well that the only factor which makes me give a second thought is that it's the first batch of MBS. But there were a lot of other factors which made me finally decide upon joining the school. It's not that i didn't have offers from other B-Schools. I've had a tough time to convince my folks about MBS as well, especially my brother who's an ISB Alumni, 2005 Batch.

All Coaching Institutes promote a certain set of colleges. I wonder if you guys are aware of the fact that, there're lot of colleges who visit various coaching institutes, giving them presentation about their own colleges. I know a faculty personally and he says this to me.
Okay lemme take you through the First Merit List of MBS. Check out profile of Ankita Jain, She's over 2 years of work experience and she's working with CAREER LAUNCHER. I believe, this ends the argument to what coaching institutes have to comment on MBS. Had the case been that sad, i do not think she would have even appeared for the selection process.

Regarding concerns over IMS,time or Career launcher...please check out post by Neerav_v....

@roly we have already discussed this in previous posts(thread 3 to 5)....Hope so you remember it

Hey Roly..

Am glad that you are doing the research about the school and finding out more details about this.

But we would also like to know whom and what are you writing to these "Experts" and "Education Specialist". Cos sometime your words might itself play the answer you desire or rather looking for. So, it also depends what information you are sharing with them in order to get their feedback.

Was just curious to know this..

Cheers!!

My Dear Friend,
I have attached the entire mail that i received from IMS, which includes my query and their reply.You haven't checked the entire thread.Request you verify yourself by putting up a query with them .You can also do the same with TIME and Career Launcher.

Cheers

Guys chk this out..

MBS US faculty - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0o22lxHNpdc&feature;=related

MBS Board - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cflEiAFuPFU&feature;=related

CEO Futurebrands Mr. Santosh Desai - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ly3VxNb0Ck&feature;=related

MBS Placement - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YaLbdQv_UQc


From the CEO Mumbai Business School - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iGlwbE5pbME&feature;=related

Hey Roly..

Am glad that you are doing the research about the school and finding out more details about this.

But we would also like to know whom and what are you writing to these "Experts" and "Education Specialist". Cos sometime your words might itself play the answer you desire or rather looking for. So, it also depends what information you are sharing with them in order to get their feedback.

Was just curious to know this..

Cheers!!

I think so MBS will apply for it ....my rationale is based on Great lakes applying for it .....as great lakes is also framed by Qodrej group...Anyways let's see how it works out

Check out the following link for the latest on AICTE approvals ..

AICTE frames rules for one-year MBA courses - Mumbai - Cities - The Times of India

I hope MBS goes for it as well !!!

Cheers..

I have also got the offer letter from the school ,but i am still confused whether to join it or not . i have not still paid RS 1 lac admit fee.Can somebody help me with some more information except that given on their website

Roly,

People here are aware that it is a new business school. What you are saying is that nobody should join a new business school, which is a pretty paradoxical statement.

You've stated your point enough times in this thread now. Whoever wanted to pay heed to it would already have or not. Leave it upto them. Let's move on in life now.

Cheers,
Apurv

Dude,

This is the response i got from IMS today for MBS.I think this will create a new debate...

Guys you can call up TIME, IMS or Career Launcher and find out yourself.



Dear Roly,
Thank you for writing in to IMS. MBS is not among the better known schools in the nation and hence not recommended. I suggest that you opt for this school only if you have constraints to join a B-school this year itself, otherwise you can surely take the tests again and apply to some of the best schools in the nation.
Do write back to us in case you need any further clarifications.

All the Best!

Regards

IMS Student Guidance Cell.

IIM CAT 2009, CAT 2009 : IMS India : Training for IIM entrance exams, MBA in India, MBA Abroad, CAT Coaching / training (IMS Home Page)
myIMS - Home (Your personalized home page)
Praxis Business School (The IMS B-School in Kolkata)
Advancedge MBA Online :: Mastering Business Acumen (The IMS publications Site)
Welcome :: IMS Proschool (The IMS School for Professional Education)




From :dolha007@yahoo.com
To : ims@imsindia.com
_________________________________________________________
Need help
Name:Roly
Experience :4 yrs
Qualification :MSc
Student Query:I have got admission to Mumbai Business School (www.mumbaibusinessschool.org).It promises assured placements.Could you please guide me whether this B School is worth taking up the risk? I would be quitting my job to join them.

Hmmm,

I feel like laughing at such comments ... dude if MBS will do any good to your frustrating career, I would be happy.

I would luv to meet you guys personally.Kindly let me know your contact numbers so that we can continue our personal fights outside this forum.

Roly,

People here are aware that it is a new business school. What you are saying is that nobody should join a new business school, which is a pretty paradoxical statement.

You've stated your point enough times in this thread now. Whoever wanted to pay heed to it would already have or not. Leave it upto them. Let's move on in life now.

Cheers,
Apurv

Roly now you are going berserk....Boss mind your words before saying anything without any kind of knowledge...You cannot say some ones career as frustrated one..I do not want to indulge in this but your post provokes so...I think you should stop writing on this post or other wise official complain needs to be raised against you...We are not against challenging against MBS....but your talks are baseless and do not add anything useful......

Roly you are no one to comment any thing against MBS...that also in front of MBsians....Please excuse us and do mind your own business now....We know who we are ...and what we are joining..

So please stop giving your expert comments...please keep it to your self

Hi Guys,
Just spoke to IMS.They have told me that for a fresher this would be a good B School.Not recommended for experienced guys.

Call IMS for more info

Hey Roly
I am a silent visitor of this thread....
Roly u can not get personal Man..
do not be a spoiling spirit
guys its not the forum to fight like cats n dogs...
we expect a healthy discussion n that's it
so guys chilllll

Hi Sneha,
You should not be a silent visitor :-)

Raise questions like i do.

Not everybody on this forum will speak good about an institute. Peole speak out and that is what is required.If you only talk goody goody, you will get only silent visitor's.The moment someone talks negative, people pounce on him.I am keeping this thread active and lively.Hope you will agree to it.

When the first batch gets out, then we can shower praises on MBS.Be assured if the placements are fantastic then i would be the first person to praise this institute.

So join the party...

Cheers

Roly now you are going berserk....Boss mind your words before saying anything without any kind of knowledge...You cannot say some ones career as frustrated one..I do not want to indulge in this but your post provokes so...I think you should stop writing on this post or other wise official complain needs to be raised against you...We are not against challenging against MBS....but your talks are baseless and do not add anything useful......

Roly you are no one to comment any thing against MBS...that also in front of MBsians....Please excuse us and do mind your own business now....We know who we are ...and what we are joining..

So please stop giving your expert comments...please keep it to your self

Guys,

I commented because someone has challenged me on this forum to get personal.You should refer to his thread first and then comment on mine dude.

Ask your current employer whether he has even heard of this B School and what does he think about its future.Ask a B School Coaching Institute what they think about it.

I have written to one of the top B School Coaching Institute asking for their advice on your B School .I should get the reply soon. Will post it once received.Then we can continue our discussions...


Let us get back on track and not get personal.It will do no good to anyone of us.

Kindly note:
I believe in doing complete research my dear friends.Will get my understanding certified and endorsed by an Educational Specialist .Wait with bathed breadth for the my next post....

Any news of MBS applying for any of the accreditations from organizations like EQUIS/AMBA/AACSB etc.

Cheers...

Friends who have accepted the admission offer , can you place shed some light on the placement assistance being provided by the institute ?

Hmmm,

I feel like laughing at such comments ... dude if MBS will do any good to your frustrating career, I would be happy.

I would luv to meet you guys personally.Kindly let me know your contact numbers so that we can continue our personal fights outside this forum.

Roly now you are going berserk....Boss mind your words before saying anything without any kind of knowledge...You cannot say some ones career as frustrated one..I do not want to indulge in this but your post provokes so...I think you should stop writing on this post or other wise official complain needs to be raised against you...We are not against challenging against MBS....but your talks are baseless and do not add anything useful......

Roly you are no one to comment any thing against MBS...that also in front of MBsians....Please excuse us and do mind your own business now....We know who we are ...and what we are joining..

So please stop giving your expert comments...please keep it to your self

Be my guest.. have my contact details on my profile... Get in touch, you'll know who has a better job and who's frustrated.. Better we do it in person than on this forum..

Grow Up Roly!!!! Since your first post on this thread.. you've kept on saying same thing over and over again.. If you do not have anything else to say or to quote.. better stop posting.. makes no sense repeating the same thing over and over again.. with different choice of words.. and stop fighting like cats and dogs.. More you do this, more it show your immaturity over ways to convince people to what you think and please stop being our Gurdian when you are not. If you are a risk analyst, then you better concentrate on that and if you do not wish to join MBS or feel that you can not afford to take such a risk or how so ever you want to put it, then buzz off.. or else come up with a different comment/argument all together. I believe all of us are tired of reading the same stuff over and over again. You've kept your point/opinion, end of the story, why are you being so rigid if we do not want to consider it. We'r grown enough and can very well take care of ourselves.. Remember, One can learn only from the mistakes he/she makes in his life. We fall or rise, our destiny. It's always better to regret on the decisions you've made (if you goof up), instead, regreting on the decision someone else would have imposed. You're not our mentor so don't try be one. It's an open forum where people share there views, but this does not mean, you'll want people to accept whatever you say.
So, would request you not to start over with I'm not being personal shit again. Would be rather glad if you would come up with a different argument all together.


PS- I'm Getting Personal

Frustated guy from Baroda wants to add another feather in his cap.

MBA from MBS.

Haa haa ha...

Testing karenga tu even after MBA

Grow Up Roly!!!! Since your first post on this thread.. you've kept on saying same thing over and over again.. If you do not have anything else to say or to quote.. better stop posting.. makes no sense repeating the same thing over and over again.. with different choice of words.. and stop fighting like cats and dogs.. More you do this, more it show your immaturity over ways to convince people to what you think and please stop being our Gurdian when you are not. If you are a risk analyst, then you better concentrate on that and if you do not wish to join MBS or feel that you can not afford to take such a risk or how so ever you want to put it, then buzz off.. or else come up with a different comment/argument all together. I believe all of us are tired of reading the same stuff over and over again. You've kept your point/opinion, end of the story, why are you being so rigid if we do not want to consider it. We'r grown enough and can very well take care of ourselves.. Remember, One can learn only from the mistakes he/she makes in his life. We fall or rise, our destiny. It's always better to regret on the decisions you've made (if you goof up), instead, regreting on the decision someone else would have imposed. You're not our mentor so don't try be one. It's an open forum where people share there views, but this does not mean, you'll want people to accept whatever you say.
So, would request you not to start over with I'm not being personal shit again. Would be rather glad if you would come up with a different argument all together.


PS- I'm Getting Personal

Hmmm,

I feel like laughing at such comments ... dude if MBS will do any good to your frustrating career, I would be happy.

I would luv to meet you guys personally.Kindly let me know your contact numbers so that we can continue our personal fights outside this forum.

Roly - you are saying the same thing again and again... You claim not to get personal but each post of yours aims at doing on thing - criticizing... the school - especially its placement... I dont think you got what I said on my 2 previous posts, if you had read them carefully... If you are the best, and you bank on yourself, you shouldnt worry about placements at MBS... You keep repeating the same thing structured in a different way all together...
Dont know if you have the confidence in yourself to make it big - guess you are one in the crowd looking out for a B school that would do the work for you rather than doing it yourself...Please dont beat around the bush again and again... it s a humble request... You have put forth your views... Dont push on it.... Thanks....

HI Ninad, Sanki
I have sent you guys a pm with my mail id details.
Lets see if we can chat there ...

Cheers..

Hi friends,
Any idea of how many of us puys here, taking part in this thread have actually accepted admission to MBS . (I mean paid the initial deposit of INR 1 lakhs).
I am waiting for an interview call from MBS as well.. Would be great if you guys could help me by letting me know what to expect in the interview and what not ...
What type of essays etc. were asked to be written ...


Thanks in Advance
Saurabh

hi,
i think more than 25 students paid registration fees,
as per my experience, in interview they will ask abt ur education backgrnd, ur views abt managment studies, ut english communication all other general ques related to management.
in essay they will give topic on current issues, i have got abt economical crisis, & which is my favorite ancient say & y ?
regards,
ninad.

Hi friends,
Any idea of how many of us puys here, taking part in this thread have actually accepted admission to MBS . (I mean paid the initial deposit of INR 1 lakhs).
I am waiting for an interview call from MBS as well.. Would be great if you guys could help me by letting me know what to expect in the interview and what not ...
What type of essays etc. were asked to be written ...


Thanks in Advance

My Dear Friend,
When did I get personal???

I started out writing on this thread because i have seen ethusiatic guys like you struggling after doing an MBA from Set-Up B Schools...

At the end of the day, the best person who can ever guide you is the alumni of the school itself.Now since this being the first batch, you guys would be the alumni.I would like to see your comments when you get placed.Keep me in the loop dude

I read yesterdays Times of India (Mumbai Edition).It had an article on B Schools and the placement offer being for 2010.Hope something similar does not happen with you guys too.Even the best of B Schools in the World do not assure placements...

"Think before you Leap"

I have been in the most sought after industry for quite a long time now and have seen which B School Grads do good in their career and who struggle.Again, read the article that is there on the front page of Pagalguy ( which i attached in my previous thread)

Best of Luck to you and other aspirants of MBS.Hop this B School does not turn out to be a Turkey

Grow Up Roly!!!! Since your first post on this thread.. you've kept on saying same thing over and over again.. If you do not have anything else to say or to quote.. better stop posting.. makes no sense repeating the same thing over and over again.. with different choice of words.. and stop fighting like cats and dogs.. More you do this, more it show your immaturity over ways to convince people to what you think and please stop being our Gurdian when you are not. If you are a risk analyst, then you better concentrate on that and if you do not wish to join MBS or feel that you can not afford to take such a risk or how so ever you want to put it, then buzz off.. or else come up with a different comment/argument all together. I believe all of us are tired of reading the same stuff over and over again. You've kept your point/opinion, end of the story, why are you being so rigid if we do not want to consider it. We'r grown enough and can very well take care of ourselves.. Remember, One can learn only from the mistakes he/she makes in his life. We fall or rise, our destiny. It's always better to regret on the decisions you've made (if you goof up), instead, regreting on the decision someone else would have imposed. You're not our mentor so don't try be one. It's an open forum where people share there views, but this does not mean, you'll want people to accept whatever you say.
So, would request you not to start over with I'm not being personal shit again. Would be rather glad if you would come up with a different argument all together.


PS- I'm Getting Personal

HI

It is sad that we look at 8 lakhs just as an investment... I dont even know if returns are only placements for everyone...which anyways MBS is pretty confident about...I think we need to realise the value of education this is going to provide... the quality of teaching and faculty...and seeing the kind of exposure MBS provides - i think 8 lakhs is a fair amount.... I would request all to do all the ground work - before looking at 8 lakhs only as a figure...
It is completely normal to follow the normal though - "there are lot of money-making schools in the country today"... but again... ask yourself how much of groundwork you have done... I request you to do a complete research on the school, faculty, staff and teaching... to come to a justifiable conclusion...
And about the recession... i think if you are the best... you can survive anywhere... under any economic circumstances....

hi,
good one nikhil, well said.........
roly, still didint ans to ques. which i have asked her in my previous msgs
may be she didint have ans or she just want to argue & dont want proper logical discussion.
thanks for the support
regards,
ninad.

malay_shah Says

Hey hii guys...jst wanted to know hwz dis college in terms of placements??...n is it well recognized??...hw gd is dis college in terms of a specialization in finance...whr is it located in mumbai n hw old is dis college??...thnkx...

Malay @For more details on placement you can directly contact MBS ...2009 is first batch for college but people behind college are quite a experienced lot...

Faculty is also of world class so i assume specialization is finance would work out great...

This college is located in MALAD west....

For details please log in to

Mumbai Business School - MBS

Hi,
Is MBS still accepting applications for its 1 year MBA program ?
Any idea how many student have taken admission till now ?
Seems that the entries in the blog have not been updated since the past couple of weeks ...

Cheers..
Saurabh

Saurabh @ To my best of knowledge,MBS is still accepting application for 1 year MBA program..

Regarding student count, you may directly call up MBS and confirm it ....

hi,
i m not banking on new B-school. see, if i get call from established B-school, i don't have any probs in going there, i have that option opened for me, but I cant wait myself for yrs just sake for name, & tell me one thing clearly, that i have asked u before also, if everybody will wait for 1st batch out then how 1st batch will form.......?
& u r not the person who can say me that i m playing with career, i know that how i handled it till date & how to enhance it. i m not pointing out ur career in banks although i have manyt things to say.....! but this is not the place for personal fightings.....so dont comment on personal career, if u want to say something abt career then u can say but in a proper way to say....
regards,
ninad.

My Dear Friend,
When did I get personal???

I started out writing on this thread because i have seen ethusiatic guys like you struggling after doing an MBA from Set-Up B Schools...

At the end of the day, the best person who can ever guide you is the alumni of the school itself.Now since this being the first batch, you guys would be the alumni.I would like to see your comments when you get placed.Keep me in the loop dude

I read yesterdays Times of India (Mumbai Edition).It had an article on B Schools and the placement offer being for 2010.Hope something similar does not happen with you guys too.Even the best of B Schools in the World do not assure placements...

"Think before you Leap"

I have been in the most sought after industry for quite a long time now and have seen which B School Grads do good in their career and who struggle.Again, read the article that is there on the front page of Pagalguy ( which i attached in my previous thread)

Best of Luck to you and other aspirants of MBS.Hop this B School does not turn out to be a Turkey

Hi,
Is MBS still accepting applications for its 1 year MBA program ?
Any idea how many student have taken admission till now ?
Seems that the entries in the blog have not been updated since the past couple of weeks ...

Cheers..

HI

It is sad that we look at 8 lakhs just as an investment... I dont even know if returns are only placements for everyone...which anyways MBS is pretty confident about...I think we need to realise the value of education this is going to provide... the quality of teaching and faculty...and seeing the kind of exposure MBS provides - i think 8 lakhs is a fair amount.... I would request all to do all the ground work - before looking at 8 lakhs only as a figure...
It is completely normal to follow the normal though - "there are lot of money-making schools in the country today"... but again... ask yourself how much of groundwork you have done... I request you to do a complete research on the school, faculty, staff and teaching... to come to a justifiable conclusion...
And about the recession... i think if you are the best... you can survive anywhere... under any economic circumstances....

Dear Friend,
If you say you are aiming at returns going forward then why are you banking on a new B School? Go to an established B School which atleast has some name in the Industry.I guess there are better established players in the B School Market whom you could think of rather than an new B School as getting recognized after your MBA would be a BIG CHALLENGE....

You are playing with your career dude...

Hopefully you will get what you expect from MBS. I only want to guide people to make sensible decision cos i have seen people ruining their careers with a not recognised (By Employers) B School.

Had you taken this decision next year, I would have encouraged all to apply/ not apply depending on the first placements.

hi,
i m not banking on new B-school. see, if i get call from established B-school, i don't have any probs in going there, i have that option opened for me, but I cant wait myself for yrs just sake for name, & tell me one thing clearly, that i have asked u before also, if everybody will wait for 1st batch out then how 1st batch will form.......?
& u r not the person who can say me that i m playing with career, i know that how i handled it till date & how to enhance it. i m not pointing out ur career in banks although i have manyt things to say.....! but this is not the place for personal fightings.....so dont comment on personal career, if u want to say something abt career then u can say but in a proper way to say....
regards,
ninad.

dear roly,
i completely agree with you that MBS may not get packages like ISB or SP Jain, but it is stupidity of expecting it, specially in this recession period.
acc to u when you pay 8 lakhs u should get atleast 12 lakhs but in todays world but this formula is not applicable even for the established b-schools, so how can I expect for the new B-school, as you said there are many b schools opening every yr in india, even i have got offers from some these b-schools having less fees than MBS, but MBS i found better in every aspect,
now, one thing is sure that it is difficult to get 8 lakhs or more packeges, but as said MBA is investment therefore i m not expecting outcome from very 1st yr of investment, may be we'll get somewhat less packages from campus interview, but it will be not below average, it is not always necessory that ur fees (ie 8 lakhs in this case) should be recover in 1st yr only, it can be recover in 2 yrs also, & specially in this period nobody should expect recover of ur fees in very 1st job even for established b-schools,
so my dear frnd, i m very aware of todays situation, & i m taking calculated risk & not expecting something miracle....
regards,
ninad.

Dear Friend,
If you say you are aiming at returns going forward then why are you banking on a new B School? Go to an established B School which atleast has some name in the Industry.I guess there are better established players in the B School Market whom you could think of rather than an new B School as getting recognised after your MBA would be a BIG CHALLENGE....

You are playing with your career dude...

Hopefully you will get what you expect from MBS. I only want to guide people to make sensible decision cos i have seen people ruining their careers with a not recognised (By Employers) B School.

Had you taken this decision next year, I would have encouraged all to apply/ not apply depending on the first placements.

My Dear Friend,
I think you have not read my latest thread on MBS.Read it and you will understand what my threads actually mean.

I am discouraging people from joining a set up B School primarily because the Economy is in a very bad shape.Students are taking loans and defaulting.Global Credit Crunch also involves B Schools Grad defaulting. Top Tier B Schools Globally are struggling to place their students.In such circumstances, how will a new B School fare? Read this link about the best B School in India (Placement Season at ISB Hyderabad gets Extended Indefinitely | MBA Placements 2009 : IIMs, FMS, JBIMS, XLRI and other top B-Schools)

MBA is an Investment my dear friend so think twice before you leap.In India MBA has become a money making business and you find soo many B Schools setting up every year.

The timing of doing an MBA is bad.And what is even worse is that students are opting for new B Schools that are charging exhorbiant prices ...

You cannot gamble with your career my dear friend.

I would be very happy if MBS places all its students cos one of them is my very close friend.....

Don't expect huge pay packets.I know for sure that all those who have enrolled to MBS are dreaming about ISB packages.People would disagree about that on this forum but i know at the back of their mind they are thinking about ISB type of placements.Thinks realistic is what i can tell such students.ISB is in a different league all together.

dear roly,
i completely agree with you that MBS may not get packages like ISB or SP Jain, but it is stupidity of expecting it, specially in this recession period.
acc to u when you pay 8 lakhs u should get atleast 12 lakhs but in todays world but this formula is not applicable even for the established b-schools, so how can I expect for the new B-school, as you said there are many b schools opening every yr in india, even i have got offers from some these b-schools having less fees than MBS, but MBS i found better in every aspect,
now, one thing is sure that it is difficult to get 8 lakhs or more packeges, but as said MBA is investment therefore i m not expecting outcome from very 1st yr of investment, may be we'll get somewhat less packages from campus interview, but it will be not below average, it is not always necessory that ur fees (ie 8 lakhs in this case) should be recover in 1st yr only, it can be recover in 2 yrs also, & specially in this period nobody should expect recover of ur fees in very 1st job even for established b-schools,
so my dear frnd, i m very aware of todays situation, & i m taking calculated risk & not expecting something miracle....
regards,
ninad.

hey roly,
i have read all ur opnion abt MBS, what ever u r saying is okk at ur point of view but there is no need to say that "people will laugh at you when u'll say that u r from MBS", might be people like you will really laugh....anyway, in above msg u strongly belive that everyone should do his/her MBA from best b-school right ? now tell me one thing how did u judge the best b-school, offcourse acc to their previous placements records okk? now every best b-school in todays date was best from day one of its begining.........? the answer is "No" but they become best after so many batches.....have you ever mate anybody from the 1st batch of SP Jain or Welingkar's ? I mate to both of them. see, No b-school is perfect at its 1st yr, we'll have to make them perfect by our performance, the only good thing the b-school should give u at very 1st yr excellent faculty & very hard try to invite companies for an interview, & MBS will do it that is for sure.....(as they have very big experienced people)
if MBS would have very less experience people like only 3 to 4 yrs then ur what ever u were saying is somewhat correct, but its not like that.
if everybody will think like u then there will no 1st batch to any so called best b-school, when SP JAIN was started No star name was connected with them, but now anybody from SP Jain is a star in management.
there were a time, only IIM is a big name in india for management, then why did people went to other b-schools also....?
have you taken ur "UG" from best college in india ? if yes, i m very eager to know from which institute & what degree u have ? if No, then i dont have any probs bcoz u r still surviving na...? in investment bank
my many frnds are waiting for 3 to 4 yrs for best b-school, they leaved many good schools just for some perception,
& you dont worry abt people laugh....smart employer will recognize smart employee...
No hard feelings for you just wanna say that u may get what u want but if u r not getting it try for some new & make it as u want....
all the best !

My Dear Friend,
I think you have not read my latest thread on MBS.Read it and you will understand what my threads actually mean.

I am discouraging people from joining a set up B School primarily because the Economy is in a very bad shape.Students are taking loans and defaulting.Global Credit Crunch also involves B Schools Grad defaulting. Top Tier B Schools Globally are struggling to place their students.In such circumstances, how will a new B School fare? Read this link about the best B School in India (Placement Season at ISB Hyderabad gets Extended Indefinitely | MBA Placements 2009 : IIMs, FMS, JBIMS, XLRI and other top B-Schools)

MBA is an Investment my dear friend so think twice before you leap.In India MBA has become a money making business and you find soo many B Schools setting up every year.

The timing of doing an MBA is bad.And what is even worse is that students are opting for new B Schools that are charging exhorbiant prices ...

You cannot gamble with your career my dear friend.

I would be very happy if MBS places all its students cos one of them is my very close friend.....

Don't expect huge pay packets.I know for sure that all those who have enrolled to MBS are dreaming about ISB packages.People would disagree about that on this forum but i know at the back of their mind they are thinking about ISB type of placements.Thinks realistic is what i can tell such students.ISB is in a different league all together.

My Dear Friend,
First thing, Failure in MBA is not accepted.
Secondly, no job is safe.Infact the industry that i work in is the most unsafe place.
Thirdly,I got admission to MBS without any scores.I have never given GMAT,CAT or any other entrance exam.
And lastly, I intend to get into the most competitive B School.I would be appearing for my GMAT this year and apply to B School for 2010/2011 intake.I am willing to wait and take my best decision.You cannot change your decision once you are in:-)

I strongly believe that everyone should do his MBA from the Best B School.Study hard for the competitive exams and get into the top league.Nothing is impossible my friend.

hey roly,
i have read all ur opnion abt MBS, what ever u r saying is okk at ur point of view but there is no need to say that "people will laugh at you when u'll say that u r from MBS", might be people like you will really laugh....anyway, in above msg u strongly belive that everyone should do his/her MBA from best b-school right ? now tell me one thing how did u judge the best b-school, offcourse acc to their previous placements records okk? now every best b-school in todays date was best from day one of its begining.........? the answer is "No" but they become best after so many batches.....have you ever mate anybody from the 1st batch of SP Jain or Welingkar's ? I mate to both of them. see, No b-school is perfect at its 1st yr, we'll have to make them perfect by our performance, the only good thing the b-school should give u at very 1st yr excellent faculty & very hard try to invite companies for an interview, & MBS will do it that is for sure.....(as they have very big experienced people)
if MBS would have very less experience people like only 3 to 4 yrs then ur what ever u were saying is somewhat correct, but its not like that.
if everybody will think like u then there will no 1st batch to any so called best b-school, when SP JAIN was started No star name was connected with them, but now anybody from SP Jain is a star in management.
there were a time, only IIM is a big name in india for management, then why did people went to other b-schools also....?
have you taken ur "UG" from best college in india ? if yes, i m very eager to know from which institute & what degree u have ? if No, then i dont have any probs bcoz u r still surviving na...? in investment bank
my many frnds are waiting for 3 to 4 yrs for best b-school, they leaved many good schools just for some perception,
& you dont worry abt people laugh....smart employer will recognize smart employee...
No hard feelings for you just wanna say that u may get what u want but if u r not getting it try for some new & make it as u want....
all the best !

"I claim authority in declaring MBS a total failure even before it starts its first term this year. (It will be a success as far as the internal business plan is concerned. It will be a total failure as far as career advancement of students is concerned) If MBS manages to place a single student with less than 2 years of workex prior to joining the program with a net take home salary of greater than 12 lakhs per annum in the next 3 years, I will refund the fees paid by the student to MBS!

Thats a challenge from me to MBS - Prove it! (I bet you can't)"Hi there,

Well even i have my doubts about the success of a college in its very 1st yr.
But i strongly feel that the above comments will only discourage people from joining the college. There are 100s of MBA colleges in India. All of them cant reach the level of IIMs, ISB or other premier B-schools like FMS, MDI, SPJ, NITIE,XLRI etc. Does this mean that people should not do MBA from them? If that is the case then India will be producing less than 3000 MBAs every year. Will that be sufficient for a country of over 1 bn population?
I strongly discourage such kind of comments for any college...no matter whether the comments are from the no 1 expert of the field.
MBS is a new college. May be it will grow and reach the levels of IIMs in time. If everybody starts thinking negative about the college then i believe new start up colleges will never be able to take off!!!
India is such a vast country that it has got oppurtunities for everyone. If everybody starts thinking like reachnagraj then there wont be any successful IPOs (in share markets) in our country, Venture Capitalists will not fund the new start ups, customers wont try new products!!! Only a few mighty will dictate the rules of the game. If people would have thought on the same lines about ISB 8 yrs back then i am sure today ISB wont have been there where it is today. In fact a new college like ISB changed the rules of the game and posed a serious challenge to top Indian B-schools. ISB did it with an unconventional model of 1 yr MBA (unconventional in India at that time).

So i urge you not to challenge anybody's capabilities and intentions. Let the college evolve and establish itself.

Always remember the golden rule which you must have learnt/will learn in your MBA...higher the risk higher the returns!!!

Thanks
Himanshu

PS: i hope you will take everything in good spirit...absolutely no intentions to hurt anyone :)

I found this interesting article on the front page of pagalguy.All you guys who are going in for Financed MBA, please pay attention to this article.Those who have not taken any finance, still pay ears to this article-

Is this a good time to take up an educational loan?
By Yogesh Chabria
Published: March 23, 2009
Print Email

In the current financial crisis, a six-month work experience will teach you much more than a two-year MBA ever will, argues well-known investor and Guest Writer Yogesh Chabria. According to him, there's no predicting how the economy will turn out in the next two years, and the educational loan you signed up for might just turn out to be a big mistake.

One of the main reasons the global financial crisis took place was because of excessive debt/loans taken by people in America. Just recently I met someone who had completed his MBA.

This person had recently started working in USA after completing his MBA there. Everything seemed excellent; he had a fancy foreign MBA degree, an expensive car and a high paying job. He was living the American dream and spending quite well, since he has a big fat salary. However one fine day everything changed he lost his high paying finance job and had to return to India. He had to return his car which was purchased on EMI.

He had spent around USD 150,000 overall to complete his MBA and living expenses and like several other people he had taken a loan. But now the main problem he has is that in India, it is very difficult for him to repay such a large amount of loan.

His father was his guarantor and now the entire family has a lot of stress, thinking how they will repay such a large loan. He has still not been able to find a job here and even if he does find a job, he would be paid much less here as compared to America. Today he and his family are under a lot of stress and are hoping they find a solution. If the bank doesnt get their money back, they will go behind the guarantors assets, in his case his father will have to somehow arrange those funds.

Even though an MBA in India is cheaper than international ones, it does cost a couple of lakhs. Im sure many of you might be thinking of taking a loan and doing an MBA in India, but before you blindly take a loan, think about the job market and if it really makes sense to take a loan.

Most MBA salaries quoted by institutions are exaggerated. An average MBA graduate can be hired for Rs. 2.5 - Rs. 3 lakhs a year. Visit any regular MBA college and ask the final year students about placements and average salaries, they will tell you the reality. Salaries quoted and the cash actually received in hand is also very different. Quite a sizeable position of salaries are kept variable and performance based, specially in times like now employers get the opportunity to bargain even more. There are colleges, where placements are barely 20%-30% and most students are trying to find jobs on their own or are becoming entrepreneurs.

My simple advice would be to not take a loan today and work for one or two years, to gain valuable work experience and also build earn some money that will be able to fund your own education. Academics and the real world are very different, what can be learnt within six months of working can never be learnt throughout an MBA course.

MBA courses all over the world are considered to be at par with PHDs and LLMs, however in India lately it seems an MBA course has become as common as a regular graduation. This means a huge oversupply of MBA grads and that pushes salaries downward.

Having the funds and then spending it on an MBA, will give you and your family peace of mind after graduating. Working will also give you the necessary confidence and skills needed to make the most of your MBA degree.

Fresh graduates might also not realize that an MBA degree isnt just about lectures and PPT presentation. One of the most important things in business are people and contacts. For instance I remember one of my friends who was in his early 30s joining LBS (London Business School) for creating new business and professional contacts, as he would be getting the opportunity to interact with a lot of influential people.

I can understand how a lot of fresh graduates might be very eager to take an educational loan and immediately join an MBA degree. However dont get carried away by the hype and invest money and two years of your life, speak to people who have completed their MBA degree. They will be able to help you understand the realities much better. Today thanks to the internet and web forums like PagalGuy.com here, it becomes even easier for aspiring MBAs to interact with seniors and people who have already completed their MBA.

A college prospectus is not the best way you can find out more about the college you want to study in, but a simple talk with an ex-student is.

Im sure that there will be quite a few people who might not fully agree with what I am saying and might put forward a few arguments. I have heard quite a few people telling me that since the job market is bad now, it makes sense to go and do an MBA and be comfortable in a B-school. By the end of two years, everything should be all right and back to normal.

But firstly, how do we know everything is going to be better by the end of two years? What if things are worse than they are today? If the bubble took so many decades to be created, it is quite likely that it will take several years for the bubble to deflate. I agree that today finding a job might be more challenging, however anyone who starts working today will put in his/her best to make sure costs are minimized and efficiency is increased. The real world experience that can be gained from this rare incident will surely teach a lot of new things and will make you stronger. Personally what I am learning in the world of investing is extremely exciting and I thank my stars to have given me this opportunity.

In fact today the economy needs people who are creative and can come up with new solutions. If you are someone who can reduce costs even by 10% because of your skills and knowledge, you will be handsomely rewarded. Companies are more open to new creative ideas when times are challenging as they are desperately looking for new solutions.

An MBA shouldnt be used as something that can help you escape from the challenges of the real world, but instead should be used as something that will give you valuable skills. Education and knowledge are definitely an asset, but ask yourself if an MBA degree is the only way you learn new things?

To move ahead in life, you dont necessarily need to follow what everybody around you is doing, but instead listen to your own heart. What might seem right today, might not necessarily be right tomorrow. Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns were filled with the best PHDs and MBAs of the world, and we all know what happened to them and on the other hand Dhirubhai Ambani worked as a petrol pump attendant.

Today I know of MBAs who are working in call centres and are extremely frustrated with life. They had a different image in their mind about how life would be after an MBA. It really might not be worth spending several lakhs on an institute which isnt going to help you gain new skills. I hope more people realize this and dont look at an MBA degree to a guaranteed way to success and riches. Have an open mind and spend some time in learning more!

Yogesh Chabria is an investor and bestselling author of Invest The Happionaire Way. In his next book published by CNBC-TV18 and titled 'Happionaires Cash The Crash', he shares little known secrets on how to make the most of the crash. You can find out more about him by visiting The Happionaire Way- Investing, Indian Stock Markets, Wealth Creation!.

Hey hii guys...jst wanted to know hwz dis college in terms of placements??...n is it well recognized??...hw gd is dis college in terms of a specialization in finance...whr is it located in mumbai n hw old is dis college??...thnkx...

Guys chk this out..

MBS US faculty - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0o22lxHNpdc&feature;=related

MBS Board - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cflEiAFuPFU&feature;=related

CEO Futurebrands Mr. Santosh Desai - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ly3VxNb0Ck&feature;=related

MBS Placement - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YaLbdQv_UQc


From the CEO Mumbai Business School - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iGlwbE5pbME&feature;=related

"On a parting note, I will just mention that if somebody really had the 'vision', 'self-belief' and 'substance', s/he would not even have bothered to 'react' to an 'ordinary' opinion. Actions speak louder than words and yes I still remain 'opinionated' on this subject (my ordinary English proficiency does not allow me to say 'matter')"

That is funny....in one post (to which I replied), u claim that u r an experienced professional and now suddenly u classify ur expert claims as ordinary!

My friend....no one is ordinary in this world...life is not just about MBS, IIMA, ISB or Harvard.

All my point was , if u have genuine reasons for critisizing a school/authority..please go ahead...people are all ears.

But dont hurt someone's feelings just for the heck of it.

Nd there is no question of 'vision', 'self-belief' and 'substance' here.

Anywazs...gud luck!

Guys,
I just cant hold myself back any longer.This forum is getting heated and beaten...

The only point of contention with MBS is that it is still not established.Someone in the earlier thread commented"Higher the Risk, Higher the reward".I am absolutely sure this guy does not know the ABC of Finance.Otherwise such ridiculous remark would not have come from him.

In these uncertain times, students are thinking twice before going for MBA even to prestigious institutions like Ivy League, LSE, LBS, IIM's and ISB.

Let us be frank about this.The only reason why people do an MBA is for a higher salary.Position and change of location comes secondary.People obviously look for a higher return.If you are spending 8 lacs on an MBA, you would certainly be thinking that i should get placed for atleast 10-12 lacs per annum.This is where the catch lies... Economy is in shatters my dear friend and it will take atleast 2 more years to stabilise.Do your MBA when the economy is good so that atleast you know at the back of your mind that you will get placed well atleast through networking.In these markets, even if someone gets placed for 5 lacs will be a huge bonus....

Take calculated risks my friends and do not run in trouble after your MBA.

All the Best and i would like to see Nagraj to continue writing.He has added a distinct flavour to this forum now.As i mentioned earlier, there should be all sorts of discussions happening on this forum.People are sensible enough to make their judgment:-)

Lastly, guys go for advanced certifications.Leverage your profile.Make yourself more competitive.

"On a parting note, I will just mention that if somebody really had the 'vision', 'self-belief' and 'substance', s/he would not even have bothered to 'react' to an 'ordinary' opinion. Actions speak louder than words and yes I still remain 'opinionated' on this subject (my ordinary English proficiency does not allow me to say 'matter')"

That is funny....in one post (to which I replied), u claim that u r an experienced professional and now suddenly u classify ur expert claims as ordinary!

My friend....no one is ordinary in this world...life is not just about MBS, IIMA, ISB or Harvard.

All my point was , if u have genuine reasons for critisizing a school/authority..please go ahead...people are all ears.

But dont hurt someone's feelings just for the heck of it.

Nd there is no question of 'vision', 'self-belief' and 'substance' here.

Anywazs...gud luck!

'Could you please come out in the open challenge accepted please email us your Name and details and we will take it further, just for my information could you also attach your highly esteemed profile, work ex and take home'

Feel free to PM me for the challenge and other details.

may be you would need our MBA!
Thanks but no thanks - I don't need your MBA

Listen to yourself your views couldnt be more ordinary. Even a pan-waala can pass comments on how to run the country but does anyone take his words seriously.

Fully agree. My opinion probably is as ordinary as the lowest end of the spectrum. A good number of MBAs from sub-optimal business schools are out there selling insurance policies, credit cards, soaps and detergents and probably pan ;)

Well, thats exactly why we need a Bschool like MBS. The very intention is to create diamonds for the industry.
If you were to meet any of the students of the first batch, you will observe-
1. Ability to see a vision and believe in it
Fully agree with you on this point
2. Risk-taking ability the quality that separates any successful person from the herd
Provided the risks are calculated. 'Fools rush in where angels fear to tread'
3. Self Belief and substance
Absolutely. 'Substance' matters the most. If one has the substance, the self-belief will sink in very naturally

Well just to clear the air a bit guys, I agree that my views are as ordinary as they can be. My opinions may be as biased as they can be. I recognize that my harsh words have ruffled quite a few feathers around; I apologize for that.

I may not have a fantastic IQ or EQ or SQ or any other Qs that one can think of. As I have maintained in my previous postings on this thread as well, I wish all the students who have decided to go ahead with MBS the very best of luck in their careers and lives. I will not be posting further on this thread.

On a parting note, I will just mention that if somebody really had the 'vision', 'self-belief' and 'substance', s/he would not even have bothered to 'react' to an 'ordinary' opinion. Actions speak louder than words and yes I still remain 'opinionated' on this subject (my ordinary English proficiency does not allow me to say 'matter')

Cheers Puys...

nutty @ very well said