Kellogg and Rotman do not qualify as case based MBA schools. Yes, they involve the case study method ( 25 % for Rotman, 30% for Kellogg) but they do not use the case based methodology primarily or exclusively. I would categorize Rotman and Kellogg as having a balanced methodology. Almost every school uses case based method to an extent.
In my opinion there are only four schools which primarily or exclusively use the case study methodology and these are:

Harvard Business School
Darden
Richard Ivey
IESE

I agree with you, Kellogg and Rotman are not full-flashed case method programs.

Kellogg and Rotman do not qualify as case based MBA schools. Yes, they involve the case study method ( 25 % for Rotman, 30% for Kellogg) but they do not use the case based methodology primarily or exclusively. I would categorize Rotman and Kellogg as having a balanced methodology. Almost every school uses case based method to an extent.
In my opinion there are only four schools which primarily or exclusively use the case study methodology and these are:

Harvard Business School
Darden
Richard Ivey
IESE

As far as I remember, the programs that rely very heavily on case-study method are:

1. Darden
   
2. HBS
   
3. IESE
   
4. Rotman
   

I'm not sure about the application of case-study method in finance/accounting, but when I applied, I tried connecting with a few students at Darden and everyone of them strongly felt that it works well. (Google out Anand's blog, I think he wrote sth about it a year back.)

Kellogg's teaching method is

30% - Case Study
30% - Team Projects
30% - Lecture
10% - Experimental Learning & Simulations

Source: Website

You may add IESE Business School in Spain. It follows case based method of study too. How would you rate the various case method based MBA programs?

Nishant,

I disagree with what you are saying on both those points -

a) every individual has something to contribute to the class, maybe not to every single case - but he/she will. If you are good enough to make a school like Darden chances are you will be able to contribute. !

Of what i have interacted with students,Darden demands a lot from you to bring to class. So speaking for avg Indian IT fellow, that may not be easy to do

b) Regarding accounting/finance classes: I am a Non-Finance person who is being trained on financial concepts by my current manager - and every single time he tells me about a new financial ration my immediate question is - what is the business implication of this formula? We can all use excel/google to calculate formulae but what we need to understand is the real life applications behind them. And this is especially true of a non-finance person!

That was strictly my opinion. Maybe case teaches finance very well in realistic sense but then i always had this notion that you need lecture and book to do quantitative stuff. Though Case can be excellent methodology.As i have not got an opportunity to do case based study of subjects,maybe i may not be 100% right but i'm sure i'm atleast 60% right

You may ant to add Darden to the list
Case method suits the person who has a good amt of exp to share. You cannot expect to gain from others exp with minimum contribution to case. Case is all about giving and taking. So if one feels comfortable with it.Case is the best method.
IMO case is not as well suited for finance/accounting related courses.If your major interest is finance..case may not be that good especially if you come from non finance background

Nishant,

I disagree with what you are saying on both those points -

a) every individual has something to contribute to the class, maybe not to every single case - but he/she will. If you are good enough to make a school like Darden chances are you will be able to contribute.

b) Regarding accounting/finance classes: I am a Non-Finance person who is being trained on financial concepts by my current manager - and every single time he tells me about a new financial ration my immediate question is - what is the business implication of this formula? We can all use excel/google to calculate formulae but what we need to understand is the real life applications behind them. And this is especially true of a non-finance person!

You may ant to add Darden to the list
Case method suits the person who has a good amt of exp to share. You cannot expect to gain from others exp with minimum contribution to case. Case is all about giving and taking. So if one feels comfortable with it.Case is the best method.
IMO case is not as well suited for finance/accounting related courses.If your major interest is finance..case may not be that good especially if you come from non finance background